5 ms·
That's just not how digital ad campaigns are run. Advertisers, agencies, media buyers and the rest of the supply chain don't negotiate with individual sites lik
by manigandham 7y ago
That's just not how digital ad campaigns are run. Advertisers, agencies, media buyers and the rest of the supply chain don't negotiate with individual sites like that, not at any scale that can sustain a site like SO.
- scarface74 7y agoStack Overflow has a known demographic and is not some unknown site. Are you really saying that companies like Amazon (AWS),Microsoft, JetBrains, Google (GCP), Slack, etc would ignore a sales pitch from SO?
- manigandham 7y agoIt doesn't work like that is what I'm saying. You dont just pitch those companies. They have layers of agencies (a master agency of record, creative agencies, media buying agencies) that handle all the advertising duties. These shops create and traffic these ad campaigns in demand-side platforms (DSPs) which connect and bid on inventory in adexchanges and supply-side platforms (SSPs). Then there's layers of targeting, accountability, measurement, and insurance that gets requested and bought from anti-fraud, brand-safety and verification vendors. That's likely where this fingerprinting came script came from. Going to individual agencies with your own different supply path is not going to get any attention and nobody is going to change the way they buy millions in advertising just for you. No single publisher has that much power these days, not even Stackoverflow.
- xkcd-sucks 7y agoof course you pitch this way. you hire an inside sales guy who has personal relationships with c-level execs, and those execs make it happen because they're personally invested.
- scarface74 7y agoIt amazes me that people act like Enterprise sales isn’t a thing.
- manigandham 7y agoAdvertising isn't enterprise sales.
- scarface74 7y agoThat’s just the point - why not? What different strategy would you use selling a SAAS app to a few whales than selling advertising to a few whales?
- manigandham 7y agoMost ad money is in walled gardens (Facebook running ads on facebook.com). SMBs and performance marketers buy billions without ever talking to a salesperson. Advertising at big companies is the only space left for traditional sales teams and it's all outsourced to agencies. Adtech vendors and publishers sell to these agencies, not the client (and if they do, its just redirected) but there aren't any long-term deals because everything is constantly shifting. Agencies have lots of teams, they win and lose accounts, work on multiple campaign initiatives and strategies with constantly changing budgets and requirements, and use dozens of vendors to create and execute campaigns. This is the opposite of a traditional SaaS contract sold for a term directly to the people that will be using it. There's also a steady trend towards all inventory being traded programmatically which will eliminate most of the sales negotiations. Unique inventory and formats can still stand out but they also cost more in effort and money so there's less overall demand. It's very hard to scale custom sales like that, especially if one of your requirements is to avoid all the javascript verification, brand-safety and measurement. Most media sales these days is more about biz dev to get the pipes connected to exchanges and represent your inventory in the best way possible while letting the market work.
- manigandham 7y agoMake what happen exactly? C-level execs do not run ad campaigns. At most they'll defer to the CMO, who then just tells you to talk to their agency. There are private marketplaces and other deals you can work out with agencies but this is usually for inventory against existing campaign RFPs, and comes with all of the typical creative requirements. They're not going to run an entirely custom campaign under your own terms and restrictions, not at any sustainable scale.
- qroshan 7y agoThanks for your insights here dude. It is wasted on HN crowd though, who are mostly clueless about business and have pre-conceived notions and hate about everything. Any books / blog posts that you recommend. You should write a book :)
- scarface74 7y agoYes because all business is based on ad sales....
- huac 7y agowell, facebook and google have that much power (at least wrt the many 3rd party layers), but literally nobody else does :)
- wool_gather 7y agoNo. They already do this. This is how ads have been run on SO forever. The new ad network ads that they've started with are an aberration from SO's own established practice.
- manigandham 7y agoNo they don't. They use their own adserver (bought from adzerk) to physically serve the ads, but they have always come through RTB connections to ad exchanges. There are private marketplaces and "automated guaranteed" deals to isolate their inventory in its representation and pricing from the rest of the market but the actual campaigns they get exposure to, and the creatives delivered, aren't special to them.
- ceejayoz 7y agoI've seen plenty of SO-specific ad campaigns being run on the site.
- manigandham 7y agoThey run house-ads for their own jobs board and products, and they will have private marketplaces inside the exchanges, but those campaigns and creatives will still go through the standard adtech supply chain with all the JS-based layers added on. https://www.stackoverflowbusiness.com/advertising https://www.stackoverflowbusiness.com/advertising They do sell job postings and have sponsored tags so it's not all network ad revenue, but that's a minority of the income. Since they released their Q/A SaaS product now, maybe they’ll shift to selling that as the primary revenue stream.
- NikolaNovak 7y agoI thought Penny Arcade does bespoke ads. Rock Paper Shotgun used to do bespoke ads. I always found them million times more effective, and more trust-inspiring of both ad AND site, to me. Is SO smaller business? Possible... just surprised.
- manigandham 7y agoThose sites are far smaller than Stackoverflow. Bespoke campaigns don't always pay more, and usually mean less total revenue for the site if that's all they run.
- scarface74 7y agoTell that to John Gruber over at DaringFireball - He makes $6500 a week just from posting one ad in the RSS feed. If he can gross over $300K a year on a niche Apple blog without a sales team, can you imagine what a sales team could do at SO? He also sells three ad spots on his mostly weekly podcast for $6000 each. He’s a one man business grossing over 1 million a year without a sales team.
- manigandham 7y agoI don't need to imagine, I've been in adtech for 12 years and built companies and sales teams. DaringFireball is 1 example of an extremely tiny minority that can earn that today after building up an audience and reputation for decades. It doesn't just scale up linearly and getting to $10M is magnitudes more work, especially if they're going to place their own requirements on campaigns and creatives. Even buzzfeed went back to programmatic ads with layoffs because their custom articles didn't sustain the business.
- jakobegger 7y ago> He’s a one man business grossing over 1 million a year without a sales team 1) He has a sales person that sells ads on his podcast: http://neat.fm http://neat.fm 2) Extrapolating from published rates is not very reliable. Nobody except John Gruber and his accountant knows how many sponsors really pay the sticker price.
- csdreamer7 7y agoYoutubers run ads and sponsorships in their videos all the time (not the automated ads from Adsense). Squarespace, Dollar Shave Club, Ting, PIA; they all directly pay Youtubers to run ads. Youtube even had to block Youtubers from using brand's logos outside their ad network in videos.
- manigandham 7y agoThere are a million channels for every one that gets any sponsorship, and there's an equivalent ratio for the pricing of these ads. The CPMs on sponsored content are usually lower than network CPMs until you cross over to the very popular channels, but even then it's really just shifting the production costs of a video ad to the youtuber and paying some premium for their reputation. It's very hard to scale and again there are networks and agencies that aggregate channels for most campaigns and buyers. Anyway, Stackoverflow isn't producing their own content and the pricing mechanics of Youtube/video advertising is very different than display ads so this isn't really comparable.
- thirdsun 7y ago> That's just not how digital ad campaigns are run. At that point I'd expect sites like Stack Overflow to point out that they have a specific of way of running their sites as well - and that shouldn't include having ads execute arbitary javascript. While those requirements would certainly exclude a significant number of ad agencies, I can't imagine that there aren't enough advertisers left that would happily play by Stack Overflow's rules to reach a rather large and specific target audience with (likely) disposable income.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- wastedhours 7y ago> That's just not how digital ad campaigns are run I appreciate you trying to fight the argument that's being made, and you have a background for a valid opinion people are dismissing. That being said, I'm on the buying end and work a lot of different channels, and would argue that there are definitely direct buy models that SO could utilise. Lots of smaller sites have started offering direct buy inventory in larger quantities recently, and pretty much every media package I've bought this year has had some internally served display with it. I'd expect this to work its way upwards, and would fully expect something self serve to come soon for internal buys. Also, SO seems prime for a self-serve product akin to AdWords, Reddit, or even Facebook. We already buy on those channels (even though through an agency, the agency is just buying self-serve on their end - and they put their insurance, tracking and ASBOF & TI on the cost). That's be a really cool project actually, self-serve ad platform for a forum/knowledge base.
- manigandham 7y agoI'm curious how you're buying these packages? Is this traded directly with the site instead of a DSP? Also it seems like you're in the UK, is that right? Aren't the privacy laws having a major effect on the programmatic market there? I covered it in other comments but yes, SO could start their own self-serve ads like Reddit (since they both use adzerk). The problem with that ends up being lower quality ads and the inevitable support costs, and the fact that they don't have unique formats other than banners. Reddit, Quora, Pinterest, and others have custom formats but it's definitely something they can pursue.
- shostack 7y agoIn your opinion, what are the main factors or thresholds (impression volume, RPM, etc) where a self-serve solution starts to make sense for a publisher? Ie. what framework would you use to determine viability? Separately, in your opinion, what sort of stack should a publisher consider if they want to be privacy-friendly? Obviously if certain values are left out of the bid request, fill RPMs will suffer, but that may be acceptable for some publishers as the cost of striking a better balance between privacy and ad revenue. I realize there's a lot to unpack, but feel free to get technical with me, I'm on both the buy and sell side.