6 ms·
Wish I could upvote this 1,000 times. It's ridiculous. It's a text-based ad. At worst, it's a clickable image. At what point did it become okay in your minds t
by nerdponx 7y ago
Wish I could upvote this 1,000 times.
It's ridiculous. It's a text-based ad. At worst, it's a clickable image. At what point did it become okay in your minds to let advertisers run arbitrary code?
I've left ads turned on specifically on StackOverflow because 1) I want to support StackOverflow, and 2) I trust them not to run malicious ads.
I don't even care that they're running ads network-wide. But if they're going to be running these kinds of ads anywhere on the site, they're going right on the ad block list along with everyone else.
- mikeash 7y agoIt’s completely insane. Can you imagine a TV station receiving ads on tapes and playing them to their audience without looking at them first? Can you imagine TV stations occasionally showing ads containing porn, urging people to kill, showing extreme violence during cartoons, or containing specially crafted audio that blows out your speakers, and the TV station just shrugs and says they try their best to stop these things but they can’t stop everything? Imagine a TV ad that tries to make your phone call a 1-900 number so they can rip you off, and the station says they don’t know where it came from but they’re trying real hard to put a stop to it. And somehow watching the ads themselves before broadcasting them never crosses their mind.
- manigandham 7y agoTv spots are very limited. Digital ad impressions number in the billions with 10s of millions of ad creatives. It’s not the same situation.
- mikeash 7y agoThe only reason it’s not the same situation is because they’re willing to throw their users under the bus for a little extra cash. If they wanted to exert more control, they absolutely could. Ads would cost more and we’d see fewer distinct ads as a result.
- manigandham 7y agoThat is absolutely not the only reason. Digital ads work entirely different from the TV medium and its more than "a little extra cash". No single publisher today really has the power to change much, no matter how big they are. The issue likes with adtech (like Google) and advertisers.
- mikeash 7y agoDigital ads could work where every single one is vetted by people before it’s served to any users. There is no reason it can’t work this way, other than it being a lot cheaper to skip that step.
- manigandham 7y agoAll creatives (and the root templates of dynamically construted ones) are actually audited on the advertiser-facing platforms before they ever get to the publisher. Unfortunately running javascript means these ads can do anything at any time and change into malware. Other than adding some technical guardrails, the best practice would be to ban bad actors (of which many are known and usually the same shady people) but many large adtech companies look the other way because it makes money and they have no consequences. Malware and adfraud is primarily a business problem, not a technical one.
- mikeash 7y agoSo, don't allow them to run JavaScript. That's not necessary, just convenient.
- manigandham 7y agoSee my other comment for how it all works: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20290673 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20290673 It's not that simple. There are many layers in the supply chain that currently requires JS. Publishers can't disable the JS and they can't demand JS-free creatives either.
- simongr3dal 7y agoIf you can't manage to oversee it because of the scale you don't deserve to take advantage of the scale.
- manigandham 7y agoThat sounds nice but is neither realistic or even sensible. There are other solutions like sandboxing to prevent access to features, it's not an unsolvable problem.
- bamboozled 7y agoWell I would argue if billions will see the content, that gives more reason to have it checked over before serving no?
- manigandham 7y agoBillions? No single creative is seen by that many. In fact, with dynamic creative optimization (DCO) and all the optimization that happens, you can easily get creatives that are custom generated and only see by a few individuals or even a single person.
- luckylion 7y agoThe comment was referencing the parent: Digital ad impressions number in the billions with 10s of millions of ad creatives
- manigandham 7y agoI wrote both comments. There are billions of impressions but a single creative is not seen by that many. The point is that the scale is too large to validate on the publisher side.
- pushpop 7y agoIt seems to me there are two solutions to this problem: * remove the ability for 3rd parties to abuse their automatic powers (ie disable their ability to inject JavaScript) * or have a human manually vet every creative The problem here is you neither want to control their access nor take responsibility for monitoring their access. So the blame equally lies with yourselves for not managing an easily exploitable vector of attack. If this were any other system, eg VPN, security professionals would tear you a new asshole and point out just how irresponsible your lack of management is. You’re only excuse here is greed and frankly I’m disgusted.
- manigandham 7y ago
- koolba 7y agoI bet you could do that with an ad that plays “Alexa- call 1-900-555-1234”.
- josephg 7y agoIt’s worse than that. Imagine a TV ad which sends malicious code that gets executed to your television, which profiles the hardware in your TV and sends information about your viewing habits (tied to a unique ID) back to the advertiser. In any other context we would call this a security vulnerability. I think that label also applies here.
- Spooky23 7y agoYou don’t need to, it happens already. Many TVs do screen grabs and send everything you do to the manufacturer or partners.
- zeta0134 7y agoMy Vizio's built-in software tries to do that. There's a reason it's not allowed to connect to wifi.
- DCoder 7y agoWhen you say "it's not allowed", do you trust its own settings? Are you sure it's not doing something like [0]? How do you even protect against that? [0]: https://www.reddit.com/r/privacy/comments/bpr6xs/if_you_choose_to_not_connect_your_samsung_smart/ https://www.reddit.com/r/privacy/comments/bpr6xs/if_you_choo...
- SmellyGeekBoy 7y agoDon't buy a "smart" TV?
- cerebellum42 7y agoIsn't every decent TV these days a smart TV? Not exactly practical advice
- neop1x 7y agodon't connect smartTV to the internet, juse use the DP/HDMI inout ;)
- baroffoos 7y agoThe state of web ads is closer to the public pinboard only instead of having ads for grandmas couch its Mr CEO trying every trick to drain your money and track you.