3 ms·
I don't think this was worth nearly as many words as were devoted to it. (Indeed, the irony of me adding to that number by making this post is not lost on me.)
by pmiller2 16y ago
I don't think this was worth nearly as many words as were devoted to it. (Indeed, the irony of me adding to that number by making this post is not lost on me.) Use of the word "he" to describe an abstract, indefinite person ("a programmer," for instance) does not imply the gender of that person, for the simple reason that abstract, indefinite people don't have gender.
Alternatively, look at it this way. You've got basically three choices:
1. Use "he" as the default.
2. Use "she" as the default.
3. Alternate between the two somehow.
#1 is still considered the most standard usage, although #2 is certainly acceptable. As for #3, some writers might consider it progressive or gender-neutral, but I consider it simply jarring and won't use it.
When I write, I generally choose "he." I certainly hope I haven't offended any nameless, abstract, genderless persons by this practice! There are certain exceptions; for instance, if I were referring to a dental hygienist (over 90% of whom are female), I might choose "she," but, overall, I stick with the rules of English without any compiler-specific extensions.
- johnny22 16y agolots of folks go for "they"
- catshirt 16y agoI opt for they/their when possible. Although this post helped me realized I could instead just construct a fictional character with a defined gender. Can't argue with that. "Yes, that's right. (S)he's a (s)he."
- deleted 16y ago[deleted]
- wlievens 16y agoYou could go all transhumanist and use e. (http://www.orionsarm.com http://www.orionsarm.com)