4 ms·
I think ad blocking is a misnomer. What people are trying to do when blocking ads is prevent marketing people from spying on them. And the performance and resou
by Gibbon1 7y ago
I think ad blocking is a misnomer. What people are trying to do when blocking ads is prevent marketing people from spying on them. And the performance and resource consumption that comes from that.
Personal opinion: Laws are needed to make what advertisers are doing illegal. Advertisers are spying on people to the extent where if the government did it they'd need a warrant.
- yoz-y 7y agoI disagree. The tech crowd is using adblockers to prevent spying and resource consumption. But majority of people running adblockers just don't want to see ads.
- noobermin 7y agoI think the reality is more complicated. People sort of suspect being spied on, but it's hidden, not so real. It's abstract so if you ask any reasonable person, they'll say they don't like the spying, but few will take an impairment in function for something they use in order to avoid it because it seems somewhat distant.
- BonesJustice 7y agoIn most cases, I don’t think it’s ads as concept that’s the problem. If websites only had static ads in the sidebar, I question how many people would bother with ad blockers. But when ads block content; include flashing animations, audio, and video; and take up more layout space on a site than the actual content; then people have had enough.
- umanwizard 7y agoAre you disagreeing with the person you replied to? Your tone suggests that you are, but the content of your post seems to being agreeing.
- BonesJustice 7y agoI disagree that most people use ad blockers because they “don’t want to see [any] ads.” Meaning, if advertisers hadn’t built more and more intrusive ads and had stuck with static ads that don’t severely harm the UX, then I doubt most users would bother with ad blockers.
- umanwizard 7y agoI think you are misinterpreting the comment you're replying to. It's arguing that people block ads because they dislike seeing the ads they're seeing (as opposed to for privacy or resource usage concerns), not because they dislike all possible ads, which is what you're arguing against.
- Gibbon1 7y agoYeah no one would care about magazine style ads with an ordinary click through link. Especially if clicking resulting something useful instead of being the browsing equivalent of jumping into a dumpster fire. The advertiser arms race has resulted in a classic tragedy of the commons. That's my diagnosis of the problem. Traditionally regulation is needed to fix that. Exactly what that entails is beyond me.
- mikro2nd 7y agoNo, some of us block ads because we don't want to ever see any ads. Ever. At all.
- vokep 7y agoThat doesn't mean the side-effect of most people avoiding spying at the same time is somehow an unwanted one. I think most can agree here this level of spying on users is bad. Its sorta like child labor but a lot less obviously bad, in that it is obviously bad, nobody likes it, but there's enough taking advantage of it not being illegal, so its just socially tolerated thing. But once made illegal it will be looked back on like "how the hell did we think that was okay? how the hell did we willingly let it occur?"
- hysan 7y agoI don’t think it’s ever going to be so simple that we can bucket all non-tech users together. I occasionally volunteer as IT support for a small non-profit where everyone is non-technical and in many cases old. Their understanding of browsers were: - Chrome is the fast one. - IE is the one that have to use for some government/old websites. - Ad Blockers are for safety (akin to anti-virus). This was from a group that didn’t even know how to install Chrome on the new computers they got this year. Group knowledge on this topic is largely going to be driven by what they’ve heard in the news or perpetuated by their social circles. And scary things will stick for long after they stop being true.
- Marsymars 7y agoAnecdotally, that's the case for me. I've been blocking ads since ~2000 because I don't like ads. It's only more recently that I've really stepped up efforts by not allowing third party scripts, using temporary/multi-account containers, using Decentraleyes, stripping identifiers from query strings, etc.
- crispinb 7y agoI'm doing both. I don't want to be spied on, and there is no room in any sector of my life for corporate propaganda.
- ridgeguy 7y agoand for me, a third reason is that I don't want to be served malware through an ad.
- pjc50 7y agoI'm only mildly bothered by the tracking, since it seems so inaccurate, but the ads themselves always drive me to adblockers. Taboola were running pictures of rotten teeth for a while which was intolerable; Youtube ads are often louder than the videos.
- skellera 7y agoThey may be inaccurate when you actively block trackers but they are surprisingly effective if allowed to do what they want. The whole “I think they’re listening to me” effect is because of how effective these trackers are.
- kevin_thibedeau 7y agoWeb tracking data gets combined with your real life digital breadcrumbs collected by the data aggregators. Their profiles of you are extremely accurate.
- caconym_ 7y agoSee, I'm the opposite way. I don't care about seeing ads—it seems only fair, if I'm reading a site without paying for it. Unfortunately the water hole has been poisoned, so now I have to block it all.
- luckylion 7y agoIt really depends on the ads, I believe. You can't actually read that page when the ad people go all out. There will be a video playing in the background of the page, there will be animations in content and they will throw in a pop over saying if you really, really, really don't want to save $10.
- caconym_ 7y agoYeah, that is a good point. I guess I have unconsciously written off a certain class of website as simply unusable...
- WC3w6pXxgGd 7y agoLaws are not needed and will have unintended consequences. Technology is needed.
- perl4ever 7y agoThe sense of being spied on wasn't really what drove me to use an ad blocker. It was the fact that once or twice I got what appeared to be malicious code trying to take over my browser, go to pages I didn't want to go to, and prevent me from leaving, in order to promote some scam. I'm not in fact (even if it's naive) particularly scared of legitimate businesses or the CIA or whatever monitoring me.