11 ms·
Ravens parallel great apes in flexible planning for tool-use, bartering (2017)
- Tepix 7y agoThere is also an older study from February with similar results: Romana Gruber, Martina Schiestl, Markus Boeckle, Anna Frohnwieser, Rachael Miller: New Caledonian Crows Use Mental Representations to Solve Metatool Problems. In: Current Biology. February 2019, doi:10.1016/j.cub.2019.01.008 One of its highlights: - Crows can preplan three behaviors into the future while using tools Evolution is fascinating. I wonder if there's another possible outcome where these intelligent birds evolve into a species that is capable of using technology like we are today. Perhaps after mankind wipes itself out?
- gameswithgo 7y agoThere is a book, Children of Time, I caution that it isn't actually a good book, its a bit ridiculous, but it was fun to explore what an earth-like planet would be like if spiders became the sentient species.
- NeedMoreTea 7y agoIt's not that bad, it won an Arthur C Clarke award. Though I similarly thought it a bit ridiculous, that was actually more from the human elements of the plot than the spiders or ants. Spiders who'd just launched their sputnik. Overall I thought it a pretty good attempt with an unusual take, and worth reading.
- AnIdiotOnTheNet 7y agoI don't know how either of you could consider Children of Time to be poorly written, I recall it being quite good.
- NeedMoreTea 7y agoWas I damning too much by feint praise? I thought I agreed it was pretty good. Just some of the human plot stretched a bit far to the ridiculous. The spider eye view of the world and technology, and their take on religion was fun, and well done. Much better than a couple of books by far more acclaimed authors I've read recently, for instance. I'm British, we're fed sarcasm and understatement from birth. :)
- monk_the_dog 7y agoThanks for giving me an excuse to recommend "A Deepness in the Sky", by far my favorite science fiction book with a planet of sentient spiders. It's the second in a series, but the first two book can be read out of order. https://www.amazon.com/Deepness-Sky-Zones-Thought/dp/0812536355/ https://www.amazon.com/Deepness-Sky-Zones-Thought/dp/0812536... (The first book is good too; The third one was OK, but not as great as the first two.)
- dwaltrip 7y agoI second this recommendation. Really great book.
- ajuc 7y agoIt's much more likely that mankind wipes ravens than itself.
- maskros 7y agoThere are several other intelligent and adaptable corvid species that would be a lot harder for man to wipe out: carrion crows, hooded crows, rooks, and jackdaws all thrive near human societies.
- stirfrykitty 7y agoI've had an interest in crows and ravens for years. Most corvid researchers agree that ravens top the list in intelligence due to their larger brains. Crows tend to squabble over resources whilst ravens tend to be loners (mating pairs hang out for life). Magpies are also very high on the intelligence scale, as they are also corvids. Ravens have shown extreme intelligence in solving issues on how to open containers, defeat barriers to a food source (greenhouses), windows, etc. Ravens have been observed "timing" windows opening/closing to source food behind glass. Ravens make toys from pine cones, bottle caps, twigs, and play with them with other ravens. They also use ant piles to roll around in, allowing the formic acid from the ants to cover them, giving them a barrier to mites and other bad hosts (called "anting").
- tialaramex 7y agoTwo things I like that corvids do, demonstrating intelligence but most importantly demonstrating _our_ type of intelligence rather than the more alien intelligence of something like an octopus: 1. Messing about, e.g. young bird finds an object which slides on an ice-covered roof. Hops on, rides the object down, and then crucially, it picks the object up and flies to the top to do it again. What for? Not for anything, this is clearly fun to do. 2. Tormenting small dogs. Small "yappy" dogs are awful. I'd feel bad about tormenting one though. But crows don't feel bad, good for them. Dogs are often left on a lead tied to something, the lead has a specific length and a crow can see that this limits the dog's reach, so it will taunt the dog or even attack it, then fly just barely out of reach, knowing the lead will restrain the dog to its further annoyance.
- wil421 7y agoYou need hands and thumbs to manipulate the environment. Or maybe it would work if you’re an octopus but I don’t think they live long enough. Birds would need to give up flight and have stronger bones.
- dorfsmay 7y agoI think the ability to transmit complex information, like talking, is more important than thumb. Other animals have the equivalent of thumbs and have not created technology.
- madhadron 7y agoZygodactyl birds like parrots do quite well with a claw and their beak, both of which are opposable. Ravens and crows mostly just use their beak, which also works quite well based on watching them out my window.
- jelliclesfarm 7y agoCrows are passerine. If they perch on a branch..their feet automatically clamp making them ‘glued’ to the branch..I don’t know how that ties in..but I have always wondered why they evolved like that..
- ordu 7y agoThe most fascinating thing that birds have no six layered neocortex like mammals do. So birds do all the processing by other brain structures like allocortex and/or basal ganglia. It means that they could have a really different kind of intelligence.
- mannykannot 7y agoLooked at in another way, it lends support to the functionalist viewpoint that intelligence is not dependent on a specific medium.
- stirfrykitty 7y agoSome ornithologists believe that raven and crows surpass even dolphins and apes in intelligence. While I agree that dolphins and apes are intelligent, from my own observations, I would agree with that bird expert. I've seen ravens and crows do some really amazing things. Scientists think apes, for example, are about as intelligent as toddlers. Ravens are something else entirely. Birds can see the earth's magnetic field and take advantage of it for navigation. Ravens can make tools, toys, and solve more complex problems than apes. All corvids can accurately judge weights by sight, and all of them can remember faces for years. This is why farmers who shoot crows find their house, barn, and family animals harassed from then on. Corvids harbor grudges that other animals do not. And apparently the grudge and memories are passed down to offspring.
- madhadron 7y agoThey also communicate knowledge across generations and across flocks. There is a particular mask that corvid researchers at University of Washington used for experiments. It hasn't been used for twenty years. If they bring it out, the flocks still recognize and respond to it, even though the birds who would have seen it are likely dead. Even wilder, birds miles away in the city also respond to it, so the information is being transmitted.
- stirfrykitty 7y agoI think we humans don't fully understand just how intelligent animals are. The ability to relay information across town rapidly is but one aspect, and it's fascinating. And they could do this while we were still wearing animal skins and carrying spears.
- mannykannot 7y agoI imagine that, in these experiments where the subject is offered a choice, one must take care that the experimenter does not subconsciously signal the 'smart' option, such as by the counter-party in a bartering exchange being unaware of the problem that the subject is being tested with, and by avoiding having decoy objects that are more similar to each other than they are to the tool.
- madhadron 7y agoYes. This has been standard practice in animal experiments for many decades.
- Ancalagon 7y agoIts pretty great that so many branches of life, at least currently, seem to be developing intelligence (mammals, birds, octopus, even some fish). I'd really be curious to know how intelligent multi-cellular species from the past were. In my mind this suggests that there is some serious selection pressure for intelligence in evolution, at least here on Earth. If pressures were similar on other planets, mammalian-level intelligence might be fairly common among multi-cellular life on other worlds.