6 ms·
According to the post about this in SRD [0], this was because of repeated calls to violence (something that has been well-documented), and the final straw was r
by amyjess 7y ago
According to the post about this in SRD [0], this was because of repeated calls to violence (something that has been well-documented), and the final straw was repeated incitements to commit violence over the situation in Oregon.
The following is an excerpt of the message the Reddit admins sent the moderators of /r/The_Donald:
(Edit: I originally posted an excerpt of the message from the OP in the SRD post. I've since found the full message in a comment [1], so I'll be replacing it here with that version. Of note is that the admins have disabled /r/The_Donald's ability to use custom styling, as they abused CSS to hide the report button in order to prevent people from reporting violent content to them. The comment also mentions that one of the moderators of /r/The_Donald was stripped of most of his permissions as well.)
> Dear Mods,
> We want to let you know that your community has been quarantined, as outlined in Reddit’s Content Policy.
> The reason for the quarantine is that over the last few months we have observed repeated rule-breaking behavior in your community and an over-reliance on Reddit admins to manage users and remove posts that violate our content policy, including content that encourages or incites violence. Most recently, we have observed this behavior in the form of encouragement of violence towards police officers and public officials in Oregon. This is not only in violation of our site-wide policies, but also your own community rules (rule #9). You can find violating content that we removed in your mod logs.
> As we have discussed in the past, and as detailed in our content policy and moderator guidelines, we expect you to enforce against rule-breaking content. You’ve made progress over the last year, but we continue to observe and take action on a disproportionate amount of rule-breaking behavior in this community. We recognize that you do remove posts that are reported, but we are troubled that violent content more often goes unreported, and worse, is upvoted.
> User reports and downvotes are an essential way that Reddit functions to moderate content. Limiting or prohibiting them prevents you from moderating your community effectively. Because of this, we are disabling your custom styling in order to restore these essential functions.
> As stated in our Moderator Guidelines, our goal is to keep the platform alive and vibrant, as well as to ensure your community can reach people interested in it. Accordingly, here are the specific terms of the quarantine and the next steps we are asking from you as a mod team to resolve this situation.
> Quarantine terms:
> Visitors to this community will see a warning that requires users to explicitly opt-in to viewing it. This messaging reminds users of the importance of reporting rule-breaking content.
> Custom styling has been disabled to restore the report and downvote buttons.
> We hope both these changes will help improve the signal around rule-breaking content and improve your ability to effectively address it.
> Next steps:
> You unambiguously communicate to your subscribers that violent content is unacceptable.
> You communicate to your users that reporting is a core function of Reddit and is essential to maintaining the health and viability of the community.
> Following that, we will continue to monitor your community, specifically looking at report rate and for patterns of rule-violating content.
> Undertake any other actions you determine to reduce the amount of rule-violating content.
> Following these changes, we will consider an appeal to lift the quarantine, in line with the process outlined here.
[0] https://old.reddit.com/r/SubredditDrama/comments/c5safq/rthe_donald_has_been_quarantined_discuss_this/ https://old.reddit.com/r/SubredditDrama/comments/c5safq/rthe...
[1] https://old.reddit.com/r/SubredditDrama/comments/c5safq/rthe_donald_has_been_quarantined_discuss_this/es3sin0/ https://old.reddit.com/r/SubredditDrama/comments/c5safq/rthe...
- drak0n1c 7y agoFor context, the admin logs show that the Reddit Corporate Admins only bothered to remove on average one comment per few days. It wasn't a deluge. The Oregon post is an anomalous casus belli. https://twitter.com/thedonaldreddit/status/1143926570408644608 https://twitter.com/thedonaldreddit/status/11439265704086446...
- wyldfire 7y ago> only bothered to remove on average one comment per few days Does this effectively measure the incoming complaints/requests to reddit admins? If those went up, but their admins' capability to moderate was already saturated maybe the rate of comments removed would stay the same.
- EpicEng 7y agoLikely not given that the sub's custom CSS had all but removed the report and downvote links.
- goatsi 7y agoA regular subreddit would see almost no admin interaction, so if the admins are needing to correct failing moderation every couple of days that's a very bad sign. I helped moderate a large subreddit teaching people how to buy drugs on the darknet and we had zero admin interactions despite being very close to the line of what was allowed because we were aggressive with our moderation. The subreddit only ended up being banned after SESTA/FOSTA passed. Edit: It's important to note that there isn't a report function that bypasses subreddit moderators, unless you directly message the admins. So if the reddit admins are having to step in on reports it means that the moderators are ignoring them, either deliberately or due to a poorly managed moderation team (not enough members or time zone coverage).
- Solvitieg 7y agoIt's understandable that an engaged, political subreddit revolving around a controversial figure requires more admin oversight.