11 ms·
WakeMate review
- beefman 16y agoPlease fix the 'must set alarm' thing! I got one of these for my wife for Christmas. For some reason I assumed it had a vibration alarm, but that's no big deal since she'll mainly be interested in the analytics. But we definitely can't have any chance of an audio alarm going off around her wake time.
- gnemeth 16y agoWe do support a vibration alarm on the phone and if you only want to use the analytics you can just set an alarm for the middle of the day as a fix until we release the analytics only fix.
- boreacrat 16y agoI thought this was a gadget to help you wake up at the ideal time? Seems the author of the review didn't leave this much thought and didn't write about it before commenters asked for it. I agree with the reviewers scepticism towards the usefulness of the statistics, but I am interested in buying this to make my mornings better, not analyzing my sleeping patterns.
- citricsquid 16y agoExactly, it read like the reviewer thought it was an alarm clock...
- sbisker 16y agoSetting user expectation is a design problem that can't just be brushed away if there is any desire in this thing going mainstream. The user will come into the device with misconceptions - it's up to the designer to manage those misconceptions and help the user through any such "user errors" gracefully. A key teaching of service design is that often it's just as appreciated - if not moreso - to guide the user through any issues gracefully, than to not let the mistakes happen at all. Perhaps this review was just a fluke. And yes, it's a V1 - at least as far as feedback from the real world goes. But to me, a lot of the things that surprised him (that having a partner would influence the readings negatively, for instance) also surprised me. I would be hesitant to give something like this as a gift to a "mainstream" person (a "normie", if you will) right now - just because I would worry that WakeMate's manual/interface/whatever isn't yet ready to help my friend through any misconceptions they might have.
- pdx 16y agoIf you want a software only solution, I have been using the GentleAlarm App on my Android. It rings very, very softly (user configurable for how long), and gradually ramps up it's volume. This achieves the exact same objective of optimal wake time. If I'm sleeping soundly, then I don't wake up until it ramps up quite a lot, but if I'm already awake or just starting to wake up, I hear it quickly.
- sgoraya 16y ago> ...there's the obvious question of what the heck do you do with all this data? If you have a crummy night sleeping you're going to wake up and have a bunch of graphs and charts that basically say "Yup, you sure had a crummy night." You can apply tags to the data, things like "cat scratch" or "creepy owl outside window" to help you figure out why your evenings aren't as restful as they should be. But, really, wouldn't a pen and piece of paper achieve much the same thing? I was about to pre-order a wakemate several months ago, but I had the same lingering thoughts above and canceled my order; > There are a lot of people asking in comments whether the thing managed to make us feel more refreshed when waking up, and the simple answer is no. That's because, more often than not, the battery was dead by the morning or for some other reason the wristband failed to trigger the alarm. Considering the wakemate had several delays prior to launch, looks like they should have let it bake a little longer...
- latortuga 16y agoInteresting review. This is the first negative review I've read of this device; I'm surprised considering the thread that was up this past weekend was incredibly positive, with beta testers giving glowing reviews. Has anybody else had issues with the battery? With the app crashing? These seem like things that would be found in beta testing and would be pretty obvious. Reference link: http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2020811 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2020811 Edit: fixed the link
- garbowza 16y agoI've been beta testing the WakeMate for a couple months. The battery lasts about 2 nights, and knowing this, I recharge it every night. Since doing so, it hasn't run out of batteries during the night. The app crashed a lot initially (I'm on Android), but that was months back and the WakeMate guys were good about using the feedback data I sent to fix the bugs. It hasn't crashed for me in weeks, since I installed their latest version. Edit: I meant I recharge the wristband every other night, not every night.
- jlgosse 16y agoThanks for posting this. I'm glad you've had a great experience so far, and I'm glad you still use the device as much as you do. You're probably our best beta tester! :)
- plusbryan 16y agoAgreed. This honestly seems like my experience with the early beta, which did seem pretty buggy. The production version has fixed a lot of these issues, so I'm a little surprised that this version would exhibit some of these same issues. That's too bad.
- duck 16y agoThis shows one problem with "random" beta testers, in the fact they might not be that random and actually want to see the device succeed and thus their feedback is biased.
- deleted 16y ago
- gnemeth 16y agoThe review unit that engadget was given was a beta unit. We made the reviewer aware of this and unfortunately he didn't cut us any slack. As he mentioned we fixed the bugs that we was experiencing. Also we should not that he was using an Android unit, which was the most buggy of all the platforms. The UX on the iPhone and Blackberry for review units, was much more stable.
- rufo 16y agoSo is the estimated and/or actual battery life better in the shipping units? That seemed to be his main complaint, and that complaint seems like it would apply equally to both iPhone and Android WakeMates.
- gnemeth 16y agoWe have worked quite a bit on battery life and will continue to. Right now you can use the WakeMate for 2 solid nights and then you will need to recharge. The issue with battery estimation occurs when you do not fully charge the unit (as we indicated to him) and we are currently working on improving the estimation even further.
- weaksauce 16y agoHas the battery life indication been improved since the demo units? I know lithium ion battery life estimation is hard but I am curious if you have made any improvements since then. My work android phone crashes all the time and so I empathize with you for having to program for it. My personal iPhone is much more stable and I would imagine that it would be roughly the same for your app.
- TimStevens 16y agoHate to do this here, Greg, but... I specifically asked whether devices were shipping to customers and you indicated that they were, at the same time that you sent me a replacement WakeMate unit. If this is not final hardware I reviewed then what is being sent to consumers? Secondly, you never expressed any concerns about my testing on Android and I was quite clear with you about the issues I was having, and even delayed the review so that I could use a more recent version of the software. Finally, when you contacted me and offered me a WakeMate in the first place the subject was "WakeMate review unit" and inside that e-mail you repeatedly used the word "review." I'm sorry, but I can't cut any slack on a reviewable product that is shipping to customers. I'd also ask that if you have further concerns you contact me directly rather than posting here. Sincerely, -tim stevens (dude who wrote the review)
- livando 16y agoFair review, but I'm still pumped for mine to arrive. I don't mind supporting smart people trying to innovate, and I'm betting the app will be getting better all the time.
- bloggergirl 16y agoI totally agree. WakeMate is way more cost-effective a solution than any of its competitors... And the 'personal sleep analytics' (or whatever) could really help busy people make better sense of the practical ways to improve their sleep habits. As with all cool things -- esp. cool startups -- a little patience can help. Greg and the WakeMate crew will surely continue to innovate and improve. One so-so review is exactly that: one review. Plenty of other reviews to come.
- deleted 16y ago[deleted]
- invisible 16y agoI'm not saying negativity is something bad, but this guy just seems spiteful. It's a brand new product and this guy probably doesn't even need the benefit of it waking him up at a good time. He complained (sorry, repeatedly complained 20 times) about the battery, but despite knowing it only lasts 2 days he refused to charge it after 2 days. I don't get that all.
- jamesaguilar 16y agoThe battery bit I am with you. I don't understand for example why people complain that smartphones need to be charged every day. It's not that much of an inconvenience. Please, just plug in your phone. On the other hand, a product's being new does not entitle it to soft treatment in a review. Even without the battery issue, it sounds like this device is not ready for prime time.
- invisible 16y agoI think you're right except if you look at his review, half of his points deal with the battery not lasting 3 days. All of the other points had to deal with the app crashing when he said "I'm awake early." I doubt this applies to all phones too (even different Android phones). This also means the app/software can be improved. "The score is based on the failures of this thing to operate, not questions relating to data relevance or actual ability to improve sleep cycles." Where is the actual review of, "OK, so I recharged it every night, it woke me up before my alarm, and it did/didn't work." This review is useless for that.
- syaz1 16y agoSo very true, I'm annoyed how people always compare their lower-power phones with my HTC Desire (and previous android phones). They said they can last 3-5 days without charging and I need to charge everyday. Unless you sleep every 3-4 days, charge it when you sleep, d-uh.
- rodh257 16y agoPretty average review really, spent the whole time talking about a few bugs which are no doubt being sorted out. Fair enough they are warning that it is buggy but surely they could have worked around them and talked about the actual main purpose of the device in more depth, which is, waking you up at the optimal time. He basically got frustrated and didn't test that properly. In a couple of weeks/months when those specific bugs are sorted out this review will be absolutely worthless. I look forward to seeing a review based on how someone felt after having it wake you each morning for a while.
- nroach 16y agoIf the product doesn't work and perform its intended task, then what's the point of reviewing the feature bullets? I know that personally there's nothing as disappointing as reading glowing reviews of a product's potential, only to find that I a paid good money for what should have been a pre-release product. Sure, as a developer there's always a push to just ship it and get some "traction" but the flip side of that is that doing so risks alienating customers (and reviewers). If I'm a customer looking to make a purchase, what you're implying is that "in a couple of weeks/months when those specific bugs are sorted out this [product] will [no longer] be absolutely worthless." Is that really the standard customers should expect? It's nice to see a reviewer as a customer advocate occasionally rather than just recite the bullet points of a press release.
- Havoc 16y agoThe theory is pretty sound imo: REM atonia, a state in which the motor neurons are not stimulated and thus the body's muscles do not move. [From http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/REM_atonia#Physiology http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/REM_atonia#Physiology]
- jpark 16y agoI would totally disagree that the theory is sound. The fact wrist-based actigraphy correlates at all with REM phases is not scientifically validated in any robust way.
- 16y ago
- cmos 16y agoMaking small portable things with long power life can be difficult. Making money selling small volumes of custom hardware is even more tough. Why not make a sensor that clip onto your pillow? Then they could be powered by a wall socket, or at the very least have a large battery once you take the necessity of size and weight out of the equation.
- cma 16y agoGiven their history, I wouldn't trust anything from these guys that makes contact with my skin and plugs into a wall. Hell, I'd be a little worried about anything from them with a lithium battery, which could cause some major burns.
- Deadsunrise 16y agoI was waiting for reviews of the wakemate but now I think I'm getting a Zeo. At least it will know when I'm awake and not my girlfriend. Logging just the movement of the wrist is almost useless. It's better to properly monitor the different phases of sleep trough the night measuring brain activity.
- invisible 16y agoSo you made the jump from a $60 product to a $200 product based on one review? I'm not certain either way, but if you can wait I'd wait for a few real reviews that are in-depth.
- sp4rki 16y agoSo this is basically a review of the battery life... The reviewer was basically too busy to charge the device every couple of days and then complains that the device runs out of juice? It's like he wanted the gadget to fail so he could write a review chastising it. Even worse is the fact that the little it did focus on the actual usage, was complaining about how he doesn't know what to do with the analytics' data. Would it have been such a hard thing to do to charge the device once a day (as he probably already does with his phone) and report on the actual point of the device? We want to know if it wakes you up at the right moment, not if the analytics are useless for you and that you forget to charge gadgets.
- andrewljohnson 16y agoThe reviewer posted that the device reported 11-12 hours of charge, and then it died. That doesn't sound like user error to me.
- sp4rki 16y agoThe Wakemate website states that the device's battery lasts 2 to 3 days depending on your sleeping patterns. Battery estimates are bound to usage in every device from the Wakemate to your laptop. The reviewer realized that for him, the device lasts two days before needing a charge, and even then kept using it for the three days. As I already said, if you realize that your smartphone only lasts two days with your usage (even though the manufacturer might say that it can last up to three), it would be stupid to keep trying to use it for three days. It's user error to rely on estimates of 11 or 12 hours when you discover that you drain the battery faster than said estimates.
- ljf 16y agoYes, as the device kept telling him it could last for longer. If I had a car that I found only really went 100 miles on a full tank, but kept telling me it was half full still, I would be pissed, and I would focus on that. This is a gadget review, not a life review. You dont see their other reviews taking on how items affect your life, just the quality and appropriatness of the product. Why did you think this would be different.
- jes5199 16y agoI think "WakeMate" is a terrible name. Before I read the explanation, I guessed that it had something to do with wakes, you know, like funerals.
- ericd 16y agoI knew what it was instantly from the name, so I'd disagree. It would be an oddly cheerful name for something that dealt with funeral wakes, so I don't think many people are likely to jump to that as their first conclusion.
- chc 16y agoI think that's really just you. That is a very uncommon usage of the word "wake" for most people, and would be especially odd in the name of an app called "WakeMate."
- rue 16y agoSomeone might think it was an app for stalkers to better follow in your wake.
- coverband 16y agoThe device or the s/w might have some problems, but the team is dedicated to fixing them and not leaving their customers out in the cold, I'm willing to spare my hard-earned cash to support an innovative idea. Which I did, incidentally, earlier today after getting their "your WakeMate is ready" email. I have a serious problem with sleep apnea, and if this gadget can help me wake up fresher, it's priced right for me.
- tpz 16y agoMy mother suffers from severe (but now under treatment) sleep apnea and believe me when I tell you that if left untreated it could cause you far larger problems than wanting to feel fresher when you wake up. Please, please, please see your doctor about the cause of your sleep apnea before treating its obvious symptoms with a device like the WakeMate.
- coverband 16y agoThanks for the sincere advice. :O) (I didn't want to give details for privacy reasons, but I'm already under treatment for it with a CPAP device. WM will not be a replacement.)
- joshu 16y ago"a wedge of silicon" - does the author not know that the green boards are fiberglass or whatever?
- iamelgringo 16y agoSo, as a critical care nurse with 18 years of experience, and as someone who has been seeing a sleep medicine physician for multiple sleep disturbances for several years, I feel inclined to say something. I have my doubts about the premise that if people are awakened when they move their arms, they will wake up more refreshed. If Wake Mate has done studies showing this is true rather than personal anecdote, I'd love to read it. What WakeMate refers to on their website as "Actigraphy" is a method that sleep medicine uses to measure sleep/wake cycles and circadian rhythms by measuring arm movements. I know it has been used during sleep studies, and some of the literature I read showed this, but the studies I read showed that Actigraphy was better used in longitudinal studies. People do tend to move around a lot less when they are in bed sleeping, and they move around a lot more when they are awake. But actigraphy seems to be especially uuseful in capturing data over the course of several weeks rather than during a particular sleep cycle. I would love to read some research on this, if WakeMate has it. What I was able to find online were these references [1]. And, it seems like they are saying that actigraphy is much better at measuring cycles of wakefulness/sleepyness over long periods of time rather than measuring depth of sleep. Also: These limitations rely on how to decide if someone is awake or asleep (automatic scoring algorithms) and not on the activity measurement itself. However, regarding the sleep-wake pattern during daily routine, the actigraphy seems to add more naturalistic information. Thus, it might be helpful for monitoring sleep-wake patterns of insomnia, rhythm disorders, and inadequate perception of sleep in longitudinal studies. Actigraphy might even replace the self-assessment of sleep in some circumstances as it has been reported that patients with insomnia not only underestimate the duration of sleep but also overestimate the sleep latency.22 The American Academy of Sleep Medicine23 considers that actigraphy might help the assessment of the sleep-wake pattern of insomnia patients for extend periods, thus providing data not usually measured by PSG. [2] From what I know, wouldn't measurement of rapid eye movements be better at providing data on when to people wake up? That being said, I do think that you guys might have a great direction in home sleep measurement. I have sleep apnea. I stop breathing or under breath to the point of rousing me from sleep about 30 times an hour. I've undergone extensive testing for this, and it's really expensive to provide that testing ($3000 to 5000 per sleep study). A lot of nurses that I work with know that their husband snores, and wake themselves up at night. But, those nurses have a very hard time convincing their husband that they need to go see a doctor about it. If you could provide an inexpensive way to tell a person that they stopped breathing for 30 to 45 seconds at a time several hundred times a night. It would probably be a lot easier to convince that person that they need to go see a doctor. /$0.02 ref: [1] http://www.aasmnet.org/Resources/PracticeParameters/PP_Actigraphy_Circ.pdf http://www.aasmnet.org/Resources/PracticeParameters/PP_Actig... [2] http://docs.google.com/viewer?a=v&q=cache:E06qD_EZLSYJ:www.journalsleep.org/Articles/260111.pdf+actigraphy+sleep+study&hl=en&gl=us&pid=bl&srcid=ADGEESh50-olBbYd-bduJ1GpLgMNAQ7cg-e849GxKjKf7JwNZRE55dj0fB-SY15V8vYGp3qitZ6GgFLP_WRCqo7aYiu25j0-DdZvm8uJSAXwEhEDef6BXaw7N0pM2ng0h1ZB3rmTGtOG&sig=AHIEtbT3DBFfF5ewL4wAz3UOi5c-Af60aA http://docs.google.com/viewer?a=v&q=cache:E06qD_EZLSYJ:w... pp 84 Updates: Clarification of some statements.
- DrStalker 16y agoMy question is "how does this compare to a $2 iPhone app like Sleep Cycle?" Those apps (I assume there are clones of the one I used) measure the overall bed movement to track sleep depth, and have worked very well for me. Will wrapping something around my wrist do any better?
- flip 16y agoSeems like the WakeMate guys are desperate to burn bridges. There are proper channels for addressing negative reviews... This isn't one of them. It's difficult for me to maintain interest in a company that doesn't respond to criticism with a promise to do better in the future. Oh well.
- kin 16y agoHmm, typical Engagdet review IMO. First off, the battery is a non-issue to me. If it lasts 2-3 nights then I'll charge it every night like I do every other device I have, which is what most people do to my knowledge. Second, if I'm trying to analyze my sleep statistics, I don't think I, nor anyone else can resort to pen and paper to effectively study several nights of sleep and the many factors to sleep. Next, if you're sleeping with someone else and intend to wake up, how is the method in which the Wakemate wakes you any more intrusive than a regular alarm? In fact, it is a regular alarm. I'm sure he simply imagined a vibrating wristband and so was disappointed with a regular alarm. Which is fine, but, vibration could also just as easily annoy others. It's personal preference and not poor design. Finally, what irks me most is that he complains about the Wakemate setting off when you're already awake. Complaining about this tells me he doesn't know what the Wakemate is. It wakes you up at the optimal time such that he feels refreshed. If he's already awake and wants to chill in bed, that's a personal preference. Though I personally would enjoy doing the same it is precisely this habit that causes me to fall asleep again and then wake up at a non-optimal moment and end up not feeling groggy. The point is to wake up refreshed and I feel he missed the point there.
- ljf 16y agoTo those focusing on the battery and issues raised by reviewer... Yes, as the device kept telling him it could last for longer. If I had a car that I found only really went 100 miles on a full tank, but kept telling me it was half full still, I would be pissed, and I would focus on that. This is a gadget review, not a life review. You dont see their other reviews taking on how items affect your life, just the quality and appropriatness of the product. Why did you think this would be different. In all, if I were reviewing a car that had this many issues I would not focus on what the drive is like, I would not be doing my job if I didnt address the failings of this item. It seems loads of people here want the reviewer to just ignore these issues. What do YOU want from your reviewers?
- bostonvaulter2 16y agoHas anyone compared this to a Sleep Tracker Pro? http://www.amazon.com/gp/product/B0026RHFPS/ref=oss_product http://www.amazon.com/gp/product/B0026RHFPS/ref=oss_product
- rdl 16y agoI want something with EEG sensing like the Zeo, but which talks all night to my computer, vs. having to download to an SD card. Then, based on if anyone has added morning meetings to my schedule, or traffic is heavy, or flights are delayed, it wakes me up gently by increasing ambient lighting in the room, temperature, music etc. If I don't wake up, it can become increasingl insistent, and most importantly, if I go back to sleep without getting up, it can escalate. Or, get a pet which expects to be fed in the morning.
- moogatronic 16y agoFirst part of this you can do with the Zeo - They have programming API's that allow you to use a port on the Zeo for real-time data access. The rest of your requirements are up to you to provide!
- rdl 16y agoWhoa. Thank you so much -- I didn't realize the Zeo could actually talk to anything in real time. I've done most of the other parts several times; maybe I should make a packaged service in January. There are probably plenty of people with macs, maybe with big TVs attached, in bedrooms, with Internet access; adding the Zeo and some kind of computer-controlled lighting (optional) isn't much to ask. Unfortunately having to mess with a serial port is so 1995. I wonder if anyone will make a simple serial to bluetooth dongle so the whole thing can be done from an iphone/ipad, or if it will end up with serial to usb to PC.