3 ms·
> in the emissions process most states in the USA perform I'm not sure how accurate that is. From what I can tell, only about half of states have some region
by ken 7y ago
> in the emissions process most states in the USA perform
I'm not sure how accurate that is. From what I can tell, only about half of states have some region that requires emissions testing for some vehicles.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Vehicle_inspection_in_the_United_States https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Vehicle_inspection_in_the_Unit...
For example, Washington requires testing in part of 5 counties (out of 39), for non-hybrid, 4-wheeled vehicles older than 2009. But even that is misleading, as the emissions testing program is being discontinued entirely at the end of the year.
So even if they wanted to just add noise testing (it sounds so simple!), most cars don't get annual testing, and in another 6 months, none will. The state won't even have facilities for it.
The bigger issue I see is that emissions is generally seen as bad by everyone. Most people don't spend money to mod their car to pollute more, so if you test cars once a year, it's probably going to be OK the rest of the year. People do mod their cars to make more noise, though, so if you test once a year, they're going to fix the noise for the test, and then put it back the next day.
To fix this problem, you need to be able to catch people on the road.
- jgalentine007 7y agoI didn't realize how tragically limited emissions testing is (everywhere I've lived in the last 37 years has required it.) After some cogitating, I think you're right about enforcement needing to be done on the road which is unlikely to ever happen.
- mark-r 7y agoHow hard would it be to make a drone that hones in on the loudest car nearby and snaps a picture of the license plate?
- jgalentine007 7y agoI was thinking something a bit more simple like a smartphone with a directional mic and opencv could work - at least for getting an idea of the scope of the problem. Put one on each side of a two lane road and you could probably get accurate results.