3 ms·
Russia isn't all that big in economic terms [0]. Really only China, America, Europe and maybe India are serious players in terms of how much real might they can
by roenxi 7y ago
Russia isn't all that big in economic terms [0]. Really only China, America, Europe and maybe India are serious players in terms of how much real might they can marshal for sustained pressure.
Most countries are powerful players, but the economic giants are in a class of their own.
[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_GDP_(PPP) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_GDP_(PPP)
- _hao 7y agoSee that's the thing. It doesn't matter that Russia is an economical midget. They hold the keys for the energy sector in Europe - Russian fossil fuels supply Europe with energy. And as far as military power goes, many people underestimate Russia, but they took Crimea, they keep sowing disarray in Ukraine, Syria and now Georgia again. And that's even before talking about their influence in elections and paid diplomats that push for pro-Russian agenda.
- 0815test 7y agoEnergy sector? Renewable energy is actually becoming cheaper than fossil fuels. It doesn't matter. And foreign-policy-wise they're not even trying to seriously wield "influence" that could actually be positive for them in the longer run. They can "sow disarray" all they want, even on Twitter and Facebook for that matter but that's theater. It's a bit of cheap lulz at the West's expense.
- _hao 7y agoI'm not saying this will continue in the future. I'm just saying that right now there are a lot of European countries that are at the mercy of Russia when it comes to energy. In my home country Russian influence is very strong. Is not just cheap Twitter and Facebook tantrums. It's full scale invasion in every part of the government. They've been quite successful actually.
- lostmsu 7y agoMercy? Do they not have alternative suppliers?
- cat199 7y ago> Syria umm. how about those 'moderate rebels'? pretty sure the US and its regional allies were the ones stirring the pot in the middle east since hussein/gaddafi/mubarak..
- _hao 7y agoUS doing US foreign policy things in the ME is entirely different subject. That's part of their foreign policy set in the 80's. US had unquestioned global authority for almost 20 years until very recently.
- hollerith 7y agoRussia isn't that big in economic terms, but Russia had enough autonomy to defy the US intelligence establishment by granting asylum to Snowden. The reason Snowden had to quickly leave Hong Kong, in my opinion was that he learned that as soon as the US demanded that China hand him over, the Chinese government would have to comply or essentially run the risk their country falling apart. In particular, the Chinese-speaking lands have been united under a single government for only 500 of the last 2500 years (and 300 of those years were under the Mongol yoke). When the Chinese-speaking lands have been fragmented, non-Chinese governments have been able to cause a lot of trouble by playing one Chinese-speaking polity against the other, so it is understandable that most rational Chinese people strongly prefer to prevent that from happening. The main thing preventing popular unrest in China at levels that risk bringing down the Chinese government has been the rapid rise in living standards and rise in the economic prospects of poor Chinese. That rise would've been impossible without the massive Chinese trade with large countries that are wealthy per capita. The Chinese would not have risked Chinese trade with the US over Snowden. (It turns out that they are now having to contend with a probable reduction in their ability to provide jobs internally through trade with the US anyways, for different reasons: even if the volume of trade returns to previous levels, the terms of that trade will be more favorable for providing blue-collar jobs in the US and less favorable for maximizing employment in China.) No government on earth has as much ability to defy the US government or to inflict pain on the US as Russia does. (China might overtake it in that capacity in the future, but it is not close now IMO and in the opinion of professional strategists George Friedman and Peter Zeihan.) North Vietnam was tiny in economic terms (even accounting for assistance by the Soviet Union and Communist China), but that didn't prevent them from conquering South Vietnam despite massive US efforts to stop them.