6 ms·
`https://trackthis.link/` https://trackthis.link/` requests `https://www.google-analytics.com/analytics.js` https://www.google-analytics.com/analytics.js` on pa
by neilv 7y ago
`https://trackthis.link/` https://trackthis.link/` requests `https://www.google-analytics.com/analytics.js` https://www.google-analytics.com/analytics.js` on page load.
Which, besides being a bad idea for privacy on any site, makes much of this particular site's ostensible purpose even easier to defeat.
- contras1970 7y agothat's so tone-deaf from mozilla... hello? anyone behind the driving wheel there? what are your priorities? trying to win the game of hypocrisy? seriously, this is a great display of dishonesty at the org level.
- beshrkayali 7y agoMozilla has been tone-deaf for a while unfortunately. It became obvious during the Net Neutrality discussion, but even befor with their association with Google which is unclean imho.
- neilv 7y agoI wouldn't say dishonesty; there are numerous ways that could've oopsed in. Our industry and technology has gotten pretty twisted. Getting an understanding of the extent of the bloated mess, shoveling our way up for air, shaking up practices that have become automatic, and cleaning up all the corners that are dirty... is going to take time.
- AsusFan 7y agoThis "accident" didn't happen in isolation. Firefox already ships with telemetry enabled by default, superfluous closed source components (pocket) and a remote control mechanism which Mozilla has already abused "for fun" (remember that Mr Robot thing?). Once is an accident. Twice is coincidence. Three times is enemy action.
- Jonnax 7y agoGo use a Blink based browser whose development and roadmap is controlled by an advertising company instead then.
- neilv 7y agoYou've barely scratched the surface of unfortunate things. :) But this particular one feels accidental: Mozilla is in the midst of a PR push on privacy, and presumably they would've known that a GA request would be bad, and would assume that privacy&security experts would immediately look at what their site was doing.
- contras1970 7y ago> there are numerous ways that could've oopsed in. that's why i said "dishonesty at the org level". i don't think there's any one particular person in mozilla at the prenda law-level of crookedness, but what exactly is their company culture around privacy that they end up casually slipping a surveillance tool into a web page that's ostensibly against surveillance?
- detaro 7y agoOr it's a risk/business decision, and they believe they can trust Google to uphold the promises they make about data usage from Analytics, and that they are sufficient. (and given the fact that in other areas they have contracts with Google for extra-special handling of Analytics data from Mozilla, they likely have invested time and money into vetting that) While agree that the surface-level optics aren't ideal, and Mozilla sucks at communicating those things, I believe people often take a to categorical black-white stance on this.
- autoexec 7y ago> they believe they can trust Google to uphold the promises they make about data usage I have no idea why they would. Google is a data collection company. That's their entire job. There are zero means of implementing oversight to make sure they uphold their end.
- stekern 7y agoThere's a big difference between first- and third-party trackers though. Google Analytics belongs to the former category and does by default not collect any personally identifying information. Third-party trackers, however, usually set a unique identificator for each user and use this identificator for all subsequent requests, and as such (invisibly) track users across the web. In general, it's the third-party trackers and their cookies that you should be wary of as they are most often used for extensive tracking across different websites.
- sroussey 7y agoIt tracks IP addresses, though you can set it to remove the last byte.
- gloflo 7y agoGoogle is a third party when it is about you (first party) using a Mozilla service (second party). Mozilla exposes all its visitors to Google, it tells Google what they looked at and when, and more. This is horribly inappropriate if Mozilla touts itself as privacy protecting.
- stekern 7y ago> Google is a third party when it is about you (first party) using a Mozilla service (second party). Sure, but that is not the distinction I was making though. Google Analytics is a first-party tracker in the sense that it sets a cookie on the same domain that the script is loaded on. Contrast this to a third-party tracker which sets a cookie on its own domain, and as such the same cookie will be reused for all websites using this third-party tracker. > it tells Google what they looked at and when As far as I know only Mozilla has access to the data collected through their Google Analytics account. Third-party trackers, however, often aggregate collected data across a wide range of websites, and might sell augmented, highly profiled user data to advertisers. I have not seen any reports of Google using Google Analytics in such a way, but the data is nonetheless stored on their servers, so you will have to trust that they won't abuse their power. EDIT: As mentioned by throwaway9d0291, it seems like there are settings for enabling or disabling the sharing of Google Analytics data with Google. Not sure if this is opt-in or opt-out though, but this means that it possible to use the service without Google using the collected data.
- simias 7y agoI agree that it's dumb and it shows how the de-facto standards of the web are rotten to the core, however I don't think it completely defeats the purpose of the website. For one thing it won't let other advertisers besides Google's partners know what you're doing anyway and ever for Google it probably won't do much good unless they explicitly decide to handle that website specifically. Which they might do I suppose if it becomes popular enough. I think one of the most enlightening consequences of the GDPR for me was to see that ridiculously long list of "partners" many websites had. Hundreds of companies trying to track me on most websites. I knew this was happening before but I couldn't imagine how bad this was. For people living outside of Europe who might not have seen this before, here's what it looks like on TechCrunch (I chose the site randomly, it's by no means exceptional): https://svkt.org/~simias/up/20190626-122149_partners.png https://svkt.org/~simias/up/20190626-122149_partners.png Note the size of the scrollbar. There are 173 entries in that list.
- throwaway9d0291 7y agoSee https://bugzilla.mozilla.org/show_bug.cgi?id=697436#c14 https://bugzilla.mozilla.org/show_bug.cgi?id=697436#c14 Mozilla has a contract which prohibits Google from using data from Mozilla websites for the things people usually object to.
- dvfjsdhgfv 7y agoSome people don't believe Google at all and would prefer to not having their data handed over in any way, regardless of what Google promises.
- Fogest 7y agoThen block it with an extension? Mozilla has a specific contract against this. It's not just a "promise", it's a legal document. Why would Google care to violate that contract and risk a big shitstorm just to use the data from one company?
- neilv 7y agoYou're telling someone to add a browser extension to block some privacy invasion that a privacy-touting browser vendor is willfully doing? What about the interests of the users who don't even know they have to do that silliness? Also, threat of poo-storm is not always sufficient incentive to respect privacy or even agreements with governments (after you're caught brazenly violating privacy): https://www.telegraph.co.uk/technology/google/9432518/Google-we-failed-to-delete-all-Streetview-data.html https://www.telegraph.co.uk/technology/google/9432518/Google...
- Fogest 7y agoCorrect. At some point if you can't trust any companies, especially when in a contract like this one then you may as well use NoScript because it's unavoidable in this current state :/
- rossy 7y agoIt's not just intentional data misuse that you have to watch out for. There's also accidental data misuse and data theft. Users are safest when they aren't being tracked at all. As privacy advocates, I think Mozilla should take this into account.
- dvfjsdhgfv 7y agoThat's plain stupid. If Mozilla really was interested in the stats, they could have easily set up Matomo, Countly or something similar rather than hand our data over to Google.
- asark 7y agoAn absurd suggestion because it assumes software developers know how to use computers.
- fouc 7y agoThat didn't happen for me (safari here).