3 ms·
> Hiring managers acknowledge that nearly all job applicants exaggerate their qualifications, for instance. Is that an expectation now?
by neilv 7y ago
> Hiring managers acknowledge that nearly all job applicants exaggerate their qualifications, for instance.
Is that an expectation now?
- seqizz 7y agoFor some people, yes. I once got some feedback that my CV is incomplete, mostly because I didn't mention some stuff I consider I don't know good enough to mention. Turns out people with less experience on that topic were putting it on their CVs. So.. Better safe than sorry?
- notacoward 7y agoThat's so close to classic Prisoner's Dilemma that it makes me sad. When the majority of others "defect" (lie, exaggerate, or embellish in this case) your individually-rational best choice is to defect as well. So you get the job, which is (usually) better than not getting the job. And you're surrounded by other defectors, which is worse than being surrounded by cooperators. From game theory, the "solution" is to favor cooperation anyway, but not absolutely. So you might miss out on some jobs, but the one you get will be better. Then again, there's a reason it's called game theory. ;)
- agumonkey 7y agoIt's sad fact of human societies. It's a game of seduction, not about precision and truth (unless rare contexts). I'm like you. Unless I have near complete over a subject, I don't list it. I'm thus jobless. I believe it all depends on how ~structured the industry is. For small gigs for instance, you get direct view of the tasks and problems to fix. You can rapidly tell the customer if you know or not. In highly layered places, you get to talk to many HR that don't know what computing problem solving is, and will react negatively if you're not inside a box. I just passed some technical tests for a job. The questions were very basic. Compared to this, I should list it as senior skills. Actually that's the only reason I'm interviewing, to get a sense of what people want and how they grade it. ps: I also wonder how many people get angry at interviews due to that.
- mgkimsal 7y agoI'm routinely seeing postings for "Senior XYZ developer" and generally list "you must have at least 3 years of XYZ". I don't recall it being quite this bad 20 years ago, but... the market was different. There's a few "stricter" posts that I see that will list 5 or 7 or minimum 10 years of XYZ, but the most I see (when time experience is listed) is 'minimum 3'. Outside of something like nodejs, I'm not even sure 3 years will get you through the experience of a version upgrade with some tech stacks, let alone "senior" qualifications. But it will all come down to how you define "senior".
- agumonkey 7y agoI also have a dilemma. Spending 3 years in a project using <tech> doesn't mean much to me. Unless it's a serious gig with regular problem solving .. but if it's mostly management hell, documentation, ... you might not know much more than when you came in. I know a lot of things I learned in python on my own wouldn't happen in a job because you don't have time to play with everything in the language.
- Double_a_92 7y agoMost of the time you actually know more than you would assume. Even if you barely touched something, if you know about it you at least know what it is, what it can be used for, were to start learning... That's already much more than what average people can quickly pick up.
- Bombthecat 7y agoThe sister of my wife looked for a new job. Started to talk to friends, colleagues etc. All of them lie! Not a single one didn't lie on there cv. So she lied too, to get a job.. In that regard, from what I hear on forums and now live from the sister of my wife, us became a low trust society for job applications..
- rightbyte 7y agoWhat do you mean with lying? Like writing 3y exp. with x instead of the accurate 1y or even zero? Writing that you have a cert when you really dont? Doesn't the employer check the facts?
- Bombthecat 7y agoLying like, did stuff at one firm, which she never did there... But, as I said, everyone she knows did that... Maybe for woman in tech stuff is worse, and they need to lie to get a job, or because everyone is lying you need to lie too to get even a chance, who knows...
- mrunkel 7y agoLet me put it this way, in a previous job, I held the title of Director of IT. That company disappeared after the first dotcom boom. Now, on linkedin, there are no less than four people that claim to hold the title of Director of IT at that company even though I was the only one to actually have that job. The others are former co-workers who have taken the opportunity to inflate their job titles by appropriating mine.
- maxxxxx 7y agoIt’s part of “hustling”. If you lie and win, you are a “hustler”. If you don’t win you are just a liar.
- notacoward 7y agoSadly, yes. Just a couple of days ago I saw some explicit advice to take credit for things even if you're not sure you contributed enough to deserve it. This was in the context of reviews rather than hiring, but I think it's about equally common. I consider it a form of exaggeration and I'm uncomfortable with it. On the other hand, there's a difference between taking primary credit and taking credit for contribution. Sometimes it's not a zero-sum game, and taking credit for contributing in no way harms the person who gets and deserves primary credit. In those cases it can still be deceptive, but how much that matters depends a lot on how much exaggeration the interviewer expects and adjusts for.
- bliblah 7y agoI think that is the point of interviews. Sure I may not have worked X years on a project but I can answer any question my potential supervisor ask then who cares? I would say my CV is 90% accurate and 10% lies, enough to get some glances from hiring managers, but not enough to blow an interview due to sheer ignorance if they ask me about i.