4 ms·
What would be really nice is if a worm like this patched the crappy security of those IoT devices, but I guess that's too hard. With the question being either b
by mcv 7y ago
What would be really nice is if a worm like this patched the crappy security of those IoT devices, but I guess that's too hard. With the question being either bricking them or allowing them to become part of a botnet, I guess the world might indeed be better off with vulnerable IoT devices getting bricked. But boy, it's really a marginally lesser evil.
Let's hope this forces manufacturers to improve their security. That's the main good that needs to come out of this.
- Groxx 7y agoWorms that patch with better security have been a thing before: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Computer_worm#Worms_with_good_intent https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Computer_worm#Worms_with_good_... They have generally had mixed success, from the ones I've read about. Pretty often there are side effects that aren't good (e.g. bricking some devices, excess traffic due to being too successful, that kind of thing) But yea, in this case I think it's clearly too complex. There are thousands of different things hooked up to the internet, and you can't fix all of them at once.
- icebraining 7y agoPatching is just a subsidy for the manufacturer. This malware just soft-bricks (the device can be restored by reinstalling the firmware), so it inflicts a cost without generating extra garbage. Sounds great to me.
- mcv 7y agoWith the risk that the owner just throws it out and buys a new one. Possibly even from the same manufacturer.
- philpem 7y agoLooking at the MTD commands it runs (assuming the ones in the article weren't faked) -- on some hardware it'll clobber the bootloader. You'd need a JTAG cable and a fresh firmware image to fix that. Hardly something within the reach of a typical home user.
- jordan801 7y agoHow many people are going to be capable of reinstalling the firmware? I can tell you 99% of the people I know are just going to junk it.
- myself248 7y agoThese things would be most positive if they were more common, so a vulnerable device would get bricked while it's still in the store return period, and people would just take it back. If they wait too long, then the result is more sales, which increases profit for the whole ecosystem that produces these devices. But if it's more common and results in returns and exchanges, the result is less profit, which might finally put some pressure where it needs to be.
- magashna 7y agoThe attack that crippled Akamai DNS a few years ago actually did close up security holes, though only to cement the attacker more firmly in place and keep other attackers out.