5 ms·
The growing disconnect between the politics and the reality of renewables versus (specifically) coal is troubling. The current Australian government has been d
by BLKNSLVR 7y ago
The growing disconnect between the politics and the reality of renewables versus (specifically) coal is troubling.
The current Australian government has been denying climate change since they came to power in 2013. They've been talking down renewables and placing national-security-scale importance of the role of coal in Australia's future economic success (which I actually find a significant worry because the bottom will drop out of the coal market sooner rather than later). Without much support from federal government policy (but with some support from state governments), renewables in Australia have been steadily growing in their contribution to the overall energy generation mix at a rate higher than expectations, such is the purely commercial justification of renewables.
And yet politics is trying to (s|t)ell a different narrative without providing any foundational reasoning other than motherhood statements about the importance of coal to Australia's economy.
Either politicians know more than they're letting on about the fragile state of Australia's economy and its fundamental over-dependence on a single mineral, or the Australian powers-that-be are over-dependent on a single mineral for their power base.
The more politicians talk down renewables, the more they damage their legitimacy on any other topic; the more they advertise that their speeches are for sale.
- wilsonthewhale 7y agoThe moment it becomes more economically viable to use renewables on a large scale than to use coal is when this stops. The tipping point isn't here yet, but it's coming. Always follow the money.
- rsj_hn 7y agoThis all boils down to economic realities, available technology, etc. Yes, the politicians can wring their hands but don't end up actually doing much because they understand that people like to complain about global warming but when asked how much money they are willing to spend to reduce carbon emissions, the dollar amount is usually like 20 bucks per person/per year. Macron discovered how angry people get when you actually force them to pay more and he quickly backtracked. None of the Paris signatories have met their goals, nor are they on track to meet their goals, because of political reality, not despite it. So the politicians are generally smarter at reading the pulse of the public than the activists on this issue. People care, but only a little bit. But as technology continues to progress, I have no doubt that long term we will not be using coal anymore. But solar has serious problems, the most intractable being the disposal of the solar cells -- they are quite toxic, and no one has figured out what to do with the decommissioned cells -- and we will have a lot of them if solar accounts for a non-trivial share of global electricity output. As in billions would need to be disposed of each year. So I don't think solar is the answer, given current materials. Personally, I like nuclear, but I could be wrong. We will move on from coal just as we moved on from wood and whale oil and all the energy sources of the past, but it's going to happen on a timeline determined by technological feasibility and economics, not by politics or political pledges.
- creato 7y ago> But as technology continues to progress, I have no doubt that long term we will not be using coal anymore. But solar has serious problems, the most intractable being the disposal of the solar cells -- they are quite toxic, and no one has figured out what to do with the decommissioned cells -- and we will have a lot of them if solar accounts for a non-trivial share of global electricity output. As in billions would need to be disposed of each year. So I don't think solar is the answer, given current materials. Source? I find it hard to believe this is a problem given they last decades, I'm not aware of any major problematic materials in solar panels, and the primary alternative is burning coal.
- rsj_hn 7y agoThere are many alternatives to solar other than burning coal. For example, you can build a nuclear plant or hydro dam, or use more natural gas or biomass. The world is not divided into solar v. coal -- solar is not even a major player in global energy right now. In terms of sources about the disposal issues for solar, there are many discussions about this online, but here is a nice, readable, layman's introduction to the problem: https://www.theverge.com/2018/10/25/18018820/solar-panel-waste-chemicals-energy-environment-recycling https://www.theverge.com/2018/10/25/18018820/solar-panel-was... "To understand the challenges of solar waste, it’s helpful to understand how the panels are built. There are different types of solar panels, but most of them contain aluminum, glass, silver, and an elastic material called ethylene-vinyl acetate. The problem is that they can also contain more dangerous and sometimes cancer-causing, materials such as lead, chromium, and cadmium. Functional panels are sealed off with glass and are very safe. But when the glass breaks or the panels are damaged, those substances can leak. This risk is especially high with poorly made solar panels installed in areas that experience extreme weather, like hurricanes and hail. Winds and rain can break the glass, allowing chemicals to leach into the soil and then into the water system" Now imagine a world where solar is a major player. So world energy consumption was 1.575 × 10^17 Wh (2013) and growing at, say, 3% per annum (conservative). (wikipedia). Let's imagine that in 2033, when world energy consumption is 2.8 * 10^17 WH, solar accounts for 1/3 of that. Now today's panels are about 1.65 m^2 and can generate about 300W (https://www.solarpowerrocks.com/solar-basics/how-much-electricity-does-a-solar-panel-produce/ https://www.solarpowerrocks.com/solar-basics/how-much-electr...), so let's say due to improvements in science, that becomes 600W. And let's say they do that 12 hours per day nonstop year round, to produce 2.63*10^6 WH per annum. That means they can account for 1/3 of world energy needs if we have 38 Billion of these futuristic solar cells (the ones with double the current energy output and that produce peak output 12 hours each day 365 days per year). That's about 20% of the area of Arizona. And let's say that due to external damage and internal failure, the cells need to be replaced once every 40 years, so that means we need to recycle about 1 billion of these cells each year, each weighing about 25kg, so that is 25 Billion kilograms of waste that would need to be recycled each year, contaminated with some nasty chemicals. And that number too will grow by 3% each year as global energy use increases. And this situation is only going to get worse because as we do more research and create more efficient cells, that's not going to happen by switching to more organic compounds. It means more exotic compounds. And we still need to find something else for the other 2/3 of global energy use.
- crispinb 7y agoNot necessarily. Most governments of wealthy nations are determined to prop up fossil fuel use regardless of so-called 'economic' or environmental fundamentals. This is very well-established in research but for a recent newsy report see https://www.theguardian.com/environment/2019/jun/25/g20-nations-triple-coal-power-subsidies-climate-crisis https://www.theguardian.com/environment/2019/jun/25/g20-nati.... You might say this can't go on forever as it soaks up government revenue unsustainably. But many decades can pass before 'forever' is hit, and we're in amongst the decades that really count, right now.
- Gibbon1 7y agoIt can go on for a long time indeed. The issue is that eventually your infrastructure is hopelessly outdated. And your key industries run by goldbricks whose core competence is demanding subsidies and hand outs. See the US steel industry for an example. It was a long hard fight but we did it. The US steel industry went from being a world leader to not particularly important in 50 years.
- martythemaniak 7y agoI have to admit, Australia looks particularly weird from afar. I mean, you guys are baking under intense light for huge parts of the year and yet someone thought "I know, let's burn some coal". I mean, at least here in Canada people have a sort of emotional attachment to burning things for heat. Anyway, I just find it amusing.
- crispinb 7y agoIt's a complicated (and somewhat regional) story. But at the root of it is something our politicians have known for a long time, which has made (for example) constitutional alterations almost impossible to achieve: Australians are very, very easy to scare when it comes to any change from the status quo. All a politician has to do is hit the 'this will affect your standard of living' riff (whether justified or not), repeat it endlessly, and a change is usually nixed. Why? It would require a book. Donald Horne's 'The Lucky Country' covered some of it. My (highly contestable) short version is that Australian culture is preturnaturally shallow. There is nothing that holds our society together other than material consumption. Citizens are somewhat aware of this, and are (perhaps subconsciously) terrified of what might happen if anything threatens our lazy prosperity. We have nothing to fall back on - no heroic national myths, no exceptionalism, no religion, no idealism, no common ground.
- BLKNSLVR 7y agoWe have nothing to fall back on - no heroic national myths, no exceptionalism, no religion, no idealism, no common ground. That's all true, and yet Australians are very protective of what they consider "theirs". Maybe it's because of this historic void meaning all they've got is their material things and social status etc. I'll have to have a read of The Lucky Country, thanks for the reference.
- BLKNSLVR 7y agoI think it's because Australia is so rich in mineral deposits, and there's so much momentum behind Australia depending on digging shit up and selling it overseas that politics lacks the will to fight the existing momentum because there's still so much money in it. If Australia had gotten on front foot and built out more solar / wind / renewables, almost to excess, it would be able to then apply that potentially excess power into either local manufacturing with much lower electricity / energy overheads and / or "exportables" such as hydrogen fuel cells (effectively exporting our free and abundant sunlight). This technology is under discussion at the moment, so maybe it's not matured to the point of viability even now, but it's not something that's factored into any Australian political speeches about the country's future economic opportunities. It IS amusing. It provides great insight into the competing priorities of the human condition. Then it becomes depressing.
- roenxi 7y agoUnfortunately the Australian electricity grid is so hopelessly mismanaged I can't make a case that renewable over cheaper options are the major cost driver. There is some evidence from SA that it is likely to be a mistake, but there is a lot going on [0]. If renewables are cheaper we will use them, the government isn't really doing anything overt to support the coal industry. Nothing that really moves the needle on coal vs. alternatives as a power source. As for "over-dependence on a single mineral" - it isn't quite that bad. We have 2 major minerals, coal and iron ore in roughly equal quantities [1]. It is a pretty scary state of affairs, we have really screwed ourselves over by focusing the nation's investments into property speculation rather than into growing businesses and useful infrastructure. [0] https://theconversation.com/factcheck-qanda-are-south-australias-high-electricity-prices-the-consequence-of-renewable-energy-policy-93594 https://theconversation.com/factcheck-qanda-are-south-austra... [1] https://atlas.media.mit.edu/en/profile/country/aus/ https://atlas.media.mit.edu/en/profile/country/aus/
- Spooky23 7y agoAustralia is too dependent on extractive industries. Once that happens, things go downhill, as the owner of the resources is a rent seeker, and his only goal in life is to reduce his overheads and keep the good times rolling. As the Chinese diversify their sourcing of materials in Africa, Australia is pretty fucked later this century.
- equalunique 7y agoI think the strategy of promoting coal in the 21st century is basically to be the first to run out of it. Kind of like a furniture store doing a liquidation sale. Nobody wants that product, but the store doing everything they can to sell as much as they can possibly sell is the difference between having a convertible asset and having a liability. In national terms, coal & coal mines = GDP. For every country that mines coal, the goal is to not be the last one selling it for power generation. That's why there is a push from the top to outproduce everyone else. At the rate things are currently going, it looks like China will be the last one selling it. The international market will go first, and finally the domestic market will shrivel up in the next decade or two, and so will coal's material contribution to any country's GDP.