2 ms·
By far the biggest dark pattern on the web is javascript. Enabling javscript in your browser (which is what almost all browsers do by default) opens you up to
by pmoriarty 7y ago
By far the biggest dark pattern on the web is javascript.
Enabling javscript in your browser (which is what almost all browsers do by default) opens you up to all sorts of tracking, hacking, spying, and advertising (which itself is a significant vector of malware, once again through javascript).
This is why I surf the web either through a browser that doesn't support javascript at all (like emacs-w3m), or in Firefox with the uMatrix extension set to deny javascript from all sites by default.
Unfortunately, the vast majority of users are neither computer-savvy enough to know how to do that, nor to even know how or why they're vulnerable, and probably wouldn't go to the trouble even if they knew how and cared. So they get hacked, and sometimes the rest of us pay the price for it through things like major data leaks of our personal information from organizations where employees browsed the web with javscript enabled.
- westoque 7y agoAlthough I agree somewhat. I think the web wouldn't be what it is without JavaScript. Nothing is perfect and there will always be a compromise. At least there's a good layer of security/sandbox within the browser itself so attack vector is more complex.
- pmarreck 7y agoI don't know what websites you are limited to visiting, but pretty much none of the ones I use on any regular basis would be functional without Javascript. Sorry, not a viable solution except for extremists.
- pmoriarty 7y agoYou're using just such a site right now: HN runs fine without javascript -- except for voting, which I rarely do anyway. Reddit runs fine without it (again with the exception of voting). Most news sites run fine or even better without javascript, as without it you're not subject to all the bloat that advertising heavy sites burden you with. Recently there was some post on HN that linked to a Forbes article, and there were a bunch of complaints in the HN thread about how nightmarish the Forbes website was, with all the ads it foisted on the user. But in emacs-w3m, which does not understand javascript, the site was perfectly readable. There are plenty of other sites which implement anti-ad-blocking code via javascript which are completely bypassed by simply using a browser that doesn't run javascript. Overall, I find that maybe 90% of the sites I visit run fine or well enough without javascript. Sometimes a website will have a legitimate need for the interaction or live updates that javascript facilitates (thout maybe some or all of that could be done via HTML 5.. I haven't done web development in decades, so I don't know, but I suspect it could), like finance sites which run stock tickers, or some art or games sites. I mostly don't use any of those, though, so very rarely run across a site I need that actually legitimately needs something like javascript. Much more frequently I run in to sites that don't need javascript (because they're just delivering static content), but which choose to use javascript anyway -- either because it's more convenient for them, because a lot of web frameworks make use of it, and/or because they want to deliver ads and track their users through javascript. When I run across such sites, I either try to circumvent them somehow (maybe by manually reading the source and extracting the content), or when that fails I just avoid them. In the very rare cases when I can't avoid them, can't circumvent them, and absolutely need them, I'll grudgingly enable javascript. This case accounts for maybe 5% or less of my web use.
- doc_gunthrop 7y ago> HN runs fine without javascript -- except for voting, which I rarely do anyway. You can still sign in and vote with JS disabled on HN.
- LinuxBender 7y agoI agree with the sentiment, but too many companies are using javascript. That said, I only enable ecmascript for sites that I do business with. If I don't know where the site owners work, I won't enable it. I make a few exceptions for a few sites under heavy scrutiny. Even CSS has some exfil risks, but there are browser addons to block that as well. [1] [1] - https://www.mike-gualtieri.com/css-exfil-vulnerability-tester https://www.mike-gualtieri.com/css-exfil-vulnerability-teste...
- glitcher 7y agoYou seem to be conflating multiple topics. Sure, security, privacy, and user hostile dark patterns do have some overlap, but dark patterns can certainly be implemented without JS.
- notatoad 7y agoa dark pattern is not simply something you don't like. javascript is a useful tool, not a dark pattern. it can be used to implement dark patterns, but words actually have meanings and the way you use it is not what "dark pattern" means. "javascript is a dark pattern" is as much a meaningless statement as "emacs is a dark pattern" or "you're a dark pattern"