8 ms·
I hate dark patterns and wish they didn't exist. But I'm not sure that putting the government in charge of policing them is a good idea. There are some objecti
by gnicholas 7y ago
I hate dark patterns and wish they didn't exist. But I'm not sure that putting the government in charge of policing them is a good idea.
There are some objective criteria that can be applied (don't have addons like trip insurance selected by default), but other things are more subjective than this.
Is legislation going to make this better without having unintended consequences that make life difficult for startups who aren't necessarily trying to be sneaky (the quoted language refers to things that are either intended to produce a certain result or have the effect of doing so — even if there was no intention).
I would also note that dark patterns even exist in the legal/governmental sphere. For example, the California Bar website, which lawyers use to pay their annual dues, has optional fees added on by default, and they obscure this fact by making it seem like the default is the barebones cost. It was only after a year or two of paying my fees that I realized how they had hidden these tacked-on fees.
Perhaps the testing ground for anti-dark patterns laws can be governmental websites like calbar.ca.gov!
- frgtpsswrdlame 7y agoIf it's too subjective for the government to make specific laws then the government should just make vague laws and enforce them.
- Despegar 7y ago>I hate dark patterns and wish they didn't exist. But I'm not sure that putting the government in charge of policing them is a good idea. I think after about 30 years of deregulation and "I'm not sure that putting the government in charge of policing them is a good idea", it's time for the pendulum to swing the other way. Yes that means there may be bad regulations and/or enforcement, but nothing is written in stone. Those things can be fixed as they come up. Relevant: https://twitter.com/camerondare/status/1143538064402157568 https://twitter.com/camerondare/status/1143538064402157568
- dvtrn 7y agoI’m always incredulous about legislation ala carte because lived experience has shown me that the “fix later” part of “legislate first fix later” so rarely happens because of all sorts of forces from political to social mixed with the passage of time. But maybe I’m a bit bias in my incredulity residing in a state where legislative sessions happen every two years resulting in sometimes two year waits to come back and address a bit of policy that probably could have been deliberated on more in committee.
- Despegar 7y agoIf Congress legislates they aren't going to be prescribing UI design in the text of the bill. They will give the FTC rulemaking authority and they'll be the cop on the beat that digs into the weeds.
- dvtrn 7y agoTo be fair that isn’t much better in my view, given the FCC’s own behavior recently with dark patterns and public commentary on policy changes that the agency itself promulgated and “requested” public input on Furthermore I’m not even sure if I agree that regulating UI patterns of web application even falls or should fall to the delegated powers of the FCC; this agency primarily concerns itself with interconnected communications systems like the Public Telephone Switching Network, not social networking sites. We have a consumer financial protection bureau, if a solution should exist at the Federal level, I’d be far less dubious of a bureau that follows a similar framework as the CFPB to establish guidelines and frameworks for handling user data and disseminating data to the user respectively.
- Despegar 7y agoThe DETOUR Act empowers the FTC to do this, not the FCC. The FTC already has the responsibility of policing "unfair or deceptive acts or practices" and this is an extension of that. The bill is 13 pages long. There are affordances for small businesses, this bill would only apply to "large online services" with 100 million users or more within a 30 day period. It seems to be a very thoughtfully written piece of legislation. https://www.scribd.com/document/405606873/Detour-Act-Final https://www.scribd.com/document/405606873/Detour-Act-Final
- dvtrn 7y agoOpe I misread your agency there. Sorry about that. Taking a gander at your link before responding further. Edit: Alright I’ve read the first half, because I’m at lunch and would like to take the time this evening to really sit and pour over it: I concur with your assessment. This does seem to be well designed and thought out policy, and I could see myself actively supporting it versus my previous position of “no Federal involvement”. Point, humbly conceded. Thank you for the point of view change.
- ksdale 7y agoMove fast and break things is bad policy for companies, I don't think it would be any better for the government.
- moorhosj 7y agoI’m not sure anyone is suggesting that policy, but “do nothing” seems equally bad, if not worse.
- ksdale 7y agoThe parent was suggesting to regulate first and fix broken regulations later. That's almost literally moving fast and breaking things.
- moorhosj 7y ago==The parent was suggesting to regulate first== The assumption is that introducing a bill to regulate dark patterns is the same as "moving fast". This bill hasn't even made it to committee [1] and darkpatterns.org was started in 2010 [2]. I think an argument could be made that the US government is actually moving pretty slowly on this topic. GDPR has been in place for over a year, so there is significant data to understand the implications of this type of regulation. ==and fix broken regulations later.== How is this different from a software product releasing an updated version? Microsoft Excel is on v16 and I don't think anyone is accusing that product of moving fast and breaking things. I wish we spent more time adding features and fixing bugs from past legislation. [1] https://www.govtrack.us/congress/bills/116/s1084 https://www.govtrack.us/congress/bills/116/s1084 [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dark_pattern https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dark_pattern
- ksdale 7y agoTo clarify, I wasn't really commenting on the validity on any particular regulation so much as on the idea that "it's time for the pendulum to swing the other way." which seemed to imply (to me, anyway) that it's better to do something, anything, rather than doing what we're doing. I agree that doing effective things is better than nothing, but I think doing ineffective things is worse than nothing. As to your second point, I also wish we spent more time adding features and fixing bugs from past legislation. I don't think that happens nearly enough, which is a major reason I don't trust our ability to just fix shoddy regulation after the fact.
- pmarreck 7y ago> but nothing is written in stone. Those things can be fixed as they come up. Unfortunately, this is not true. For example, a right that is taken away will be EXTREMELY difficult to restore again. It's not like a switch that you can flip back and forth until enough evidence is gathered from both states that you know the "correct" way forward... Software has A/B tests for this, law most definitely does not.
- d1zzy 7y agoUnfortunately regulation does seem to be mostly written in stone. Sure, things can drastically change in events like revolutions but I'm not holding my breath for that (nor do I think that kind of instability is something good to have, it's essentially a huge regression with the opportunity to "redo" things, but as humans we ALWAYS do the same mistakes again sooner or later). How many laws are we re-evaluating every few years and updating/changing them as necessary? I think if we had almost all laws passed with expiration time it would hopefully result in better/more up to date legislation although the only "temporary" legislation I remember (Patriot Act?) was just passed every time it expired...
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- la_barba 7y ago30 years of deregulation is a vague, almost meaningless phrase. I'm in pharma and I haven't seen this "deregulation" so to speak. We're seeing more and more regulation surrounding safety of our products (and obviously I agree with that kind of regulation). >Those things can be fixed as they come up. I assume "as they come up" means decades later? The government is like a supertanker, changing course is a sloooow process.
- soulofmischief 7y agoI factory reset my phone yesterday and during the setup process Google asked me to enable location & web tracking. There was a thick, blue button that said "Turn On" at the bottom. But until I scrolled the arbitrarily extended page all the way to the bottom, the option to keep it off (with no button background, just text) didn't appear. That should be straight up illegal, hands down. When we are talking about user privacy these details matter and should be regulated. We don't need to regulate presentation elements but we need to regulate equivalency of options and what some defaults should be.
- hinkley 7y agoThe light grey button with white text makes me smolder, and it's getting a little hotter every time I encounter it.
- EGreg 7y agoBetter than the white button with white text! When iOS 7 removed skeumorphism, they made it harder to see controls. Sometimes the controls were white on a white website. Like on Google Chrome address bar! And in YouTube also.
- wlesieutre 7y agoA note for anyone who has trouble telling what's tappable on an iOS device: there's a setting under Accessibility -> Display & Text Size -> Button Shapes that will add outline/fill to some tappable elements, as well as underlines of tappable text
- m463 7y agoTesla does the same thing in the latest software. To configure car settings on the main display, there is a sidebar on the left, and settings to the right. For example, select "Driving" on the left, and in the pane to the right you can switch the acceleration mode, or steering wheel effort, or regenerative braking level. If you select "Safety and Security" in the sidebar, there are a number of settings in the pane to the right. The trick? the right pane is scrollable. Like realplayer. Move your finger upwards to reveal a [Data Sharing] button to disable sharing of car data/video clips with Tesla.
- simion314 7y agoIF there is no law then how do you fix the problems? I remember years back when a law had to be created so money exchange shops had to display the commission with big fonts under the place they display the prices. The law fixes the issue people had, fixing it with free market and wishful thinking would have cost much more. I think you can find some good enough rules on how things should be without forcing the use of the exact font family and color.
- mrob 7y agoThe EU already applied a similar law with Microsoft's "browser ballot" screen. The requirement is fairness, not any specific presentation detail. Something like "whenever you request permission for something, you must offer the chance to refuse permission equally prominently".
- hinkley 7y agoThis may be a domain that consumer protection groups could latch on to. A little bit of lobbying to fix the worst of the problems and shining daylight on the rest might be enough to change the course of enough companies to improve the situation.
- moorhosj 7y agoThe question you are raising is really: Should we build government policy around promoting startups/ new business or protecting consumers?
- chiefalchemist 7y agoThe government can't bring themselves to stop robocalls. I have little if any faith they can save us from something as nebulous and abstract as "dark patterns".
- NeedMoreTea 7y agoDepends how you look at it. Distinguish dark UI pattern from the traditional confidence trick please. The same abuse of trust and guided decision making whilst carefully trying to stay just outside the line marked fraud. My wife is tech literate, and has put up with my complaining of countless patterns and tech developments over the years, but still managed to get signed up for a subscription when she thought she'd just bought a pair of shoes. A little search showed it a very common issue a few years ago. Maybe it is still. It's all very well not wanting to make life difficult for startups, but what of the flipping public? I don't think it reasonable to expect people examine every pixel of every page just to avoid getting scammed. The startups, even large ones, are often as bad as the worst snake oil selling SEO and internet marketers. It's those startups who made regulation increasingly inevitable. We've had 40 years since Thatcher and Reagan started working to make regulation unacceptable and unfashionable. The first 10 years probably did improve things, the next 30 has been too much and caused countless scandals, banking crises and what not.
- daniel-cussen 7y agoMaybe force websites to be accessible through an API, so if their UI is crap you don't have to use it and you can use a third-party UI instead.