3 ms·
The US has long ago abandoned free market healthcare. I don't know why people keep calling it that. It's some bastard child of socialized medicine where the po
by dmix 7y ago
The US has long ago abandoned free market healthcare. I don't know why people keep calling it that.
It's some bastard child of socialized medicine where the poor and old are covered mixed with gov mandated private insurance coming from a few very large insurance companies capable of operating within the regulatory environment.
Which is basically one step removed from full blown single-payer public health insurance (as we have here in Canada) and about a hundred steps removed from "free market" health care.
I hope the US gov decides on single payer soon as I see no path towards going back to an actual market. Which would be better than the current system which features much of the worst of both worlds.
- tombert 7y agoI've been saying this for years. The only way that our healthcare is truly capitalistic is that someone makes a profit. When I got appendicitis a few months ago, it's not like I went on Yelp and searched for the best prices and and reviews; I went to the hospital that was closest, and prayed that it was covered by my insurance.
- TrevorJ 7y agoYep. It's the worst of both worlds right now. Either take it over fully, or devolve it to a pure free market system, with medicaid backstops.
- phil248 7y ago"The US has long ago abandoned free market healthcare." Not true. Like literally every sector of a mixed economy, there is government interference. And sure, there is a lot more in the healthcare industry than most. But it does operate as a highly regulated market system wherein private enterprises compete and consumers make decisions. And certainly it is not strictly "free market", but then again nothing is.
- AzzieElbab 7y agoUS health-care costs are out of this world. However, for the life of me I cannot begin to comprehend why every Canadian keeps using our healthcare system as example of success when incidents like these are becoming more and more common https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/newfoundland-labrador/samanthan-rideout-amputee-broken-foot-1.5184582 https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/newfoundland-labrador/samanth... https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/nova-scotia/mother-iwk-halifx-hospital-mental-health-refusing-to-leave-1.5181626 https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/nova-scotia/mother-iwk-halifx... and for a description of typical hospital visit https://www.cbc.ca/news/opinion/health-care-1.5170948 https://www.cbc.ca/news/opinion/health-care-1.5170948 note, CBC is basically a more liberal Canadian CNN
- dmix 7y agoIt’s always lesser of evils when you’re dealing with critical gov services. If you can’t provide a better alternative then it’s still an improvement. The much larger UK NHS system where even hospitals are publicly run would be even harder to pull off in America. So single payer insurance is basically the lowest hurdle. Plus the simpler the better. At some point the right in the US has to concede on healthcare because it’s already been gutted and killed by a thousand cuts. And I say that as a libertarian leaning person. You can’t honestly believe they can solve this problem by writing a thousand more small reform bills. Plus if you give the mob public healthcare they will be much more tolerant of pro-economy policies and take a strong argument away from the people who want to gut even more industries so they function just as poorly as the pseudo healthcare market in the name of “fairness” and “equity” (mediocrity for all!). Lesser of evils.
- marrone12 7y agoWell the maritimes have much less funding overall than other provinces, and their health outcomes are noticeably worse.