8 ms·
The idea of requiring list prices of drugs to be displayed in commercials seems like it might be very effective. Imagine if you were able to do some quick ment
by Waterluvian 7y ago
The idea of requiring list prices of drugs to be displayed in commercials seems like it might be very effective.
Imagine if you were able to do some quick mental math on your couch:
"Okay so ask my doctor about Poopathome for my rectal bashfulness... Well let's see first. It says $890/month average dose. My insurance covers 80% so that would cost me something like $180 a month. Yeah sorry Pfizer you'll have to do better."
- cr1895 7y ago>The idea of requiring list prices of drugs to be displayed in commercials It's bizarre that prescription medication is advertised like that in the first place.
- PeterisP 7y agoThe obligatory reminder like in similar threads before - in most other first world countries it's not done because it's forbidden; mass media advertisements of prescription medicine is a practice specific to USA and a couple other places.
- jjoonathan 7y agoIt used to be forbidden in the USA, too.
- Rebelgecko 7y agoWhen?
- arcticbull 7y agoExactly. In Canada you an only advertise either that a drug to treat a certain condition exists, or that a drug with a certain name exists, but not both in the same ad. Why advertise drugs to customers, they're not medical professionals - that's why we have GPs.
- SteveNuts 7y agoWhat about for OTCs? I would think most people can self-diagnose and self-treat everyday allergies, for example.
- arcticbull 7y agoSorry, to clarify, I meant prescription medication. OTCs are allowed to advertise as of 1997. [1] [1] http://theconversation.com/drug-ads-leave-canadians-in-the-dark-about-safety-risks-102317 http://theconversation.com/drug-ads-leave-canadians-in-the-d...
- sonnyblarney 7y agoYes, you can advertise Tylenol in Canada. But not Oxycontin.
- smhenderson 7y agoDoes Tylenol in Canada have a small amount of codeine in it? It did when I lived there in the 90's. Does that make a difference when it comes to advertising? If I recall correctly it was like 2 or maybe 5 mg of codeine which is a very small amount. Any dose over that needed a prescription so I wouldn't be surprised if Tylenol was considered just an OTC drug but knowing there is codeine in it made me unsure.
- sonnyblarney 7y agoYes, Tylenol 3 with codeine was available until 2018 in Canada without a prescription, oddly. But that 'loophole' would eventually be exploited by those needing their 'fix' ... so it's now prescription only. As far as I know the rule for ads is 'non prescription', beyond that it's hard. I don't recall seeing an ad for a prescription drug in Canada in the last decade, though they might exist in some form. We get American TV and those ads seem quite ridiculous, what with the senior citizens dancing away, and the narrator iterating through a huge list of symptoms, then listing off 30 or 40 side effects as fast as he can, as if people are remotely capable of understanding. My family works in the drug industry, I should say one thing that people don't want to hear: a lot of doctors are lazy. Just because they're doctors, does not mean that they keep up in any way with current issues, trends. The level of power they have, and the relative lack of ongoing certification is ridiculous. Once they get their ticket, it's a golden ride for the rest of their lives if they want. Many people complain about the 'free lunch' doctor's visits by the sales reps, but I don't see it as such a bad thing. It's intense and important information, I have no problem with Doctors getting a 'free ham sandwich' to entice them to go through the data on the latest trials. Obviously, there are shenanigans there, misrepresentation, competitive issues, pricing etc. etc. - but frankly a 'highly moral sales/communication force' actually I think does add value - they get doctors to pay attention to the specific issues. Obviously, there are probably better alternatives ... but again, Doctor's guilds are very powerful and archaic, nobody can tell them what to do.
- AnIdiotOnTheNet 7y agoDamn straight. Sane countries don't put up with this shit. I don't watch normal TV so when I do see these ads they never fail to remind me what an oligarchic dystopia my country has become.
- metalliqaz 7y agoIt can get so, so much worse.
- pdpi 7y agoHow much worse can it get while most of the population still honestly believes it's great, though? Getting China out of the hole it's in would be much harder than reversing the course on US politics, but only if US citizens stop fooling themselves into thinking they're in "the best country in the world".
- zzzeek 7y agoWe have a president who is complicit in assisting with state sanctioned murder of US journalists, and people don't seem to be very upset about it
- ameister14 7y agoCould you clarify what US journalists President Trump has assisted in murdering?
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- zzzeek 7y agoJamal Khashoggi. I guess moderators thought I was suggesting he was involved in the murder itself, rather than obstructing an appropriate diplomatic response. Sort of proves my point that nobody cares.
- mwfunk 7y agoAgreed, I think it's crazy. I don't know what's more surreal, the fact that those ads are 50% recitations of side effects (which they have to say, but surely it makes them think twice about advertising), or the inevitable "ask your doctor if <blank> is right for you". What?!? I would hope that if it was, my doctor would already know about it and have prescribed it for me. If not- new freaking doctor time.
- jlmorton 7y agoIt's not that strange for new medications. Here's a personal example. Lots of people suffer from hyperhidrosis, which is excessive sweating, generally on the palms, feet, or armpits, where sweat glands are clustered. There have never been great treatments. There are all sorts of them, but many of them just don't work, or have horrific side effects. Among these is a drug called glycopyrronium bromide, which is an anticholinergic. Taken orally, it absolutely cures hyperhidrosis dead in its tracks. It also has a tendency to dry up every part of your body that should naturally be lubricated in some way. Imagine your mouth, tongue and throat so dry you can barely form the movements necessary to speak. Imagine your eyes so dry you can barely blink. Imagine your nose dry and cracking and frequently bleeding. Lots of people would have talked to their physicians about this in the past, and lots of people would have tried options available to solve the problem, including surgical options. But all of those options were either terrible, or did little to alleviate the fundamental problem. And then in 2018 there was a new treatment developed, qbrexza, essentially the same drug, but delivered as a topical cloth treatment. It turns out this drug is not readily absorbed into the surrounding bloodstream, and in any event doesn't cross the blood-brain barrier at all. It turns out that topical treatment works quite well for the primary purpose, with significantly reduced side effects. But imagine you've already talked to your doctor about this problem, years ago, tried several remedies, and none of them worked. Imagine you had already given up on seeking treatment. Then you see an advertisement on TV for your particular affliction. It sounds like a new, and promising avenue of treatment. And so you decide to go back to your doctor, and ask about this new treatment, which never existed before. And you never would have done that, probably ever, if you hadn't seen the advertisement. How many drug advertisements do you see for old drugs? Not that many. There are some, for very common ailments like hypertension. But primarily drug advertisements are focused on new drugs. It's not that odd to advertise a new treatment. There are still doctors that need to evaluate patients and prescribe the medication. If doctors are prescribing useless medication to patients, that seems like the primary problem to me, not the advertisements.
- mfatica 7y agoMaybe there's a gap for some kind of doctor-patient communication application? The idea is a new drug like this comes out and a doctor can go into their system and send some notification to their patients
- wingspar 7y agoUntil I saw an tv ad for Paxil, I didn’t know social anxiety disorder was a thing... visited their website, took their ‘survey’ and talked to my Dr. Started taking it and it was very helpful. Then after a few years, I didn’t need it anymore.
- falsedan 7y agoYeah, see, here your GP would refer you to a psychiatric provider (probably a nurse) or you’d see it a pamphlet in the waiting room when you came to talk about how you feel because you saw your doctor more than once every 2 years because you weren’t terrified by how much it cost/if you would lose your job taking time off work.
- wingspar 7y agoAt the time, my healthcare was fully paid for with small copays. Went to Dr as needed. The issue is, that until I saw the Paxil add talking about social anxiety. I thought I was just very shy, so why would I talk to my dr about that? The Ad changed my life.
- falsedan 7y agoIt worked for you but consider the vast population who are not as privileged to have easy access to health care. Do the ads help them? Will their lives be improved by more ads, or by removing barriers that make it harder to get medical assistance (physical & mental)?
- tzs 7y ago> "Okay so ask my doctor about Poopathome for my rectal bashfulness... Well let's see first. It says $890/month average dose. My insurance covers 80% so that would cost me something like $180 a month. Yeah sorry Pfizer you'll have to do better." ..."but (hehe) maybe I'll check GoodRx too. Hmmm...they have discount coupons that bring it down to anywhere from $20/month to $100/month, depending on the pharmacy. Hmmm...it's $40/month at the pharmacy I have all my other prescriptions, but $20/month at the Safeway that is a bit out of the way for me. Ooh...look at this! It's also $40/month with GoodRx at my pharmacy for pills with twice the dosage I'd need. If I get that and cut the pills in half, it's effectively $20/month at my pharmacy! Maybe I'll talk to my doctor about it after all!" It's ridiculous currently, and some of it makes no sense whatsoever. Here's a recent illustration of the absurdity which I experienced last month. (For those in Europe reading this--I swear I'm not making this up! This is really how we do prescription drugs over here). There's a drug I take twice a day, 150 mg each dose. I had a monthly prescription for 30 x 300 mg, with directions to take half a pill in the morning and half a pill in the evening. That costs $9 cash at Walmart. The cash price at Walmart for 30 x 150 mg is also $9. The 300 mg pills were back ordered last time I needed a refill, and Walmart said they could change it to 60 x 150 mg. I said to go ahead. Turns out they actually changed it to a 3 month supply, 180 x 150 mg...and the price was $400. WTF? I pointed out that this was rather absurd, and they redid it as 60 x 150 mg for one month...that was $300. Huh? According to GoodRx the cash price at Walmart should be $24 for 60 x 150 mg (which still doesn't make much sense, because it is the exact same freaking pill used for 30 x 150 mg, which is $9. Filling a bottle with 60 pills instead of 30 pills should not add $6 to the cost!). They agreed to redo it yet again, as 60 x 150 mg, for the $24 cash price listed by GoodRx. (And I do mean "redo it". They could not just sell me the 60 x 150 mg bottle that they had just filled for $24. Nope. They had to count out another 60 x 150 mg into a new bottle and sell me that for $24. Presumably the first 60 x 150 mg bottle, the $300 one, got treated as a prescription that was never picked up). When it is time to renew that, I'll be moving it to Safeway. 60 x 150 mg there is $13.99 with a GoodRx coupon.
- newman8r 7y agoEven if the pharmacy doesn't accept GoodRx coupons (some don't) - you can ask if the pharmacy has any discounts for uninsured persons.... if they do, it's often even cheaper than the coupon would have been.
- slg 7y agoI don't know, getting people to prioritize their wallet over their health seems like a bad solution. Maybe we should actually work on reducing the high prices instead of scaring people away from seeking medical care due to those high prices.
- Waterluvian 7y agoRight. The real solution is to be more like the rest of the modern world. Let drug prices be negotiated in bulk by your government, so that you can focus on being healthy. I just don't believe the U.S. is capable of such significant change. So maybe one thing at a time.
- peteradio 7y agoAwareness of pricing will be the single biggest contributer towards reducing price. If I'm only aware of the price after services rendered how am I supposed to discriminate among my options?
- slg 7y agoDoes this really increase awareness of pricing if the price displayed is only the worst possible situation in which the person has no insurance? Most people don't care what their insurance company is charged, they only care about the amount they personally are charged. I also have a hard time believing that the reason prices haven't gone down is due to some overall lack of awareness of the problem.
- Shivetya 7y agoWho knows, we might end up with that result that some studies found when restaurants starting posting calorie counts, there were people suddenly consuming more! I think the fear here is that if prices are published its going to provide leverage to smaller outfits to get better pricing and that is a good thing. the best benefit is to give Americans a true idea of what stuff is costing because so many are too separated from the cost of their health care to understand the magnitude of the problem