2 ms·
> but if both sides are worse off at the end than at the beginning... why do it? Some fun philosophical questions... Do you actually know that both sides are
by mistermann 7y ago
> but if both sides are worse off at the end than at the beginning... why do it?
Some fun philosophical questions...
Do you actually know that both sides are worse off at the end?
How do you personally believe this should be measured? How confident are you that that measurement approach is correct? What is the definition of "correct" in this context?
Do you conduct your measurements at two discrete snapshots in time: before and after? Are consequences 5, 10, 50 years down the road irrelevant, both in theory and in fact?
If you are measuring GDP, do you think looking at the aggregate national level is satisfactory? Might there be some unintended consequences lurking in the shadows waiting to bite you in the ass if you ignore regional GDP?
Do the very real (democratic) consequences of people's opinions matter in your measurement, or are you content with measurements limited to the the theoretical world, where people behave as they "should"?
It's interesting how easily technical people can see the complexity in their software models, but seemingly remain blind to the complexities of planet earth and human nature.
- lsc 7y agoI think if you are going to seriously argue that the US net benefited from the Vietnam war... or that Vietnam itself would not have been better off if it wasn't attacked by the US, I just don't know what to say.
- dragonwriter 7y agoVietnam wasn't attacked by the US, at a minimum because Vietnam wasn't one country at the time of the war, leaving aside the question of which of the Vietnams (along with the corresponding superpower puppetmaster and allies) was the aggressor.