2 ms·
IMHO, good electron apps feel and behave like native apps. Or, in the worst case scenario, they feel like an equivalent web app. Specifically - I should not ha
by falcolas 7y ago
IMHO, good electron apps feel and behave like native apps. Or, in the worst case scenario, they feel like an equivalent web app.
Specifically - I should not have to think of having to “ctrl-R” for a desktop application.
Good electron apps do exist, but they feel like a vast minority. Most just feel like a bloated version of their web application.
- jlongster 7y agoI completely agree! Are you referring to the "ctrl-r" to reloading the server in the article? That's only for development - the user never has to refresh the app like that of course!
- falcolas 7y agoI think you’re saying “a user should never have to refresh the app”. Because ctrl-r has returned completely borked applications back to working. Specifically, I’ve had to use it almost daily to make slack recover from a freeze.
- jlongster 7y agoOh, yeah that's stupid. cmd+r or ctrl+r for refreshing doesn't even work in my electron app because it doesn't make sense for a desktop app.
- btsheehy 7y agoI'm not sure what the point is, here. Is it that Electron apps can lock up or crash? That they can be refreshed seems pretty immaterial, given that any application in any language can crash
- yoz-y 7y ago> IMHO, good electron apps feel and behave like native apps. I second this, but there are a few reasons why they can't. For example Blink does not respect MacOS highlight color setting so any electron app won't either. I should not be able to select text in parts of interface (e.g.: text inside a button), but it is pretty common that a cmd+a selects everything including interface. Buttons should be in the correct order and have correct highlights depending on the platform.
- matchbok 7y agoEh, what? That is never true, at least in my case. Right click functionality is never good, context menus are useless, text selection, dialogs, etc. The whole point of electron is to avoid those native things.