5 ms·
Why stop there? Are you currently using solar power? Do you use the bus instead of walking? What's your food habits - do you eat meat? What clothes are you cu
by SketchySeaBeast 7y ago
Why stop there? Are you currently using solar power? Do you use the bus instead of walking? What's your food habits - do you eat meat? What clothes are you currently wearing? Where do you live? How large is it? Does it need heating or air conditioning?
You're drawing the "this makes an awful person" line at a super arbitrary point.
- coldpie 7y agoThose are all perfectly valid questions when making such a value judgment, yes. We're past the point of no return, here. Everything matters.
- perfunctory 7y agoI was expecting a reply along these lines. Just because you don't kill yourself to eliminate all emissions doesn't mean you shouldn't try to do what you can.
- SketchySeaBeast 7y agoI'm just saying - you're a bad person. Sorry.
- lordfoom 7y agoI don't know if it's your intention, but it comes across to me that you're advocating doing nothing, which strikes me as bad.
- SketchySeaBeast 7y agoI'm not - we absolutely need to do something. What I am advocating against is drawing an arbitrary line in the sand and going "well, I don't still fly, invest in fossil fuel, or consume extravagantly, therefore I'm fine and a good person." Even if you do those things, you're still going to be part of the problem.
- igor47 7y agoin your opinion, what makes someone part of the solution?
- benj111 7y agoThat isnt what you appear to be saying though, it reads as, you are a "bad person" if you don't do $semi_arbitrary_thing. Not, you should be doing all you can.
- castis 7y agoAnd in typical human fashion, we're now going to argue over where the moral line is drawn instead of the actual problem.
- SketchySeaBeast 7y agoIt was a mistake to try and make it a moral argument to begin with. We need to frame the discussion as "if we all want to survive, we're going to have to do {blah}". Drawing an arbitrary line and calling everyone on one side of it "bad" is creating an artificial division that gives those on the "right" side something to be smug about and those on the "wrong" side something to ignore.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- castis 7y agoWe'll I'm glad that you're here to set everyone straight.
- igor47 7y agomy standard response to this is the one i learned from william macaskill at oxford, and is an extension to a line of reasoning from peter singer. peter singer believes that if you could save a child's life for two dollars, and you instead spend that money on a coffee, you're in effect killing the child. if you extrapolate this reasoning to it's logical conclusion, it follows that you should be living at the same level as the poorest person in the world so you can donate as much money as possible and still survive. however, if you start living in a refrigerator box and not doing laundry because you don't want to spend money on detergent, you're likely to lose your cushy tech job for being weird, and then you'll be able to save way fewer children. so, while it's true that you can go be a hermit in the mountains who only eats berries extracted from bear poop, that might not actually be the most effective way to help the environment. it would preclude you, for instance, from trying to convince someone on hacker news to live a more modest lifestyle, thereby doubling your contribution.