5 ms·
https://www.newsweek.com/concentration-camps-alexandria-ocasio-cortez-trump-border-1444843 https://www.newsweek.com/concentration-camps-alexandria-ocas... > "C
by eesmith 7y ago
https://www.newsweek.com/concentration-camps-alexandria-ocasio-cortez-trump-border-1444843 https://www.newsweek.com/concentration-camps-alexandria-ocas...
> "Concentration camps are considered by experts as 'the mass detention of civilians without trial.'
Even without photos, we know there is mass detention of civilians without trial.
Do you deny that?
What term do you want to use? From the same link:
> We don't say 'prisons' because prisons are a part of the formal legal system," Lester Andrist, a sociologist who has studied indefinite detention, tweeted.
Or would you prefer "internment camp", like we used for Japanese Americans? From the same link:
> "I know what concentration camps are. I was inside two of them, in America. And yes, we are operating such camps again," the Takei tweeted. The Takei family was interned in Arkansas and California in the 1940s.
Or perhaps you want to reserve 'concentration camp' only for the Nazi death camps? From the same link:
> Federico Finchelstein, a historian at the New York-based New School, agreed that the progressive congresswoman is right to call the ICE facilities concentration camps.
> "As [a] historian of fascism & [the] Holocaust, I would also call these centers concentration camps," Finchelstein tweeted. "As a Jewish person who lost family in [the] Holocaust, I regret that some Republicans use memory of the Holocaust to defend racist policies of Trumpism."
From https://beta.washingtonpost.com/nation/2019/06/20/concentration-camps-alexandria-ocasio-cortez-japanese-americans/?outputType=amp https://beta.washingtonpost.com/nation/2019/06/20/concentrat... :
> A 1998 Ellis Island exhibit drew outcry from the Jewish community and others after the Japanese American National Museum titled it, “America’s Concentration Camps: Remembering the Japanese American Experience.” To the museum’s curators — and to many historians and leading Japanese American organizations today — “internment” or “relocation camps” were euphemisms for the reality of what Japanese Americans endured. President Franklin D. Roosevelt and Supreme Court justices, the museum noted, had both referred to the Japanese American camps as concentration camps.
> ... Ultimately, Jewish and Japanese American groups held meetings to reach an understanding, Schiffrin reported. The exhibit’s title stayed, but with one long footnote on the flier, making clear that it was not an attempt to directly compare the Japanese-American camps to Nazi camps.
- s9w 7y agoAOC said "never again" in her concentration camp remarks, CLEARLY making the connection to WW2 concentration camps.
- boapnuaput 7y agoOregonian here. Yes, she was talking about WW2 concentration camps. It's disgusting that you've forgotten that, during WW2, we ran concentration camps too, for Japanese-Americans and others who we failed to trust in spite of their citizenship. Read the parent comment again. George Takei was in one of these camps!
- RickJWagner 7y agoNo, those were not concentration camps. They were internment camps. Big difference. Concentration camps were murder centers. Internment camps were not.
- eesmith 7y agoFDR, Eisenhower, and many other high-ranking government officials at the time referred to the Japanese 'internment camps' also as 'concentration camps'. See http://www.english.illinois.edu/maps/poets/g_l/haiku/camps.htm http://www.english.illinois.edu/maps/poets/g_l/haiku/camps.h... as an example of how in the 1990s there was already the complaint that it "seems strange that we are still debating the use of terms describing this event" when it was well-established that the Japanese were indeed in concentration camps in all but official name. It also gives quotes, like Truman in 1961 saying "They were concentration camps. They called it relocation but they put them in concentration camps, and I was against it. We were in a period of emergency, but it was still the wrong thing to do." The term "concentration camp" was also used in the Spanish-American and Boer Wars, for something other than "murder centers". All evidence I've seen says that calling these facilities something other than "concentration camp" is a euphemism to hide the atrocities that we are committing YET AGAIN.
- whamlastxmas 7y agoThere's tons of Jewish people, including a Holocaust survivor and former victim of a real concentration camp, telling AOC to quit her bullshit. The kids are in a detention facility. Donald Trump didn't personally decide "fuck Mexicans" and rip kids out of their loving homes. He's protecting children from the people in an adult detention facility who have actively broken the law and took their families with them in the process. Calling Trump a Nazi and calling these places concentration camps is a massive slap in the face to the millions of people who actually died from the war.
- eesmith 7y agoSo if there are Jewish people who agree with her, and Jewish people who do not ... what does that mean? If there are Japanese people, who lived in "detention facilities" during WWII who agree with her definition ... what does that mean? If Ben Ferencz, who prosecuted Nazis in Nuremberg, 'describes these policies of separating children from their parents and putting those children in cages as “crimes against humanity.”' (quoting https://www.politicususa.com/2019/06/20/opinion-a-concentration-camp-by-any-other-name-is-still-a-concentration-camp.html https://www.politicususa.com/2019/06/20/opinion-a-concentrat... ) ... what does that mean? Maybe it means we need to stop what we're doing to those tens of thousands of children. 'Cause, you know, that's not doing anyone any good. And as for "actively broken the law" - last I checked, crossing the border illegally was a misdemeanor offense. Is this really just? Because I think it's much closer to an administration policy of "fuck the immigrants" than anything else.