3 ms·
Physical modelling peaked in 1993 with the Yamaha VL1 - which was an amazing synth that crashed right into the uncanny valley between sampling and real instrume
by TheOtherHobbes 7y ago
Physical modelling peaked in 1993 with the Yamaha VL1 - which was an amazing synth that crashed right into the uncanny valley between sampling and real instruments.
PM is a complete nightmare to program - even harder than FM. Which was why the VL1 was a preset-only machine. The full programmimng system was never made public.
There are some modern remakes in the box, especially from TAS, but IMO they don't sound as impressive.
The appeal of analog isn't just the sound, it's the conceptual simplicity. Ditto for sampling. Almost anyone with an average-ish IQ can understand the basics.
There are plenty of alternative synthesis techniques, but they're not popular because most people find they're too much effort for too little reward.
PM, modal, spectral, and straight additive can all make some very wild sounds, but - ironically - they don't sound like most people's idea of a synthesizer, so they're used much less often, and usually only by people who are hardcore sound programming nerds.
- CuriouslyC 7y agoWhile I agree with you in the context of making synth sounds, I just wanted to note that physical modelling is amazing for real instruments if done right. For example, take MODO bass - none of the sample based solutions come close.
- arvinsim 7y ago> The appeal of analog isn't just the sound, it's the conceptual simplicity. Ditto for sampling. Almost anyone with an average-ish IQ can understand the basics. But software can still the same, right? Albeit with a lot of distractions.