4 ms·
There is not complete price transparency. The shop claims the normal price is higher than it actually is, in order to make the discount seem more attractive. Th
by mcv 7y ago
There is not complete price transparency. The shop claims the normal price is higher than it actually is, in order to make the discount seem more attractive. That is deception, and therefore not transparency.
If only the final price mattered, shops wouldn't be advertising such discounts.
- lotsofpulp 7y agoThe only purpose of a discount is to make the buyer feel better. If they changed the price without labeling it a discount, the buyer’s utility of the item doesn’t change, but they’re feeling good about it does. I’d rather see education in schools teaching people that discounts are sales tactics that should be ignored rather than laws governing discounts, which would be costlier to implement and enforce.
- mcv 7y agoIt makes the buyer feel better because the buyer gets intentionally misinformed about the value of the item. That lies can make someone feel good does not necessarily make the lie okay. (I suppose it might in some circumstances, but I don't think trying to manipulate someone into spending money is one of those circumstances.) If you think discounts are completely meaningless, then completely banning advertising with discounts is very easy to implement and enforce. Much easier than to properly educate everybody how to arm themselves against deceptive sales practices (though I agree it would be nice if we could do that).
- lotsofpulp 7y agoThe value of an item is decided at the time an agreement is made between a seller and buyer. There is no one size fits all "value" until then. This can easily be seen in goods such as low volume, high margin goods such as land, vehicles, heavy equipment, intellectual property, and of course, labor. However, in the developed world, logistics and supply chains have sufficiently developed to allow for minuscule margins on many everyday, low price items that make it uneconomical to negotiate the value of each item to each buyer, so the seller just lists one price for everyone. In markets in poorer countries, the seller might not do that, and it might be worth their time to negotiate each sale. If they say to one buyer "I'll sell this to you for 50% off today, and charges him the same price as yesterday, and the buyer agrees to buy", who is harmed? Price discrimination is a natural part of markets, and the only reason it hasn't been happening is because it wasn't worth the retailers time in the US. But with automated systems coming into place, there is no more labor cost and so it's becoming economical to price discriminate again.
- mcv 7y agoIf you want to get technical about it, the value is determined by the market, by the forces of supply and demand. Advertising with a fake discount suggests that the market was willing to pay more for the product than it actually was. Most products are actually sold with a one size fits all price. People don't haggle over every single item they buy in a shop.
- lotsofpulp 7y agoThe market does not pay for anything. Individual buyers pay for things, and individual buyers and sellers determine the value of items, at a certain place, at a certain time. Most everyday items are sold “one size fits all” (but not in large quantities) in developed countries (since the seller's time is valuable enough to offset the extra revenue (or loss) from price discrimination), but there are quite a few places in the world where people still haggle over the price of tomatoes and onions. But even in the developed world, once you move beyond low margin retail items that are not expiring goods, there is no single sale price. Sometimes price discriminating turns off more customers than the revenue it generates or the labor it costs the seller, so it doesn't make sense for a seller to do it. Sometimes it's worth it, so some sellers might.
- mcv 7y agoDo we really need to deconstruct all of economics here? The market consists of those individual buyers and sellers. But they set the value together. No single buyer can set the value of the items they want to buy in the supermarket. They buy them or they don't buy them. In response to that, the seller adjusts the price. If not enough people buy it, the seller lowers the price, if he runs out too fast, he raises the price. That is "the market" determining the price in a free market. So if a potential buyer sees something 70% discounted, that implies that originally, the market determined that higher price as a fair price: a price that at least some buyers would pay for this item. The buyer trusts the market that that is apparently a fair price, but today the buyer is in luck, because it's been discounted to below the usual market price! If the seller advertises with a fake discount, he's betraying the buyer's trust in the free market by intentionally lying about what the market is willing to pay for this item.
- TeMPOraL 7y ago> I’d rather see education in schools teaching people that discounts are sales tactics that should be ignored "I'd rather see education in schools teaching people that $instances-of-abuse are members of $family-of-methods-of-abuse that one should protect themselves against". Funny how for almost everything else, the abuse itself is considered both illegal and morally repugnant, yet abusive sales tactics are legally above board and the profession itself is considered respectable.
- lotsofpulp 7y agoWhere is the abuse? A seller has the right to sell at whatever price they want (assuming non emergency situations). If I'm a seller, I can raise the price 100% at 10AM, and then put a sign that says 70% off. And then the next day, I can reduce the price 100%. The very use of ambiguous wording is a signal that it's a sales tactic. No one advertises 50% off the median average sale price in the past 30 days, because then it would be abuse. But that's not what any seller advertises. Stating that someone else saved Y dollars is also ambiguous. Saved compared to what? Booking.com claiming so and so is selling out quickly! What is quickly defined as? Until there are falsifiable metrics being falsified, I don't see what the abuse is.
- TeMPOraL 7y agoYou say elsewhere in the thread; you and others use discounts because it's a psychological trick that makes buyers feel good - and thus more likely to buy. > If I'm a seller, I can raise the price 100% at 10AM, and then put a sign that says 70% off. And then the next day, I can reduce the price 100%. Sure, you can do that. Or, you could simply list the price that lets you have some margin while still being competitive. Why would you do the former rather than the latter? Only because of a clear intent to abuse the customer. > Booking.com claiming so and so is selling out quickly! What is quickly defined as? Words have meanings. I can't tell you what exactly "quickly" is defined, but I believe everyone reasonable would assume it's something around minutes to hours in this particular business. Ask yourself, what would you assume? > Until there are falsifiable metrics being falsified, I don't see what the abuse is. I.e. until there's a clear and unambiguous statement that turns out to be purposefully false, you don't see a problem? Most lies aren't using clear and unambiguous language precisely because that makes them easier to spot; it doesn't change the fact that the intent is malicious towards your fellow human beings.