7 ms·
G20 nations triple coal power subsidies despite climate crisis
- rlpb 7y agoIt's a shame this journalist doesn't seem to have investigated at all why these governments have increased coal subsidies. Surely there's a reason, and it's the reason that needs political support to tackle.
- DennisP 7y agoA better question is to forget about "governments" and ask why politicians have voted for these subsidies. But the answer will probably be depressingly familiar.
- chumali 7y agoIt's a combination of reasons present to different degrees depending on the nation in question. These include: The political fallout of allowing these industries to fail (coal production and power generation make up a large portion of economic activity in many rural regions, with workers in these industries having little transferable skills.) Strong protectionist incentives given that coal power is relatively cheap and can enable lower costs in energy intensive industries such as steel manufacturing. Security of supply - having some domestic capacity is always preferable to being totally reliant on imports. Opportunity cost - emissions tariffs have generally been on the increase so it makes sense to pollute whilst it's still relatively cheap.
- Angostura 7y agoI can think of at least one hypothetical, which is good news, related to security of supply: With an ever-shrinking share of the market, coal is no longer financially sustainable - the stations are only used in times of absolute need. They are usually off, but the government pays to keep them available.
- benj111 7y agoGood point, it's relatively easy to get to 70/80/90% renewables. Its that one week in January, where its cold, the wind isnt blowing, it's cloudy and your nuclear reactor is down for whatever reason. But most countries seem to be shifting to gas away from coal in the short term, wouldn't gas generation be better for that kind of situation, ie if you have mothballed gas and coal generation, why keep the coal around?
- AstralStorm 7y agoGas is no better than coal from climate PoV, and it is much harder to source locally in many countries.
- benj111 7y agoNo but its better from a start up quickly point of view? I don't really know anything about the startup procedure for a power station that's been off for 6 months, I would guess gas is easier?/quicker? I'm unsure if its better from a storage point of view. Yes you can pile up coal in a field, but I'd prefer a tank of gas. And there should be infrastructure for storage left after households move away from gas heating. I'm speaking from a UK POV, the model would seem to hold for Europe and North America at least.
- cygx 7y agoNaively, replacing coal with gas will decrease CO2 emissions by 40%. Not sure how this changes once you factor in supply chains, etc.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- tialaramex 7y agoNope. Gas is _much_ better than coal from a climate POV. Natural gas is basically methane, CH4, when you burn it you're making CO2 and H2O (water) and you get energy out from both these changes. But coal is much nastier, not only is there nitrogen and sulfur in there (which are both going to produce poisonous gases you'll need to do something about) but the ratio of carbon to hydrogen is much worse so we produce far more CO2 for the same amount of energy production. Shutting coal plants and building gas plants instead makes a big difference. Not enough of a difference to prevent catastrophic climate change, but a big step in the right direction compared to subsidising coal.
- SECProto 7y agoIn the case of Japan, it's because they don't want to restart any nuclear plants post-fukushima. Similar to Germany coal usage increasing as they phased out nuclear plants. This is the most important reason for these two countries.
- cygx 7y agoThe increase in Germany was only temporary, though. We hit a low point in '09, and a high point in '13 (but still below levels of '07). Coal usage has gone down ever since, and we're currently at a new low.
- SECProto 7y agoThanks! I wasn't sure on the details. Germany also has (or at least had) huge incentives for renewable energy production, so it wasn't meant as a critique. Just wanted to note one source of increase that OP hadn't mentioned
- tootie 7y agoAn energy shortage would politically and economically catastrophic. They can either invest a known amount into fossil fuels and get a known outcome or invest a huge amount into renewables and get a variable outcome.
- dagw 7y agoYou're changing the terms of the debate, we're not talking fossil fuels vs renewables, we're talking why are they choosing specifically coal over all other options.
- pjc50 7y agoUnderlying reports are linked, which is nice, and they're even CC licensed: https://www.odi.org/sites/odi.org.uk/files/resource-documents/12745.pdf https://www.odi.org/sites/odi.org.uk/files/resource-document... and https://www.odi.org/sites/odi.org.uk/files/resource-documents/12744.pdf https://www.odi.org/sites/odi.org.uk/files/resource-document... The "why" and "how" are more complex. The figures include lending as well as direct subsidy. Both China and India have been building at a high rate. > With regard to domestic public finance identified, India provided the highest amount of support identified by far, at US$10.6 billion per year (2016–2017 average). However, it must be noted that these findings are not directly comparable between countries; one reason behind such high numbers in India is that its banking system is dominated by government-owned banks which were nationalised in the 1960s and 1980s. These banks, despite being majority government-owned, operate predominantly as commercial entities rather than as banks driven by government policy > In its National Electricity Plan, India still foresees new capacity additions for coal – 45.9 GW from 2017–2027 – but this is dwarfed by planned additions for renewable energy, with 275 GW targeted by 2027 (CEA, 2018)
- HaukeHi 7y agoI made a spreadsheet here comparing comparing countries climate policies including fossil fuel subsidies: https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/e/2PACX-1vTaPmBiFIbPqzc1KLWHDgFVESLw9Ay7TtGGoDlIeza1XPpFPi5Abv7_nl1yLsImqBQozEgbi6O1klE_/pubhtml# https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/e/2PACX-1vTaPmBiFIbPq...
- H8crilA 7y agoFor what it's worth, China is actually more CO2 efficient compared to Western nations at similar levels of development in the past: https://www.economist.com/graphic-detail/2019/05/25/china-is-surprisingly-carbon-efficient-but-still-the-worlds-biggest-emitter https://www.economist.com/graphic-detail/2019/05/25/china-is...
- ptaipale 7y agoNot surprising at all, considering that Western nations have been leading the walk on the path of technical development, from discovering the benefits of things like coal, to the discovery of downsides of things like coal. Therefore I would call this comparison anachronistic in the literal sense. One can of course always say that developing nations have a right to emit just because rich 1st world countries emitted in the past. But the outcome of this is huge emissions. And China is building a lot of coal. In any case, I don't expect the efforts to limit CO2 emissions to make much difference globally. Coal that can be easily burned will be burned. What we need to concentrate on is how we are going to deal with it.
- vonmoltke 7y agoThe wrench in that analysis is that Western nation's used to direct burn coal and oil for many purposes that are now unnecessary due to technological innovation. If China had to exclusively use things like steam locomotives, coal furnaces, and oil-fired boilers for its current level of industrialization, it would be putting out just as much per capital as the US and UK 120 years ago.
- taf2 7y agoThat's good news but didn't they just finish putting more CO2 into the atmosphere then all developed countries combined over 100 year in like the last 10 years? https://www.forbes.com/sites/rrapier/2018/07/01/china-emits-more-carbon-dioxide-than-the-u-s-and-eu-combined/#2114269b628c https://www.forbes.com/sites/rrapier/2018/07/01/china-emits-... https://www.nytimes.com/2018/01/25/business/china-davos-climate-change.html https://www.nytimes.com/2018/01/25/business/china-davos-clim...
- 7y ago
- HaukeHi 7y agoThe importance of fossil fuel subsidy reform is overstated. Burning fossils fuels causes climate change, which has costs estimated to be in the trillions.[133] Some people refer to these negative externalities are “subsidies for fossil fuel”[134]. Perhaps it’s fair to refer to the amount untaxed negative externalities as ‘subsidies’, but some people might think that these ‘trillions in subsidies’ refer to funds in government budgets to directly lower the price of fossil fuels that could simply be cut.[135] But direct government support and tax breaks for fossil fuels that could be cut amounts to ‘only’ about $330 billion per year globally, according to a new study in Nature.[136] This means that unfortunately, fossil fuel subsidy reform will not increase the price of fossil fuels by trillions, because negative externalities (e.g. climate change and disease) make up most of these trillion dollar figures. Would cutting these—still considerable—subsidies reduce emissions substantially? The Nature study suggests that global subsidy removal would only lead to a small, 1%–5% decrease in global CO₂ emissions. Only a small share of this can be influenced by policy in advanced economies: There are $43 billion in subsidies, amounting to 13% of global subsidies, within Europe, North America, and the Pacific OECD, and this number is not projected to grow much in the future. In fact, EU member states and G7 nations have pledged to end fossil fuel subsidies by 2020 and 2025 respectively (although they are currently not on track to fulfill this pledge).[137] Advanced economies might be able to use their influence to push fossil fuel subsidy reform in emerging economies, but this would be hard because even though it would have many benefits,[138] they are nevertheless often seen as regressive[139]. The Nature study has been criticized[140] for leaving out some subsidies, such as capacity market payments to ensure the constant electricity supply, public finance, and investment by state-owned fossil fuel enterprises. Others estimate subsidies in European countries alone to be $138 billion a year.[141] But even if we were to use these higher estimates to naively extrapolate them to get a rough upper bound of the direct government support in all advanced economies, then this number would probably not be much higher than the $330 billion. Thus, advocacy for subsidy reform in advanced economies is unlikely to reduce emissions by much more than 5%. Because phasing out these minor subsidies is theoretically equivalent to a very small tax on carbon, it will not substantially stimulate the kind of energy innovation that could spill over to emerging economies. Thus, the net benefits of advocacy might be lower than other policy areas. Reducing emissions by 5% is not insignificant and worth promoting, especially if broad support can be garnered from both environmentalist and libertarian camps to end support of fossil fuel subsidies. Also, any country can unilaterally cut their fossil fuel consumption without the need for international coordination. But because the world must lower emissions to zero or even negative emissions soon,[142] phasing out fossil fuel subsidies can only be a small part of the answer. It is not the silver bullet some advocates claim. All citations and more effective climate policies can be found at: https://lets-fund.org/clean-energy/#h.jf0xbaac5xn6 https://lets-fund.org/clean-energy/#h.jf0xbaac5xn6
- mparramon 7y agoAnd then people complain when these things happen: https://www.dw.com/en/coal-protests-in-germany-climate-activists-storm-garzweiler-mine/a-49313892 https://www.dw.com/en/coal-protests-in-germany-climate-activ...
- adrianN 7y agoI wonder when this[1] stops being satire. [1] https://www.theonion.com/last-ditch-climate-change-report-provides-locations-of-1835244382 https://www.theonion.com/last-ditch-climate-change-report-pr...
- passiveincomelg 7y agoNuke the site from orbit. It's the only way to be sure.
- jandrese 7y agoGotta use Nukes, they're the green bomb. No CO2 release.
- londons_explore 7y agoI'm actually pro making carbon emissions tariffs, and then subsidising coal. The subsidy can be made the same size as the tariff, but reduce over time. It also gives the coal plants a massive incentive to look for ways to increase efficiency. If they can generate slightly more power from the same amount of emissions, they will make lots more money.
- madez 7y agoWhy give the opportunity to the coal plants but not everyone else? What you are proposing is again a favouribly treatment of coal plants, and we desperately need to make life difficult for them. We could, however, introduce a general carbon emission tariff without exception but ramp it up instead of introducing it fully at once.
- WhompingWindows 7y agoWhy would you ever give aid to the dirtiest source of electricity? Coal use will accelerate future catastrophes and cost WAY more long-term than any meager benefits until 2030 or whenever they are banned. It's simply immoral to suggest coal subsidies. Renewables are much cheaper and far better for the planet and local air pollution. Anyone who is willing to give anything to coal at this point is selling 1000's of years of emissions for 5-10 years of coal-worker and coal-owner subsidy. It's disgraceful coal still gets subsidies.
- Robotbeat 7y agoSubsidize all energy (most effectively through subsidized loan guarantees on the supply side but with off-setting cash for consumers on the demand side) but provide massive tariffs on emissions. Way more effective.
- agentultra 7y agoClimate apocalypse. We have approximately 4-5 years left to mobilize massive de-carbonation in order to stave off the worst effects of climate change [0]. It's already too late to avoid 2C warming. Even if we stopped instantly today the feedback loops have been in gear for years. Small, incremental changes are not what I was hoping for. [0] https://www.earth.com/news/5-years-mitigate-climate-change/ https://www.earth.com/news/5-years-mitigate-climate-change/
- whamlastxmas 7y agoI don't think it's proper to take a single person's interpretation and present it as fact. This hyperbole is what makes people on the fence about climate change roll their eyes and disregard it.
- pier25 7y agoI don't think agentultra is being hyperbolic. There is a great uncertainty about feedbacks. It may very well be the case that we don't even have 5 years and we have already passed the point of no return. Even disregarding that, the 2ºC statement is also very probable. See my comments from the other day: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20256598 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20256598
- whamlastxmas 7y agoIt may also very well be the case a meteor strikes earth before I finish writing this comment and kills us all. My point is that debate about climate change needs to come from generally accepted perspectives based on concrete data and interpretations. Instead we have millions of people shouting and parroting unsubstantiated opinions that originated from a single person who's obviously very biased in their perspective. Playing "what if" all day and talking about doomsdays isn't going to help. I don't understand why there isn't a greater focus on the thousands of people who are dying every year right now from pollution caused by fossil fuels. This is undeniable and very actionable and easy to get behind.
- perfunctory 7y agoAdjusting your lifestyle and behaviour in line with climate goals is not about making a difference. It's about being a decent person. You don't throw litter into the street even though it's a drop in the ocean. You don't bully somebody just because everybody else does, even though it makes little difference. You do the things you do because you are a good decent person. If you know about climate change and you still fly, invest in fossil fuel, consume extravagantly [edit: or anything you know has a large impact and you could reasonably do without (no, I don't know how to define reasonable in this context)] you are just a bad person. Sorry. edit2: I am just saying this because I am desperate. And scared.
- SketchySeaBeast 7y agoWhy stop there? Are you currently using solar power? Do you use the bus instead of walking? What's your food habits - do you eat meat? What clothes are you currently wearing? Where do you live? How large is it? Does it need heating or air conditioning? You're drawing the "this makes an awful person" line at a super arbitrary point.
- coldpie 7y agoThose are all perfectly valid questions when making such a value judgment, yes. We're past the point of no return, here. Everything matters.
- perfunctory 7y agoI was expecting a reply along these lines. Just because you don't kill yourself to eliminate all emissions doesn't mean you shouldn't try to do what you can.
- SketchySeaBeast 7y agoI'm just saying - you're a bad person. Sorry.
- lordfoom 7y ago
- eiji 7y agoWhenever I talk to (privileged) people here in the US about this, I try to bring one point across. As a whole, people are in too much pain and stress to have any appreciation for a climate crisis. Whatever you may think, as a whole, people have to deal (personally and emotionally) with (sometimes perceived) much bigger crisis than that of the climate. As long as people live pay-check to pay-check on the brink of no health-insurance, the brink of missing mortgage- or rent-payments and ending on the streets, the brink of high medical bills, the brink of 15k a year preschool expenses, the brink of retirement ... There is always a crisis stressing people out because there is nothing but yourself to fall back on in the event of a disaster. And since nobody is politically (dare I say globally) willing to provide relief for such kind of warranted fears and concerns for ones individual future, people have to room to spend more on the perma frost, Florida homes or an underwater New York.
- hannob 7y ago> Whatever you may think, as a whole, people have to deal (personally and emotionally) with (sometimes perceived) much bigger crisis than that of the climate. That is... until they have to evacuate their home, because there's a wildfire or hurricane nearby or the rising sealevel makes it unsafe.
- nicoburns 7y agoA lot of the climate change movements have very progressive politics that addresses some of these issues too. Of course this often isn't palatable to (economically) privileged people, as it means them giving up some of that economic power. But ultimately, I can't see how the climate issues will be solved any other way.
- gingabriska 7y agoI think the bigger problem is that everyone wants certain kind of lifestyle of which they are inspired from Instagram/youtubers Even if there was no Instagram or YouTube, we'll still have companies bringing American product to local market and promising better life tho this is amplified exponentially through social media now. But we must ask ourselves, how many people sporting millionaire lifestyle can this earth take? No matter where I go, every student is reading the art of hustle, rich dad poor dad, fake it till you make it, dreaming of renting ferraris, living in vilas and jet setting everywhere around the globe, buying whatever they want whenever they want to do some cool thing similar to fidget spinner. Now, as India and China are growing coming online, everyone there is also inspired by American habits, look at the 3d printing channels, so many channels from developing countries are copying their American counterparts and printing so much ABS/PETG. Now this is simply an example. It's human tendency to copy those who you think are better than you in your limited worldview. It is justified in mind easily. So we must ask, can this planet afford everyone to live like an American millionaire? Edit: Downvotes are raining on me. I am not against America or India or even china, you can replace them with any developed - developing country pair. I am simply saying at present, planet can't ensure same lifestyle for everyone without destroying itself. Yes, with technological advancement and political will, it will be possible in future, but are we forgetting the article we are commenting on.
- vikramkr 7y agoYes if we innovate our way there. We cannot ever stop the human desire for a better life not should we, the power of mankind lies in our ability to innovate around d challenges. We fixed the ban population crisis with the green revolution. New energy sources like nuclear can give everyone the quality of life they desire and deserve. Asteroid mining can be a revolutionary source of resources. And we don't know what humans could invent next. But we need to support science and education to make this future happen
- igor47 7y agoah the extreme techno-optimist position. > We cannot ever stop the human desire for a better life not should we i think the goal is to redefine what a better life looks like. like, maybe it's not one of increasing consumption, but one of community and connection and ecological harmony.
- pier25 7y agoWhile 150+ years of GHG emissions have put us in a terrible situation, reducing emissions or even reaching zero emissions will not solve climate change much like removing your foot from the accelerator would not prevent a car crash. The current 415ppm of CO2 in the atmosphere will break havoc for centuries to an unknown extent. Self sustaining climatic systems have already been triggered (Arctic ice, methane, etc) and due to climate lag the changes we are seeing in the climate today are from the emissions from about 40 years ago. Bad news is we have emitted more GHG in the last 40 years than the previous 150 years before that. Finally we don't really know for sure how much warming there is today since the cooling effects of aerosols have been difficult to calculate, and there is some debate whether the preindustrial baseline picked by the IPCC is correct. We could already be at 2ºC of warming today. If anyone wants links of all that just ask.
- perfunctory 7y agoI agree with most of this but I find the analogy with a car crash quite misleading. There will be no specific point in time in the future when we will fall off a cliff. It will just get progressively worse. What we can do is slow the worsening down and give ourselves and future generations more time to adapt.
- pier25 7y agoThere are definitely climate "cliffs". See climate tipping points for example that could lead us into a runaway greenhouse effect. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tipping_points_in_the_climate_system https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tipping_points_in_the_climate_... https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Runaway_greenhouse_effect https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Runaway_greenhouse_effect