4 ms·
Hasn't the math already been done? There's just not enough sunlight exposure to get anywhere near the power requirements for a mid-sized vehicle. You end up wi
by manigandham 7y ago
Hasn't the math already been done? There's just not enough sunlight exposure to get anywhere near the power requirements for a mid-sized vehicle.
You end up with tiny boxes on wheels covered in very expensive
and fragile panels that only work in perfectly bright and sunny days. Impacts, accidents, maintenance, and manufacturing externalities are all against this approach.
- walrus01 7y agoYes, and even if you were to cover something with the surface area of a Tesla model S in triple junction GaAs pv cells, and park it in direct sun all day, you might collect a cumulative 25kWh of charge in a whole month. Basically the same as 25% of a single charge of the car. If you want to have a pv powered electric car, install twenty 370W panels (72 x 156mm high efficiency monocrystallin silicon each) on your roof and feed the local grid utility. Solar powered cars such as you see racing across Australia are special ultra lightweight research projects, stripped down to the bare minimum, and with motors/gearing that results in a time of something like 30 seconds for 0 to 100km/h. If you want to do the rough math on an absolute perfect case for kWh per month, go to the NREL pvwatts tool online, plug in the numbers for a theoretical 1000W pv array (same as 4 x 250W panels) at your location. Look at the cumulative kWh production estimate per month. This would assume that the car spends 100% of its time outdoors in the sunlight.
- Retric 7y agoThat math is very wrong. A model 3 sized car is ~2m x 5m and has room for side panels. At 20% efficiency that’s ~2kw in direct sunlight. Ignore panel cost and 40+% efficiency is possible for ~4kW in sunlight. Now at highway speeds that only adds up to edit: ~8 to 17% increased range which is hardly worth the expense. Exactly, how much of a car you can cover in panels and how much time it sits in shade or garage makes this less appealing. But, getting ~50 miles of useful range per day at reasonable cost in ideal conditions is very possible.
- walrus01 7y agoI think you will find that if you put the effective non-glass surface area of a model 3 in direct sunlight... Half of the car will be in shade. Half of the car will be angled at a less than optimal angle (such as 35 degree fixed tilt, aimed directly south, for a ground mounted PV install). I would be extremely surprised if a model 3 or S covered in PV cells produced anywhere near 2000W in direct sunlight. My best estimate is that it's a really charitable back of the napkin figure to say that a model S sized vehicle with every square cm available of body panel covered in PV cells might be equivalent to four 250W panels. The math is, roughly, and this is output from 30 seconds with the pvwatts tool. This is for a fixed ground mount or roof mount array of 4 x 250W panels, tilted at 20 degrees aimed directly south. Not on a car. Worst month of the year, december: 97kWh produced Best month of the year, july, 165 kWh produced. Screenshot: https://imgur.com/a/OcK8z2b https://imgur.com/a/OcK8z2b Keep in mind, that production estimate is for four panels that have unobstructed view to the sky 24x7 for a month, and begin receiving sunlight as soon as the sun comes up in the morning, and keep receiving it every minute of the day until the sun sets. Every day for a month. Not how you would see a car used. Probably a lot less than that, since any high efficiency PV cells are not curved, and if you're talking about surfaces that are curved in more than one axis, that entirely rules out using big 156mm monocrystalline Si cells. And there's no way in hell that anyone can afford to be using 33% efficient space grade GaAs PV cells on a car. Ignore the panel cost? Have you ever actually priced gallium arsenide triple junction PV cells? If you have actually installed and put into use an off grid PV system and watched its output through a whole solar day, you would understand.
- Retric 7y agoThat’s assuming you’re stuck with the shape of a model 3 rather than building a model 3 sized car. The aerodynamics suck, but a VW camper had basically a flat roof on top of a rectangle. The roof is not going to have an ideal tilt, but side panels will provide real value. In reality you are not stuck with full sized panels so as long as you avoid long curves you can still have a reasonable shape. PS: Fairly high efficiency flexible pannels are also available. https://portamaxpower.com/products/330-watt-high-efficiency-lightweight-flexible-solar-panel/ https://portamaxpower.com/products/330-watt-high-efficiency-... Which you can use in some areas to have a more aerodynamic design without sacrificing much solar efficiency.
- tonyedgecombe 7y agoThere's just not enough sunlight exposure to get anywhere near the power requirements for a mid-sized vehicle Using that logic we shouldn't build a single power station because it doesn't cover the power requirements of the whole country.
- dx7tnt 7y agoYou can't use that logic, because the two aren't even equivalent.
- tonyedgecombe 7y agoThe solar panel on the roof of that car is there to generate electricity just as much as a power station is. The difference is scale.
- thedrbrian 7y agoBut a power plant is small compared to the city it powers,solar panels on the roof of the car however.........
- justaguyhere 7y agoYeah, but solar farms are typically located in areas where there is abundant sunlight through out the year, not the same for cars
- manigandham 7y agoScale brings efficiencies, and this is especially evident in power generation. A basic solar roof installation delivers far more power with more reliability. Also everything has trade-offs and the massively increased costs, manufacturing effort and maintenance requirements are certainly not worth it compared to current electric vehicles. Are you really going to pay $200k for this vehicle with low performance and amenities, high repair costs, and no guarantee that it can ever really power itself - only for the potential to save a few hundred in electricity costs?