4 ms·
A WebGL canvas-based volume viewer
- Lichtso 7y agoScreenshots and demo videos would help a lot
- macawfish 7y agoWow! It feels fast and looks great. I'm still waiting for someone to make a WebGL viewer for SSVDAGs, but maybe that's wishful thinking.
- est31 7y ago> This software license is the 2-clause BSD license > plus clause a third clause that prohibits redistribution for commercial purposes without further permission. https://github.com/AllenInstitute/volume-viewer/blob/master/LICENSE.txt https://github.com/AllenInstitute/volume-viewer/blob/master/... I really like what the allen institute is doing and that they put so many interesting talks onto their YouTube channel, but clauses like this make it proprietary software.
- eps 7y agoNo, it most certainly does not. Stop with this nonsense. This makes this software ineligible to be called "open source" as per OSI definition. That's it. The world is not binary. Not everything that 100% free and open is proprietary. If it's not an OSI-approved license, but the source is open and avaialble for tinkering, changing and redistribution, even if conditionally, the altruistic spirit is still there and it's still an approach that is welcoming of a typical O/S use. However this also allows authors to reserve rights for commercializing their work later on and it's an absolutely fair arrangement. No reason to denigrate their work because of that.
- mkl 7y ago> For purposes of this license, commercial purposes is the incorporation of the Allen Institute's software into anything for which you will charge fees or other compensation. That seems like something best avoided. All kinds of things could be considered compensation, so I think it probably prevents a lot of open source project types. It seems like this may exclude quite a few funding models, for example. I agree it's not technically proprietary, but that doesn't necessarily make it usable (edit: for open projects, I mean).
- pfortuny 7y ago“Other compensation”... Can I use it for a student’s degree project?
- MaulingMonkey 7y agoIANAL, but I think so. You're not charging "1 degree" for your trouble. That said, neither you nor the school would be able to charge $$$ to cover redistribution costs for a CD containing your project, which sounds incredibly easy to run afoul of.
- PyroLagus 7y agoI suppose this is quite relevant here: https://words.steveklabnik.com/the-culture-war-at-the-heart-of-open-source https://words.steveklabnik.com/the-culture-war-at-the-heart-... > However this also allows authors to reserve rights for commercializing their work later on and it's an absolutely fair arrangement. They could've also used AGPL for that. A popular option. The license says, "For purposes of this license, commercial purposes is the incorporation of the Allen Institute's software into anything for which you will charge fees or other compensation." Does that include ads? It certainly seems to include donations. And I suppose requiring attribution could be seen as "other compensation". It's kinda broad, but even if it was strictly "don't sell this standalone", it still wouldn't be FOSS or open source imo. It's fine for studying the code, but it's not any better than "source available" software, such as UE4. And if do study the code, you'll have the same legal landmines to deal with as when studying "source available" code. I'd even say that UE4's license is better, because at least it doesn't cause confusion over whether it's open source. > No reason to denigrate their work because of that. I don't think anyone did. They just said it's not open source, which seems like a fair assessment to me. Saying that Windows isn't open source doesn't denigrate Microsoft's work either. Open source doesn't mean good, and proprietary doesn't mean bad. This volume-viewer just isn't open source, regardless of its quality.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- ihnorton 7y agoIf that's an issue, there are several other browser-based volume renderers with unrestricted BSD/MIT-style licenses: - https://github.com/maartenbreddels/ipyvolume https://github.com/maartenbreddels/ipyvolume - https://github.com/Kitware/vtk-js https://github.com/Kitware/vtk-js - https://github.com/FNNDSC/ami https://github.com/FNNDSC/ami (~successor to the excellent XTK: https://github.com/xtk/X https://github.com/xtk/X)
- dmt-gfx 7y agoThat code is used in the Allen Institute's online 3d cell image catalog seen here: https://www.allencell.org/cell-feature-explorer.html https://www.allencell.org/cell-feature-explorer.html and also in the 3d data explorer contained in this presentation: https://imsc.allencell.org/ https://imsc.allencell.org/