5 ms·
> My fear is that we take a big sledgehammer to the fossil fuel industry and infrastructure, and in so doing also take a big sledgehammer to our entire economy.
by AnthonyMouse 7y ago
> My fear is that we take a big sledgehammer to the fossil fuel industry and infrastructure, and in so doing also take a big sledgehammer to our entire economy. So big in fact that we face a generational backlash against de-carbonizing.
It still seems like the best solution is a revenue-neutral carbon tax, i.e. a carbon tax which is merely refunded to everyone in the form of a fixed tax credit.
Then the average person pays e.g. $5000 in carbon tax but receives a $5000 tax credit. But the person who burns a disproportionate amount of carbon pays $7000 and still only receives the $5000 credit, meanwhile someone who burns less carbon pays only $2000 and actually turns a profit after the tax credit.
Then we don't need all of this command and control. People have the right incentives, so they buy electric cars and heat pumps and solar panels, and the problem solves itself. The only real thing you have to tweak is the amount of the tax/credit, to adjust the trade off between being too fast/disruptive and too slow/ineffective.
- dragonwriter 7y ago> It still seems like the best solution is a revenue-neutral carbon tax, i.e. a carbon tax which is merely refunded to everyone in the form of a fixed tax credit. A revenue neutral carbon tax means that government is dependent for funding for operations (or, if you follow MMP, “is dependent for extracting sufficient money from the economy for the current degree of inflation control”) on continued carbon emissions at the present level.
- AnthonyMouse 7y ago> A revenue neutral carbon tax means that government is dependent for funding for operations (or, if you follow MMP, “is dependent for extracting sufficient money from the economy for the current degree of inflation control”) on continued carbon emissions at the present level. Not if the amount of the tax credit in a given year is tied to the amount of revenue the tax generates, i.e. it remains revenue-neutral. Then it automatically phases itself out as less carbon is burned.
- cavisne 7y agoRevenue neutral carbon taxes are a fantasy, because they are pushed by progressive politicians, yet are deeply regressive in their impact. Inslee admits this, and simply wants to add a new tax, and refund it selectively to people who he thinks deserve the money/access to electricity, and outlaw the use cases which don't. Purely coincidentally this is the same effect as making the tax system more progressive, but actually it's all about climate change.
- millstone 7y agoRevenue neutral carbon taxes are the most pro-market, libertarian friendly answer thus far to the reality of climate change. They're pushed by progressive politicians only because of the factual urgency of climate change. The USA can limp along with shitty healthcare forever, but irreversible climate damage is irreversible, and we don't have time for the partisan bullshit. The high order bit is the complete disengagement from the American right on this issue. The carbon-tax-with-dividend is meant to be table stakes. The onus is on the other side to show up to the table at all.
- briandear 7y agoIt’s partisan bullshit when you don’t agree with the opposition. However, I prefer to say it’s “principled opposition.” We on the right don’t accept the premise that the sky is falling. We’ve been told by politicians that the earth has 12 years left if we “don’t act now!” However, we heard that 12 years ago. And 12 years before that. We are constantly being warned that we must act now. Just about 12 years ago Al Gore’s movie said that we would be suffering a massive catastrophe by now. Interestingly, his film used approximately 12 years as the timeline for how long Earth had before catastrophe struck. This whole movement is starting to seem like a religion, except heretics are no longer burned at the stake, lest an unnecessary amount of carbon be released.
- briandear 7y ago> Purely coincidentally this is the same effect as making the tax system more progressive, but actually it's all about climate change. Is it purely coincidental? My problem with climate activists is that they have the additional goal of redistributing wealth and the means of production as an end in itself. When climate activism becomes less about socialism and actually about the climate, then I will take the threat more seriously. There is a reason that most climate change policy is split on party lines. Conservatives don’t hate the environment any more than liberals love it, but the deep seated aims of the climate movement aren’t solely about climate, it’s about increasing government control of every aspect of a person’s life, using fear of catastrophe as the means. If the government can control how people use energy, they control everything, freedom disappears for the “greater good” of the climate. We saw this after 9-11: the fear of terrorism was used to convince people to give up freedom in exchange for security. Privacy and getting on airplanes faster was less important than not dying from terrorism. The government took significantly more power and people willingly gave it to them because terrorism. The Marxist roots of the climate movement are hard to dispute. When the Soviet Union fell, global warming suddenly became a thing. The pro-communist crowd pivoted to climate as a means to their ends. In the 1970s literally global cooling was the issue, then there was the ozone layer, the rainforests, whales — none of those issues involved an attempt to completely destroy capitalism. They were seemingly authentic concerns about the environment. But now, those in the climate movement “coincidentally” have progressive economic outcomes as goal. Even one of the UN officials a few years back stated that even if the climate issue wasn’t a thing, the redistribution of wealth was a positive outcome from climate policy. The fear of climate change is being used to promote the dismantling of capitalism. There is a reason the American communist party is very passionate about climate change policy while libertarians and conservatives aren’t. It isn’t like communists have any particular track record for caring about the environment, but it’s a useful tool by which they can bring about their desired economic change. Of course there are those here that will strongly disagree and claim that concern over climate change is purely altruistic, however unlike saving the whales, there are people getting extremely rich from this issue. Al Gore became a billionaire profiting from the very issue he helped promote. Green energy companies would love to destroy fossil fuels because that would give them all the power and money. Governments love the climate issue because they can use that to force people to live however they dictate or else people have to pay a lot of money in taxes which can then be used to expand the government and further control people. If feel like the majority of people concerned about the climate are authentic in their concern, but they are being used by political and economic interests. Useful idiots, to borrow a Soviet phrase.