3 ms·
The BART screeches with the worst of them (especially the trans bay tube — you basically can’t hold a conversation in it). I heard from someone that rode it wh
by hedora 7y ago
The BART screeches with the worst of them (especially the trans bay tube — you basically can’t hold a conversation in it).
I heard from someone that rode it when it was new that it used to be much, much quieter.
So, I’m not sure I buy that the current level of screeching is by design, and not due to lack of maintenance.
- Anechoic 7y agoBART's issue is track corrugation, and they've been fighting that for many decades now.
- saltcured 7y agoA confounding factor is that I think they have changed the typical operating speeds in many parts of the BART system over the years. Also, it isn't like the entire system is made up of 40-50 year old, original parts. Train cars, wheels, sections of rail, and maybe even bits of rail-bed have been added to the system, renovated, and/or replaced over the years. Qualitatively, I think that I have experienced similar painful noises in every decade since the late 1970s, when I was a little kid and my father worked for BART. In the early 1990s, I can remember people talking about how they sometimes got a quiet train or a loud train on a familiar commute. We had similar observations about different road surfaces put down by Caltrans. I tend to ride it at least once every 2-3 years during return visits. Also, at various places in the East Bay, weather depending, you can hear the early morning trains on at-grade or above-grade track from quite far away. I have heard very similar noises in recent years when visiting the same places, giving me a nostalgic kick as it sounded so familiar.