3 ms·
I'm really afraid that ML is mainly just going to become automated p-hacking, and bring about a dark age to much of science. In a publish or perish world, how
by monocasa 7y ago
I'm really afraid that ML is mainly just going to become automated p-hacking, and bring about a dark age to much of science. In a publish or perish world, how can you compete with someone with enough budget to set a bunch of models looking for any specious correlations in data sets and publishing what comes out the other end? Like we'll still have great breakthroughs from the top of the field, but a lot of grunt work style studies are going to lose their ability to be trusted.
- analog31 7y agoContributing to this problem is the fact that professors are grimly aware of needing to confer some marketable skills on their students. And ML is perceived as being a meal ticket right now.
- rramadass 7y ago>ML is mainly just going to become automated p-hacking, and bring about a dark age to much of science It is already happening. A lot of people who can contribute to actual Science are moving into AI/ML field for the money and the industry/media hype are reinforcing this. Everything is "Deep${NONSENSE}" nowadays whether it is relevant or not. As a beginner, when i started to learn NNs, i couldn't get past my initial hurdle on how to validate the results on actual real-world data. What Statistical metrics do i use to "know" that the blackbox is working correctly? What are the assumptions and limitations that i need to be aware of to understand and have faith in the output? Most people don't seem to know or care; it is "magic" to them. In a world awash with data, reckless application of NN models to any and every problem is only going to drown us in spurious results and muddying all Scientific endeavours.