6 ms·
On the other hand, look at how ridiculously powerful our computers are and they're still so slow. We've met orders of magnitude more computing power with orders
by AnIdiotOnTheNet 7y ago
On the other hand, look at how ridiculously powerful our computers are and they're still so slow. We've met orders of magnitude more computing power with orders of magnitude slower software.
- spacenick88 7y agoI hear this claim almost every day yet its been years since I've actually felt my normal work computers being slow. Hell, even booting an OS in an emulator running in a browser proper software still runs blazingly fast. It's just that some people seem to use an awful lot of terrible software but I don't seem to be one of those people
- AnIdiotOnTheNet 7y agoJust the other day there was a thread comparing start times for LibreOffice, where 3 seconds was considered good. Three seconds on modern hardware is a damned eternity. How much does LibreOffice do that Word 5.0 doesn't, really? Yet the latter would probably start inside an emulator faster than the former does natively.
- projektfu 7y agoMostly loading fonts and things.
- fao_ 7y ago> How much does LibreOffice do that Word 5.0 doesn't, really? It has to support and parse a billion more formats. Including the fact that MS word file formats are in some cases literal dumps from word's memory (iirc). Rendering things properly is also a difficult problem to solve. Look how difficult it has been for much of the 21st century, to get a webpage uniform across all major browsers, and then realised that you not only have to display the same across all major browsers, but also be 30 years backwards compatible.
- vetrom 7y agoOn a modern OS (like anything in the last 25-odd years that has demand paging) that code isn't even loaded into RAM before it's used in many situations. While that is an additional load if you deal with those formats, the root of things like startup and runtime bloat lie elsewhere.
- EmpirePhoenix 7y agoWell one should also consider, that a really large amount of code and complexity is that current applications properly do i18n.
- tremon 7y ago> support and parse a billion more formats > Rendering things properly These should not affect startup performance though.
- fao_ 7y agoWhen do you want to incur the overhead? Do you want a user to wait once for 40 seconds, or wait 10 extra seconds for something to load/save because you're loading shit on the fly. It's a question of trade-offs.
- linguae 7y agoLibreOffice and its predecessors (OpenOffice and StarOffice) have always been considered bloated for as long as I could remember, which is nearly 20 years. While I'm very grateful for having a free, open source office suite, I've always found OpenOffice and LibreOffice to be rather clunky no matter what platform I'm using. This is especially true on macOS where a lot of the UI elements of LibreOffice don't fit in with regular Mac applications, although thankfully things have progressed from the days of having to run the even-slower NeoOffice on Mac OS X Tiger, which used the Java runtime (I remember it taking up to 15 seconds to load on my 1.83GHz Core Duo MacBook back in 2006). It might have to do with how LibreOffice decided to handle its UI elements. Writing cross-platform software is hard, and it often results in making compromises that affect conformance with specific platform UI guidelines and performance (consider how controversial Electron apps are with some users, for example). But even with LibreOffice's clunkiness, I still use it at home. While I am partial to Apple Keynote for presentations, I prefer LibreOffice Writer and LibreOffice Calc to Apple Pages and Apple Numbers, respectively. And whenever I'm on a Linux or FreeBSD machine, LibreOffice is available for me to use, while iWork and Microsoft Office are not options.
- colechristensen 7y agoYou were probably also using several thousand dollar computers. Try making the same claim using a thrift store laptop for < $200 which is all the computing power a whole lot of people have access to (if any). Yes computing is fine (and a little better than 20 years ago) for software made and used by wealthy people. You have to slide down the curve a bit to discover the frustration with everything being terribly hungry for ever-increasing resources.
- sokoloff 7y agoIsn't that directly contrary to GP's claim of "look at how ridiculously powerful our computers are and they're still so slow" though? Of course slow computers are slow.
- colechristensen 7y agoToday's cheap slow computers are yesterday's supercomputers. Of course if you upgrade to a top quartile computer every few years you're going to have a relatively good time. $200 computers obey Moore's law too.
- bigiain 7y agoI was amused to read this morning that Microsoft's new Terminal client has "GPU accelerated text rendering engine". WT actual F??? You can't run a terminal window without a few Gig of video ram and a couple of teraflops of GPU horsepower??? Boggle! https://www.theregister.co.uk/2019/06/24/microsoft_round_up/ https://www.theregister.co.uk/2019/06/24/microsoft_round_up/
- comex 7y agoIf you're on, say, a 4K 10-bit display, there's quite a bit more pixel data to push than there used to be. You still don't need a GPU just to draw text, but since you already have one, using it will provide better performance and likely consume less power.
- Crinus 7y ago> but since you already have one, Since i already have one i might want to use it for other things. The reason computers are slow is this sort of "since you already have that resource, might as well use it" thinking - which makes sense if only one program does it, but if almost all programs do it then it breaks down quickly.
- skybrian 7y agoThe same could be said for the CPU, and this helps free up the CPU for other things. It's a trade-off. But the underlying problem here is higher resolution screens than needed. Most people don't actually need a 4k display. Sometimes, they can't really see small print that easily anyway and what they need is UI's designed with large print in mind.
- Crinus 7y agoCPUs are more generic though and pretty much every single GPU accelerated text drawing operation i've seen allocates permanent GPU resources (textures mainly). It isn't impossible to not do that, but if you only allocate the necessary resources for the GPU on an as-needed basis and then release them once you're done, you are introducing latency which invalidates any gains you may have. The alacritty terminal linked elsewhere in this post, for example, keeps a bunch of atlases around with hundreds of glyphs which are local to each instance of the program (thus using both CPU and GPU resources) and for macOS and Windows ignoring any system-wide glyph caching the APIs it uses may already have (caches that will be created - and thus resource allocated - anyway when it tries to rasterize those glyphs for its own use). FWIW yeah, i agree that most people do not really need 4K displays but that is another matter.
- JustSomeNobody 7y agoBecause everyone is in a hurry. Productivity is measured in dev hours not CPU hours. This is why we have crap Electron apps.
- leeoniya 7y ago> This is why we have crap Electron apps. i've always wondered what would happen to this sentiment if something like V8, Node, Electron or NW.js was already part of the [Windows, Linux, macOS] platforms and didn't need to be distributed with every app.
- hutattedonmyarm 7y agoI was wondering about the exact same thing this morning! I came to the conclusion that every OS vendor would probably prefer to ship their preferred engine, and so we'd end up with... websites
- JustSomeNobody 7y agoWhy would this change anything at all? The "apps"[0] would still be extremely inefficient. [0] For lack of a better term.
- pizzazzaro 7y agoThats orders of magnitude of other people's software running for other people on our phones and laptops. If it were just the software we wanted, the adware, ransomware, click-baiting, click-jacking, pop ups, and such wouldnt need yet more software to fight. The internet might have been a mistake.
- mrjasongorman 7y agoBlame abstractions, and the fact that we expect a higher graphical polish to our programs and even just the desktop. Booting a Raspberry Pi straight into terminal is pretty quick.
- L_226 7y agoJust like when you have a backpack slightly too big for purpose and you tend to add in useless junk, so too do people add useless software when available compute/memory is superfluous. Because you can.