5 ms·
Emergency services are apparantly too important to allow something as 'unreliable' as skype/facetime. I don't understand why regulators can't drop the reliabil
by londons_explore 7y ago
Emergency services are apparantly too important to allow something as 'unreliable' as skype/facetime.
I don't understand why regulators can't drop the reliability requirements and understand that if skype, facetime, whatsapp, viber, twitter, etc. all have 99.9% reliability, then the chances of them all being down at once is far lower than your POTS line being down.
Just have a #911Emergency official hashtag and have a bunch of people reply to it. That's the way the people want it.
- DonHopkins 7y agoLast time the power went off in Amsterdam, the internet continued to work just fine.
- FabHK 7y agoPOTS is not dependent on the ordinary house electric system, either.
- lmm 7y agoIt's not supposed to depend on the ordinary electrical system. In practice that independence isn't always tested as often as it should be, and mistakes happen.
- FabHK 7y agoTrue, but at least it is supposed to. What about "the internet"? Which parts of that will still work when there's a power outage? Not your home Wifi, presumably. Mobile data? For how long?
- Piskvorrr 7y agoTens of minutes on average. Most BTSes are battery-backed, without generators. (Home wifi could work, but the usefulness of an island system is limited. Outer link also worked last time, but what good is that when the other end is not even on UPS? Next hop was optical, but who knows how that is powered and whence.)
- ascorbic 7y agoHow many people have their home wifi on a UPS?
- lmm 7y ago> What about "the internet"? Which parts of that will still work when there's a power outage? Not your home Wifi, presumably. Mobile data? For how long? The true-but-unhelpful answer is "depends on your ISP and what contract you have with them". A typical home user's "last mile" is almost certainly less reliable than POTS, agreed. But if you make it onto the backbone the internet is better at routing around disruption than the circuit-oriented phone system. So I wouldn't want to count on the phone system always being more reliable.
- iagovar 7y agoIt is, we just use batteries. Anyway I'm no expert of that, I just see batteries when I enter a BTS, but never checked if there was a separate power line or anything. I'm talking about one ISP in Spain though.
- Piskvorrr 7y agoUsually runs on the normal municipal grid.
- DonHopkins 7y agoYeah, the coffeeshops just kept selling it in the dark.
- stordoff 7y agoGenerally, no, but if you have a mains-powered wireless phone as your only phone (as my grandparents have for over a decade, it essentially is. This isn't necessarily something you can rely on (unless you specifically plan ahead for this).
- felipelemos 7y agoYou really don't want any one in the internet flooding your #911Emergency hashtag. I can understand Skype and WhatsApp having some kind of official emergency option, but not a hashtag on Twitter.
- zaxomi 7y agoInternet outages happens too often for any internet based services to be reliable in an emergency. Any larger ISP have several local outages per week. Last week one of the largest mobile carries in Sweden had major problems three days in a row, affecting both telephone and internet.
- FabHK 7y ago1. POTS aims at "5 nines" reliability. [1] 2. > the chances of them all being down at once is far lower than your POTS line being down. That depends crucially on the correlation. If there are common fault modes (such as: internet down), the probability might be way higher. (Remember, it used to be common wisdom that it was possible that one or two home owners won't be able to pay their mortgages, but the probability that many will be unable to pay their mortgages is so low that all these MBS and CDO's can be rated AAA...) 3. EDIT to add: Of course, adding communication options can only increase the probability that you can reach your emergency provider, but there's a reason that Skype etc. used to come with these big disclaimers that they're no replacement for POTS, namely the excellent reliability of POTS. [1] "Although POTS provides limited features, low bandwidth, and no mobile capabilities, it provides greater reliability than other telephony systems (mobile phone, VoIP, etc.). Many telephone service providers attempt to achieve dial-tone availability more than 99.999% of the time the telephone is taken off-hook. This is an often cited benchmark in marketing and systems-engineering comparisons, called the "five nines" reliability standard." https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Plain_old_telephone_service#Reliability https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Plain_old_telephone_service#Re...
- slfnflctd 7y agoThis is exactly the reason why I find all the gleeful tearing out of old POTS copper lines very distressing. This was a proven system with incredible reliability, which worked in power outages for residential users due to centralized backup systems, and still has plenty of usefulness. Until we come up with some universal multi-layered standards which provide at least the same level of uptime and utility, it seems more than a little premature to pull all of it up as a matter of course. Obviously in many places there are space constraints, but that is not usually an issue in arguably the most important use case, at home.
- walshemj 7y agoBetter that Five nines - experiencing a major switch failure should be something you experience once every two or three generations.
- 7y ago
- Rebelgecko 7y agoPerhaps because in an emergency there may not be enough time for someone to sign up for and install Skype?
- fwip 7y agoI can't go out and buy a phone in the middle of an emergency either.
- viraptor 7y agoI believe they meant the new communication as an additional option, not a replacement. It's not "now I have to install Skype", it's "the normal phone line is dead, I've got an emergency, now I've got an option to try Skype instead of possibly just dying".
- Rebelgecko 7y agoIf that's the case, they shouldn't be using the possibility of using skype as an excuse to reduce the availability requirements for getting ahold of 911
- viraptor 7y agoI hope that londons_explore meant dropping reliability requirements on the supporting tech so it can be added, not on the POTS itself.
- oneplane 7y agoThat's what they did when 112 went down, they just started accepting twitter/instagram/facebook/whatsapp. Problem is that those services can be much harder to manage making them a problem in itself (i.e. spoofing, overloading).
- walshemj 7y agoWe are talking about a countries 911 service going down and killing people and you suggest a lower (3 nines) services as a better replacement oh and a back up of a *f&^ing Hashtag! Having the Dutch government nationalise the 911 service with no compensation to the share holders would be a start.