6 ms·
Also, they can disengage from tax avoidance schemes and pay full price on taxes. I’m all for billionaires paying more, but two things: the billions from billi
by mc32 7y ago
Also, they can disengage from tax avoidance schemes and pay full price on taxes.
I’m all for billionaires paying more, but two things: the billions from billionaires don’t add much to taxes (it’d be more principle than anything), two, this is socialistic thinking on the part of the billionaires trying to coerce this on others. They don’t want to do it unless others do it.
- kyshoc 7y agoFull price, really, is what's left over after tax avoidance. Paying more than you're legally required to is simply paying extra.
- RankingMember 7y agoI think these billionaires are willing to pay more taxes with the important caveat that all other billionaires also pay more taxes. I understand that reasoning. Maybe Buffet or someone can actually start lobbying in the direction of closing loopholes.
- IG_Semmelweiss 7y agoNo, you dont. By their logic, they would not rescue a drowning man unless there was a law requiring them to do so. One can see the corruption of their logic with a simple example.
- shawnz 7y agoNo they can't. Corporations have a responsibility to act in the best interest of the shareholders, which includes not unnecessarily choosing to pay more taxes than you need to. Tax loopholes need to be fixed in law.
- bobwaycott 7y ago> Corporations have a responsibility to act in the best interest of the shareholders No, they don’t. There are no legal requirements to act in the best interest of shareholders. There are no directives to do so inside corporate charters. Your phrasing of “act in the best interest of shareholders” is perhaps the silliest and most extreme version of the “maximize shareholder value” myth I’ve heard yet—a myth that first started being pushed by Friedman and his ilk in the 1970s, and has morphed into this common theme nobody even questions. It isn’t true. There is no such responsibility required of a corporation.
- shawnz 7y agoHuh? Yes they do: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Duty_of_care_(business_associations) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Duty_of_care_(business_associa...
- bobwaycott 7y agoDid you read the link you just posted? The duty of care is owed to the corporation by its directors—"a duty to exercise good business judgment and to use ordinary care and prudence in the operation of the business ... in the best interest of the corporation [not the shareholders]...". You either are missing the distinction here and conflating the corporation and its shareholders into a single entity, or you're inadvertently moving the goal posts. There is no obligation or responsibility for a corporation—or its directors—to operate in the best interest of shareholders. Which is what you originally stated. Corporations—and their directors—have no such legal or chartered responsibility. Again, it sounds like you've perhaps unwittingly transformed the myth of maximizing shareholder value—a fiction created in the 1970s that has zero legal or chartered basis—into this even looser, but far more extreme, version of a corporate responsibility to act in the best interest of shareholders.
- shawnz 7y agoYes, okay, the responsibility is to the corporation as a whole and not the shareholders as individuals. To me that is semantics. What does that have to do with the tax avoidance argument?
- bobwaycott 7y agoIt is absolutely not semantics, though. You should correct and update your mental model here. A corporation is not its shareholders. As you're the one who advanced an argument against disengaging from tax avoidance based on the incorrect assertion that a corporation is obligated to act in the best interest of its shareholders, I'm not sure how to respond to your final question. If you accept that a corporation is not, neither by law nor by charter, obligated to act in the best interest of its shareholders, then what is your argument about paying or avoiding taxes? There is no legal obligation for directors to find every opportunity, creative method, and loophole to avoid paying corporate taxes. The directors of a corporation could absolutely, as the parent commenter suggested, "disengage from tax avoidance schemes". Nothing prohibits them from doing so. So ... what is your argument?