4 ms·
Ted Nelson is visionary but bad businessman/project leader. The Curse Of Xanadu: https://www.wired.com/1995/06/xanadu/ https://www.wired.com/1995/06/xanadu/ H
by nabla9 7y ago
Ted Nelson is visionary but bad businessman/project leader.
The Curse Of Xanadu: https://www.wired.com/1995/06/xanadu/ https://www.wired.com/1995/06/xanadu/
He patented some of his ideas (like ZigZag data structure) but failed to commercialize despite multiple attempts. Then he killed open source attempt to make it happen outside his control (GZigZag). Being very defensive and insisting of owning the project when one has not the ability to lead is unfortunate. Nelson had very good ideas.
The idea that you make closed source hypertext project seemed possible at the time, before the web, but it has no change of happening now.
- carapace 7y agoTed Nelson responded: 'Errors in "The Curse of Xanadu," by Gary Wolf' http://xanadu.com.au/ararat http://xanadu.com.au/ararat Look I'm as bummed as anyone that he never got Xanadu off the ground, but please don't link to that "hit piece". Ted Nelson is a visionary and deserves more respect.
- dredmorbius 7y agoWith due respect, Nelson's response ssuggests an inability to distinguish forest from tree. There is a difference between narrative and factual error. Nelson fails to draw that and is stuck in minutiae. There's also considerable prickliness, if not outright paranoia, shown. (And yes, I've read the Wired piece as well.)
- enkiv2 7y agoIt's not true that he killed GZZ. He had filed the patent already, & the GZZ developer (who had previously been working closely with Ted) dropped the project when he heard that a patent existed. (As far as I am aware, all patents filed with respect to ZigZag or Xanadu are expiring within the next few years.) Several Xanadu implementations are already released as open source (the first one in 1999). Believe me: I've tried to convince Ted that the appropriate way to get stuff to have traction these days is to develop in public, rather than keeping stuff secret during development & only releasing source when it's been polished. It's not that he wants a closed & commercialized system (though he hasn't completely given up on having some stake in monetization), but that he wants enough control to avoid the kinds of runaway misunderstandings that produced the web. If I had seen a warped version of my own work ruin the world, I'd be conservative too. Now that web standards are so complicated that writing a new web browser is impossible for even large & very rich companies (Microsoft is ditching IE in favor of Chrome, following dozens of others), a properly-designed (and thus, simple) hypertext system becomes a lot more sensible -- for more and more people, the web will seem less and less like a reasonable compromise (being never a particularly good system for hypertext, and a far worse application sandbox platform). Some folks have been jumping to gopher, but others will probably migrate to new systems that are along the lines of Xanadu.
- nabla9 7y agoMaybe the reason was his incompetence, incisiveness or something else, but he ended up putting people to work on a project without revealing relevant stuff of his intentions and underlying situation. Not communicating and stringing people along is not a good personality trait. see: http://lambda-the-ultimate.org/node/233#comment-1715 http://lambda-the-ultimate.org/node/233#comment-1715
- enkiv2 7y agoWhen I was brought onto the project, he made sure I was OK with working on patent-encumbered designs & possibly closed-source code, specifically because of his experience with the GZZ developer. It's a misunderstanding he learned from.