3 ms·
If one actor threatens to kill another on stage as part of a play, then says exactly the same words in the same tone to the same person off stage, the former th
by michaelt 7y ago
If one actor threatens to kill another on stage as part of a play, then says exactly the same words in the same tone to the same person off stage, the former threat isn't real and the latter case is real.
That's because the threat isn't just the words; it's also a question of intent - and in the absence of time-travelling MRI machines to objectively observe people's thoughts in the past, inferring the intent from context we can observe.
Of course, you could argue that having laws that depend on people's only-indirectly-observable mental state is a bad idea - that announcing your intention to blow up an airport should either always be legal, or never be legal. If you're interested in such questions, you might enjoy reading about the Twitter Joke Trial [1] over one such incident.
[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Twitter_Joke_Trial https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Twitter_Joke_Trial