7 ms·
Why Hong Kong protesters didn't use their own metro cards
- AtomicOrbital 7y agoPeople who live in fear of their government deserve a better government .... luckily history shows those governments fail
- gpm 7y agoDoes it? History shows that all governments fail, but does it show that governments people live in fear of fail faster? Is history still relevant? The creation of cameras, high speed communications, and computers fundamentally changes the question. The capabilities of citizens, governments, and bystanders have all changed. The capabilities are still rapidly changing, e.g. facial recognition, and drones.
- Overtonwindow 7y agoI don’t know, China is still going very strong, and Russia doesn’t look like of collapsing anytime soon.
- aurelianito 7y agoThey didn't use their metro cards but did use their cellphones, as it can be seen in the pictures. The government can easily know that they were there, as they can be triangulated using the cellphone towers information. Not using their cards is useless.
- bt3 7y agoMetro station are typically underground as well. So even a very precise triangulation could place you logically in a building above ground.
- inferiorhuman 7y agoUnless there are bluetooth beacons or cell repeaters underground.
- realusername 7y agoWith one million people on the street, I don't know if that information is really useful in this case.
- kazinator 7y agoBut then that reasoning could apply to the train cards.
- joecot 7y agoUsing triangulation to track a single person is one thing. Using it to track a million would be incredibly tedious. Whereas getting a list of everyone who got off at specific stations in specific timeframes is likely a single SQL query.
- throwaway1997 7y agoOur train cards (Octopus card) are often linked to our bank accounts so that we can use the Automatic Add Value Service (AAVS). The only people travelling to Causeway Bay and from Admiralty at that time would be protestors so it would be fairly trivial to link protestors to individual identities using the cards. It wouldn't be too hard triangulating the cell towers because we have a huge population density and, hence, cell towers attached to nearly every building. But I feel this data would be harder to get hold of and may catch the hundreds of thousands of "innocent" people who live in those buildings.
- dbuder 7y agoThis is merely a challenge for the glorious revolution, don't you want to bring harmony to your country?
- ladzoppelin 7y agoYou spot 4 people using their phones without any context or knowledge and say not using the card was "useless". Is there something I am missing?
- fwn 7y agoMost people don't understand the incremental nature of privacy. I don't mean that in a dismissive way: I think that's a seductive thought and the root of many crude, defeatist attitudes towards informational self-determination.
- helloviper 7y agoThere are several factors. - They mainly fear prosecution after the protests and the travel card as a evidence of their presence. Cell tower triangulation fair worse in court. - Many people are also using burner cards which are easy to purchase in Hong Kong. - The protest was decentralized and was mainly organized with internet forums and instant messaging software. Not using a travel card is only a mild inconvenience.
- inferiorhuman 7y agoBurner SIMs or burner phones + SIMs? As long a the government can link the IMEI to a person there's not much anonymity bought with a burner SIM. Using a burner transit card isn't nothing, but there's pretty good surveillance infrastructure in place already (e.g. the hospitals).
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]