7 ms·
The including of the espionage act is a reasonable concern. The question about helping someone hack the laptop in question (even if not successful) was a clear
by duxup 7y ago
The including of the espionage act is a reasonable concern.
The question about helping someone hack the laptop in question (even if not successful) was a clear crossing of a boundary that I would expect most journalists would not cross.
- soulofmischief 7y agoSo, did you know that in the US you can face years in prison for just telling someone, "I can't help you commit check fraud, but Google _____ if you're interested in learning how others do it"? Do you agree with this practice?
- rglover 7y agoI'd be curious to see the law in question, but yes, because you're ultimately still aiding someone to commit fraud (however indirectly).
- soulofmischief 7y agoI remember an article of a woman getting around seven years for this exact thing, but I wasn't able to find it, you'll just have to take my post with a grain of salt even though I vouch for it. I think it is an extremely slippery slope to prosecute people for providing public information about how to find public resources to do something already publicly known. That means that you could go to jail for merely suggesting for someone that it's possible for them to buy drugs online via a dark net market-- something I am indirectly doing now just by having this conversation. Or for telling them to google _____ to know how to commit suicide painlessly. Where do we draw the line? Are we sure someone won't come along and move it further down later on?
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- rglover 7y agoThat's the point of due process: to make a conscious judgment about intent based on evidence. In your case, any intelligent person—short of corruption—would realize you were stating an example, not encouraging me to commit a crime. Assange broke the law—calling him a journalist is a farce and a tactic—and has to deal with the consequences. Letting him get away with it sets a precedent for interpreting the law in any way we want, effectively rendering laws useless (and creating the exact problem you've described here). Simply put: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lbOtyWTRZ_g https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lbOtyWTRZ_g
- nkurz 7y agoWhy do you feel that it strengthens your argument to say "calling him a journalist is a farce"? Clearly, lots of people consider him a journalist. He's even won several prizes for being a journalist. Here's one from 2011: "Julian Assange, the WikiLeaks founder, has won the 2011 Martha Gellhorn prize for journalism. The annual prize is awarded to a journalist "whose work has penetrated the established version of events and told an unpalatable truth that exposes establishment propaganda, or 'official drivel', as Martha Gellhorn called it". https://www.theguardian.com/media/2011/jun/02/julian-assange-martha-gelhorn-prize https://www.theguardian.com/media/2011/jun/02/julian-assange... In the absence of a clear legal definition of "journalist" in the US, it seems entirely reasonable to call someone who wins prizes for journalism a journalist. Why do you disagree, and why should your opinion be weighted more strongly than those who disagree with you? I agree, however, that calling him a "journalist" is a tactic. The goal is imply that because he's a journalist, he should not be prosecuted for breaking the law. It's a strange tactic, though, since as far as I know there are no exceptions for journalists to break US federal laws. Anyway, I'd argue that calling him "not a journalist" is a tactic as well. Why not simplify to your stronger point of "Assange broke the law ... and has to deal with the consequences"? Do you feel that if he was a "proper journalist" he should be treated differently? (Personally, I think trying to enforce US law on foreign nationals who have never set foot in your country is a terrible precedent. I believe that prosecuting him is selective-enforcement, intended to punish him for releasing true but embarrassing information about US government misdeeds, and to dissuade others who might be tempted to follow his example. While he likely broke the laws that he is charged with, I think journalists worldwide are right to be afraid of the change in policy that this implies.)
- godelski 7y agoI think it's a hard line to draw. Did you just tell someone to Google the anarchist cookbook? Or did you tell them to Google a specific nitrate group that is easily accessible but requires specific knowledge and likely wouldn't be found by a novice searching (which novices will find a lot). I think it also matters if you explicitly know they are going to commit a crime vs just being curious (you do have to know how to commit a crime to defend against it). I don't think it is simple.
- mindslight 7y agoI think it's an easy line to draw - it just looks difficult because it has been repeatedly stretched to catch one "bad guy" or another. The example under discussion can be straightforwardly applied to the topic of software exploits. By posting a proof of concept to a mailing list, one knows that previously obscure information will then be in the hands of ne'er do wells. The motivation even includes foreseeing the exploit being used, pressuring the vendor/sysadmins into fixing it. Yet we are all safer when exploits are shared publicly so that they can be patched, rather than kept in obscurity. Providing general information, even to someone who will use it for abuse, should be protected speech. "Ammonium nitrate plus Diesel" or "Just Google Casio F-91W and thank me later" are definitively in that territory. A weaker standard is begging for selective persecution, just as we see here.
- brownbat 7y agoIt's a little more complex than that in practice. Accessory liability generally requires you to know that someone is going to commit a crime, and know that your action will help them. Juries can make bad decisions in particular cases of course, but if I were the defense I would have a field day constantly repeating the "I can't help you" quote. The other side would try to say that was just hand waving or insincere, and the jury would have to decide between those two alternatives based on all the facts of the case. (This becomes a question of fact because particular facts matter. If the Godfather leans in and says the line you gave, for instance, to one of his loyal henchmen, the law should be able to punish him.)
- pessimizer 7y ago> (This becomes a question of fact because particular facts matter. If the Godfather leans in and says the line you gave, for instance, to one of his loyal henchmen, the law should be able to punish him.) That pretty much means that by calling someone a "godfather" I can prosecute them for things that normally wouldn't be a crime. What if I call someone a "terrorist," or a government a "regime"?
- mindslight 7y ago> What if I call someone a "terrorist," or a government a "regime"? Apparently you can push a lot of people into believing a prosecution is not purely political.
- reallydude 7y agoHistorically, that has been the modus operandi since, at least, the Truman Doctrine.
- leftyted 7y agoNo one said said "calls" until your post... I think the point is well made - the jury has to decide what "I can't help you" means, and it means different things depending on who says it. This is the nature of human communication and we can't escape from it.
- colechristensen 7y agoHow about if you're talking to someone fuming about a local politician and he's talking about making an explosive and you say "I can't help you make a bomb but Google _____ if you're interested in learning how others do it" If the person goes and then tries it, yes, I agree you share in the responsibility for their actions. It was reasonable for you to believe the intent was serious and you provided essential guidance to making it a reality. There's that word "just" again. "just telling someone" adds deceptive misdirection. The context of who you tell and how and why are all important.
- threatofrain 7y ago> but Google _____ if you're interested in learning how others do it. > ...and you provided essential guidance to making it a reality. That's called essential guidance? Man, I guess I could be an educator and mentor, providing essential guidance on software. I guess people are serious when they say software is Google-fu.
- Krasnol 7y agoConsidering how the internet is full of questions that could be solved by googling them, you could make the argument that it's essential. It becomes even more essential if you provide them with the proper search terms that would give them better results. Interpreting what "better search terms" is, is something a good lawyer should be able to manage.
- fwip 7y agoIt depends a lot on what's in that blank. If you say "idk, maybe Google 'how to make a bomb,'" then that's not essential guidance. If you say "Google for [list of specific key ingredients]," that's a bit different.
- sschueller 7y agoSo technically the website "let me Google that for you" could also be liable?
- Alex3917 7y ago> So, did you know that in the US you can face years in prison for just telling someone, "I can't help you commit check fraud, but Google _____ if you're interested in learning how others do it"? To the extent that would be illegal, it would only be illegal because the other person was first asking how to commit a crime. If you walked up to a random person and told them "Google 'How to commit check fraud'" then you'd be 100% in the clear.
- soulofmischief 7y agoAlright, but you know that wasn't what my post was talking about.
- sjeohp 7y agoMost journalists are state lackeys so that doesn't say much. A sane person should recognize the difference between hacking a govt computer for personal gain and hacking in the public interest before locking someone up for life.
- geekone 7y ago>Most journalists are state lackeys so that doesn't say much. Source?
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- sjeohp 7y agoNot sure what you are hoping for beyond the self-evident unwillingness of most journalists to challenge state enthusiasm for the Foreign Intervention of the Month.
- stevenjohns 7y agoThis has less to do with most journalists consciously doing it and more to do with people just riding the wave of their biases and their editor's biases. The reality is that most journalists are not proficient in the content they try to cover, and for the select "elite" that are proficient and considered to be "experts", they almost always come with some sort of insanely strong bias that made them proficient to start off with. There's almost a revolving door between "expert" journalists and think tanks/pressure groups. I see this heavily with Middle Eastern coverage. It's basically an all-out shitfight of the most bigoted, racist and sectarian people war mongering through fear, dishonestly and in some cases outright lies. In some cases this has had tragic consequences - things like ISIS' adventure through Iraq could have almost certainly been avoided. Sometimes the dog whistling moves from just dog whistling and we see writers that have written for publications like The Boston Globe outright tweeting that they wish for the suffering of Syrian children - verbatim - and then deleting the tweets after realising they're on a public platform.
- 7y ago
- SomeOldThrow 7y agoWhile I can understand that, the root issue is that this “hacking” is in fact a public service—whistleblowing. There was much more support for Assange, even from the political establishment, before he published the emails in the lead up to the election. I can’t even be mad at that because it showed what a corrupt organization the DNC was at the time (and probably still is, although there is the Unity coalition now). So I would argue he embarrassed both the military industrial complex AND the DNC to get him where he is now. It’s also much harder to see publishing internal documents of a campaign/political party as a public service or whistleblowing, though I think the case for “russian interference” is entirely overblown compared to, say, blatant interference via the incestuous political/media blob.
- freddie_mercury 7y ago> While I can understand that, the root issue is that this “hacking” is in fact a public service—whistleblowing. How do you establish that a given act of hacking is or is not a public service? Especially in cases where there isn't a bright line like "someone broke law XYZ". It seems like going to court & having a jury decide that is not obviously the wrong solution. So even if one supports your position, it seems like the issue would still end up in court with a jury deciding whether someone spends years in jail or goes free.
- justinclift 7y ago> It seems like going to court & having a jury decide that is not obviously the wrong solution. If the court process was reasonably expected to be impartial and fair, then you'd have a point. That's very much not the case in this instance. :(
- pytester 7y ago>How do you establish that a given act of hacking is or is not a public service? If you hack and then publish embarrassing material to the whole world it's a public service. If you hack non-embarrassing operationally sensitive material and then leak it selectively to foreign governments then it's espionage. There's some fuzziness but it's not a bright line to cross and Julian Assange is very, very far away from it. The fact that the murders that were uncovered are still going unprosecuted adds considerable weight to the idea that it was a public service. If Assange had done the exact same thing to Russia the idea that it was espionage would be justifiably mocked. It's not mocked because nationalism is a potent drug, essentially (here, it's not like Russians aren't looking at this and shaking their heads).
- pytester 7y ago>The question about helping someone hack the laptop in question (even if not successful) was a clear crossing of a boundary that I would expect most journalists would not cross. It seems fairly analogous to the famous 1973 burglary of FBI offices that uncovered J Edgar Hoover's blanked surveillance of civil rights movements and his attempt to coerce Luther King into committing suicide: https://www.theguardian.com/world/2014/jan/07/fbi-office-break-in-1971-come-forward-documents https://www.theguardian.com/world/2014/jan/07/fbi-office-bre... Retrospectively, it's easy now to call these people heroes who uncovered a rather evil conspiracy.
- belorn 7y agoA pity he is not in Sweden. Just four months ago a number of journalists from a tech news site accessed an unprotected medical server as part of verifying the claim that it was indeed unprotected. 2.7 million patient calls to Swedish healthcare hotline left unprotected online (https://thenextweb.com/eu/2019/02/18/2-7-million-patient-calls-to-swedish-healthcare-hotline-left-unprotected-online/ https://thenextweb.com/eu/2019/02/18/2-7-million-patient-cal...). The journalists downloaded one audio file during verification. The company filed a police complaint and claimed the journalists unlawfully accessed a computer without authorization, conspired to access a computer without authorization, and access with the intention to disclose patient confidential information (https://www.svt.se/nyheter/medhelp-anmaler-computer-sweden https://www.svt.se/nyheter/medhelp-anmaler-computer-sweden). I strongly doubt it will go anywhere or any of the journalists will see a day in prison.
- efdee 7y agoI don't think Sweden would extend the same courtesy to Assange.
- techntoke 7y agoMuch different than attempting to hack a password protected computer to get confidential government data and use it for undisclosed purposes.
- hauk66 7y ago>undisclosed purposes When your business card reads "wikileaks" I think the parties involved have a decent idea of what they where doing. I can see how the attempt might be viewed as a hostile act towards the Americans as a "military entity" but i also strongly belive that Wikileaks has done amazing work with their dumps. If he wants to try and brute a few encryptions to support wikileaks i dont really mind quite frankly. The amount of shit we (europeans++) take from the American tech/some enterprises on behalf of the us goverment i legitimatly feel that the citisens that have been illegal spied on by a foreign goverment that could not possibly care less about protecting their fundemental privacy rights, lose their privilige to complain when citizens of said foreign nations with "nobel" causes tries to fuck them back. Im sorry but with the revelations of the past decade my strong support of the status quo in regards to American dominance has withered some. There is a point where i just want to tell the American military machine to "ta deg en bolle" (Norwegian for its time to shut the fuck up and deal with it) /end of anti-America rant
- jessaustin 7y agoWhat laptop? I thought the issue was credentials for some sort of online database of war crime videos? Manning already had personal credentials, but thought that if the videos were accessed with other credentials the source of the leaks would be less obvious.