3 ms·
It’s unclear to me how much should go to founders of things like currency. Shouldn’t the amount of funds to a dev team depend on some sort of measure of value r
by prepend 7y ago
It’s unclear to me how much should go to founders of things like currency. Shouldn’t the amount of funds to a dev team depend on some sort of measure of value rather than a cut of all future tokens? That seems unsustainable and part of the reason why a cutoff would be designed into the system.
I’ve been through a lot of discussions around what a fair price is to pay for the devs of a community resource and I don’t think I’ve ever seen it resolve well. A few examples I remember are plastic and kur5hin shutting down, digg and reddit and slashdot for selling off with digg and slashdot going into barebones ad models and Reddit doing whatever they’re doing.
One of the big disagreements I witnessed a lot of discussion around was how much founders thought they should get just to run community resources and how much the community wanted to pay. The most concrete I remember was the plastic, or maybe it was netslaves, founder wanting $300/month to run the servers. Not much at all, I think it was between 2000 and 2005. A few members offered to run it for free and he wouldn’t do it because he also needed the servers for his other projects. That spiraled into a boring discussion about why a community would pay for some private servers.
- baby 7y agoMentality has changed. Look at Patreon. I’ve never given money to these types of stuff and now I’m donating monthly to Kurzgesagt. That says something.
- pavel_lishin 7y agoIt's also gotten easier to give money. Plus, at least speaking for myself, I've gotten older and am now in a financial position to realistically support things without sacrificing too much else.
- jarfil 7y agoCreators of fiat currency call that the "price of money" or "interest rate", which right now is at around 2%, but running "community resources" sounds more like what a government does, with its 30% cut from taxes.
- jonathankoren 7y agoYeah, it’s basically a tax, but a tax going to a private individual instead of an accountable organization controlled by the community.
- jonas21 7y ago> Shouldn’t the amount of funds to a dev team depend on some sort of measure of value rather than a cut of all future tokens? A cut of future tokens is a kind of measure of value, isn't it? The more value the developers produce in terms of building a useful token, the more that cut of the tokens will be worth.
- lacker 7y agoThe real problem here is that the compensation structure was initially defined to give the dev team payments for four years and then stop. That makes sense for stock options, when there are established mechanisms to expand the options pool later. For a cryptocurrency it creates a big problem for you, that you’ve punted four years down the road. We’ll see if Zcash developers manage to fork into a coin that keeps paying them to work on it, but I think the lesson here is to incorporate this up front in the model. Any amount can be fair if it’s fairly communicated up front.
- jdsully 7y agoShareholders don't expect to keep getting additional shares as time goes on. The point is you increase the value of each share by improving the company (or in this case the currency). They already have substantial ownership in the currency - this should be sufficient.
- lacker 7y agoShareholders don't expect to keep getting additional shares, but employees do. The main problem isn't that Zcash needs to incentivize shareholders, the main problem is that they need to incentivize engineers to work on their software.
- jdsully 7y agoGiven the assets they have - the interest alone out to be enough cash to employ their devs. ZCash doesn't throw off interest directly but wall street is pretty creative at turning assets into cash flow.