3 ms·
>I understand that there are limits and finite resources. If you're asking where to get the money from how about a little less on weapons development and a litt
by yummyfajitas 18y ago
>I understand that there are limits and finite resources. If you're asking where to get the money from how about a little less on weapons development and a little more on medical research.
Sounds great. Only one problem: money is an illusion. The issue isn't money, it is supply of medical care as measured in units of doctor-hours.
The only way you can get doctor-hours for person X is to take them from person Y. Doctors already work far more than full time and are unlikey to work more. Getting more doctors will be tough, since medical schools are all full.
The issue is that medical care is a very scarce commodity. And you can't legislate scarcity away. Any proposed solution that doesn't create new doctor-hours (or find a substitute good for doctor-hours, such as nurse-hours) is a fraud.
- mlinsey 18y ago"The issue isn't money, it is supply of medical care as measured in units of doctor-hours" Except it isn't. The cost of the supplies necessary for treatment (drugs, medical equipment) is at least as big of an issue. Also, wages for doctors are trending downwards thanks to HMO's. I'm not saying that's an inherently bad thing, but it's definitely not what you would expect if doctor-hours were the scarcest resource in the system.
- rms 18y agoDoctors are kept artificially short in supply by the US medical school system. This is very, very fixable.
- yummyfajitas 18y agoTechnically it is medical schools that are kept in short supply. Most medical schools operated at full capacity, and about 2/3 of qualified applicants are turned away. This is certainly fixable, though the time horizon (medical school construction/expansion time + doctor training time = 10-15 years) is longer than most politicians like.
- aswanson 18y agoSounds great. Only one problem: money is an illusion. The issue isn't money, it is supply of medical care as measured in units of doctor-hours That is wrong. What you are saying is that a doctors hours in 1940 are translatable to a doctors hours in 2008. This is obviously false; the limiting reagent is not the number of hours but the increase in effectiveness of those hours due to the 68 intervening years of medical research. A single doctor with today's knowledge and technology could have prevented the 1918 influenza epidemic, polio, the Black Plague, etc. So medical research completely matters.