5 ms·
Happy to see a couple of tube amps among the kit listings. I've enjoyed building many, many tube amplifiers in the past two decades or so. Initially they were
by JKCalhoun 7y ago
Happy to see a couple of tube amps among the kit listings.
I've enjoyed building many, many tube amplifiers in the past two decades or so. Initially they were kits, later I did rolled my own point-to-point amps and later still laid out my own PCB's for some PCB-based tube amps.
While the high voltages might seem intimidating (safety-wise) I hope that doesn't keep people from pursuing this class of amplifiers. If you're smart about it, you'll be okay. And there is nothing like the sweet music of non-quantum sound amplification.
(When consider that my other hobby involves a table saw I'm beginning to wonder what might be behind some of my life choices…)
- pthreads 7y agoI love tube amps. Would like to start building my own. Could you please share your favorite resources if any? Thanks.
- vibrolax 7y agoDid you want to make hifi amps, or guitar amps? The electronics knowledge and construction techniques are nearly 100% transferrable, but the design lore diverges, and the online DIY communities can be very diverse. I've built a dozen or so guitar amps, preamps, etc. I don't personally build hifi stuff, but I love John Brodskie's tubecad.com for the analysis of classic circuit topologies, and tons of original ideas. He offers nice looking PCB's for preamps and power supplies. For me it was useful to determine what I wanted to build first, and find the related online sites and communities.
- pthreads 7y agoHiFi. Short anecdote: I once went to a tube amp repair class. After about 5 minutes I realized this was only for guitar amps. I just pretended to be a guitar player and sat through. It was awesome though. Anyway the TubeCAD site looks very interesting. Thanks.
- opencl 7y agoPete Millet's site is a pretty good resource, he's posted a lot of different designs ranging from preamps to power amps to headphone amps. His "Starving Student" design was my first foray into building a tube amp about a decade ago, though that one is really a tube/transistor hybrid and it's designed for headphones but I used it as both a speaker and headphone amp. http://www.pmillett.com/ http://www.pmillett.com/
- ur--whale 7y agoThe age old question: besides the obvious aesthetic attractiveness, is there really any kind of objective advantages to tube-based audio amps as opposed to solid-state semiconductor based ones?
- soulofmischief 7y agoObjectively speaking, if the subjective enjoyment of your music is generally increased, then that's a net positive. So it at least depends on the target audience.
- jacquesm 7y agoIf the target audience is over 35 than chances are their wallets are fat but their ears are already shot. That won't stop them from blowing a lot of money on stuff that doesn't make a difference at all (either measurably or subjectively) but if it makes someone feel better they should be free to waste their money as they see fit.
- soulofmischief 7y agoHa, yeah there's a lot of snake oil in the business. However, there is definitely a difference in sound, however subtle to some, between most tube and solid state amplifiers when it comes to recording music, as musicians tend to try to draw out certain sounds that are a consequence of the design of the amplifier, whether by overdriving the input or exploiting analog flaws, etc. Even when comparing just tube or solid state amps, there can be a lot of variance between them. This doesn't really apply to consumer-grade amplifiers where the goal is perfect sound reproduction. A good tube amp and a good solid-state amp shouldn't sound different to an untrained ear. But amplifiers used in production often try to differentiate themselves in some way sonically.
- michaelt 7y agoWhat if I'm balancing an increase enjoyment from feeling I've got better sound against a decrease in enjoyment from feeling I've being taken for a fool by snake oil salesmen?
- vt102 7y agoI know a little about tube guitar amps, and my understanding is that they are desired due to their “defects” compared to more accurate solid state transistors. I would assume headphone amps would want pristine amplification— why would you want tubes, then?
- billfruit 7y agoI am no EE, but transistors also have problems giving precise accurate gains as well.
- detaro 7y agoTube amps (as do transistor amps) can vary quite a bit in how much they change the sound, e.g. part of the appeal of tube guitar amps is that you can drive them out of the area they work "most precise" into distortion, and that distortion sounds interesting. And some people like the sound changes tube amps cause for listening.
- C1sc0cat 7y agoThere is an story that when the Beetle's went to record at the BBC there was an argument with the BBC sound recording Engineer that no way was he allowing distortion to go out on the BBC :-)
- holy_city 7y agoThose "defects" is just non linearity in the circuit. At low gain factors (much lower than a guitar amp) it creates prominent 2nd, 3rd, and 4th harmonic distortion (depending on the circuit) which corresponds to the musical intervals of an octave, octave + fifth, and 2nd octave. That sound is typically described as "warmth" and can be quite pleasing. It also increases the RMS of the signal without (greatly) affecting dynamics, which makes it perceptually louder. Some people like the ultra hifi systems with crazy THD+N metrics, with super flat speakers in the deadest room they can find to get the most "pristine" sound they can. Other people like listening through systems that subtly color their favorite recordings to match their taste. Different strokes for different folks.