3 ms·
"Should we look in cliff shadows? Near ice deposits? The bottoms of craters? Near the equator where it is warmer? Or near the poles where there might be water?
by pmoriarty 7y ago
"Should we look in cliff shadows? Near ice deposits? The bottoms of craters? Near the equator where it is warmer? Or near the poles where there might be water? We could look a long time without ever learning whether or not life exists."
Somewhere near water might be a good start. There are plenty of candidates for this on Mars already.
Also, I'm sure plenty of people at NASA and other space agencies have thought of this, and there are probably some good reasons for not doing it, but why not take some deep core samples and look through them with a microscope for anything moving?
Not that creatures that can be seen moving under a microscope would exhaust all possible forms of life, but wouldn't it be a good start rather than looking for traces of what might have existed on Mars millions or billions of years ago?
Looking for basic components of or traces of life and only then later starting to look for existing life itself seems like the going the long way around. Why not just go for the gold from the start?
- TeMPOraL 7y ago> Also, I'm sure plenty of people at NASA and other space agencies have thought of this, and there are probably some good reasons for not doing it, but why not take some deep core samples and look through them with a microscope for anything moving? I would guess the difficulty of taking that sample would be one reason - in particular, the difficulty of building, shipping and operating necessary hardware. The best we've done so far is AFAIK the 5m thermometer-tipped drill on the Insight lander, which drilled ~30cm down and broke. We really need cheaper access to Mars for such missions, so that we could send more and heavier hardware for less.
- busymom0 7y agoI am probably the least knowledgeable on this subject, especially compared to the NASA scientists but why don't they send more "complex/capable" robots like the ones from Boston Dynamics instead of their rovers? I feel like a human type of robot mechanically would be much more capable of doing such tests than a rover with limited range of motion. The rovers already have a continuous wear and tear to their wheels (something I will guess the Boston Dynamics might be a bit better at as there is lesser surface area and rolling friction)?
- jacobush 7y agoBecause for science per kilogram sent there, you'd get very little from such a robot. Hence very little science per dollar. (Also, I'd expect such a robot to break in short order.)
- trickstra 7y agohere is a talk about the architecture of a Mars rover: https://media.ccc.de/v/35c3-9783-the_mars_rover_on-board_computer https://media.ccc.de/v/35c3-9783-the_mars_rover_on-board_com... Boston Dynamics Atlas probably wouldn't survive the journey, nor the radiation, nor the heat swings. Mars rover is specifically designed to do handle crazy unknown failures, that's what makes it complex. Having a complex robot and trying to make it resistant to all those failure modes is simply too difficult for today's engineering.
- ksaj 7y agoA lot of living things would not be seen as moving. Probably even the majority of lawki.