4 ms·
I'm pretty confident this is false. It's been repeated a lot in articles (including the usually solid Bruce Schneier), but in an admittedly brief search, I can
by nkurz 16y ago
I'm pretty confident this is false. It's been repeated a lot in articles (including the usually solid Bruce Schneier), but in an admittedly brief search, I can find no evidence to back it up.
Iowa is one of the largest pork producing states, and I can't find any mention of the deaths by pigs in the years I paged through: http://www.public-health.uiowa.edu/face/Summaries/index.html http://www.public-health.uiowa.edu/face/Summaries/index.html
New Mexico, a mostly rural state with a significant number of animal caused fatalities, does not seem to attribute any deaths to pigs out of the 63 deaths (including 2 by sheep) reported here: http://www.nmwild.org/wp-content/uploads/animalrelated.pdf http://www.nmwild.org/wp-content/uploads/animalrelated.pdf
I can't find recent data from the CDC, but this report has fairly complete coverage from 1991-2001. Snakes are at 5 per year for the US, spiders 6, bees and wasps at 50, but pigs are not mentioned specifically anywhere in the report:
http://www.scark.org/docs/Animal%20Related%20Fatalities.pdf http://www.scark.org/docs/Animal%20Related%20Fatalities.pdf
My best guess is that this number was either intended as sample copy and left in a final report, falsely conflates "other specified animal" with pigs, is a worldwide rather than US/Canada specific number, or attempts to included deaths from "swine flu" as death due to a pig. Please don't repeat this trope unless you have better evidence that it is indeed true.
- chadgeidel 16y agoTo be fair - I would expect a swineherd to know how to deal with pigs. They are, after all, experts.
- JoeAltmaier 16y agoand almost no swine are managed by hand in commercial operations. Its mostly hands-free, motivated by the desire to avoid introducing viruses to the young immune-impaired stock.
- Gibbon 16y agoIn all likelihood, the stats are referring to wild boars and feral pigs, which can be extremely aggressive and have been know to attack and gore humans from time to time. Here's a normal pig that attacked a number of people: http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-410319/Nurse-savaged-enraged-giant-pig.html http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-410319/Nurse-savaged...
- nkurz 16y agoYes, from time to time. But I'd bet you any sum of money that there are less than 40 such fatal attacks per year in the US and Canada. And I say this as someone who hunts wild boars, and currently has 2 wild boar hams soaking in brine in preparation for a Christmas dinner. And what do you mean "in all likelihood"? Do you mean that you have some evidence that there are more wild boar attacks per year in the US and Canada than there are shark attacks worldwide? Or do you mean that the concept is kind of cool despite being entirely without evidence?