3 ms·
They're already doing it culturally in response to political wrongthink on the internet and elsewhere, which legions of trolls on 4chan et al regularly exploit
by dmix 7y ago
They're already doing it culturally in response to political wrongthink on the internet and elsewhere, which legions of trolls on 4chan et al regularly exploit for their own amusement.
The same thing in the "homeland" security world would obviously result in a similar overreaction in a country where so many people are paid to be paranoid and overly sensitive to risk. But the deterrents and personal risks of messing with actual security services are so much higher which lowers the likelihood.
Plus how many crazies have tried the "mass shootings to start a {cultural/race} war" thing and completely failed. Or all the groups from the 1970-90s preaching nonsense about the triggering of some symbolic event resulting in mass societal change or utopia (see: Branch Davidians). It always fails spectacularly. Same with ISIS. I wish people would stop trying those strategies, which always harms innocent people caught in between, while the overreaction just feeds into the group's now (self-fulfilled) victim complex which just further adds fuel to their sales pitch to the fringe, creating more conflict and overreaction.
- mindslight 7y agoI was with you until the last bit. Responsibility for the overreaction rests solely on the powerful parties overreacting - USG, mainstream media, out of touch suburbanites, industry working groups, etc. The existence of crazies does not serve as justification for totalitarianism. There's always going to be some perturbation, and a robust system needs to be tolerant of it.
- ganzuul 7y agoNot perhaps solely. If we know something about a threat in advance and we do nothing to stop it from affecting ourselves, then perhaps we are not free from blame.
- mindslight 7y agoSure, but that's an awfully weird nitpick. My comment was attributing blame ostensibly for the purpose of pushing back against the panicking powermongers...