7 ms·
I too wish we could get rid of all the bloat and use the marvelous machines at our fingertips to their full potential. But I seriously doubt that you can write
by adrianN 7y ago
I too wish we could get rid of all the bloat and use the marvelous machines at our fingertips to their full potential. But I seriously doubt that you can write a bloat-free OS that runs on multiple brands of laptops with a bloat-free webbrowser that allows me to read most websites with a small team in reasonable time, no matter how brilliant the people involved are.
- tosh 7y agoI can imagine working on a special purpose machine that streams legacy software in similar to how stadia streams in video games. This might not have been feasible or practical a few years ago.
- toast0 7y agoThis has been feasible and practical several times in the recent past. Serial terminals, Thin clients, X server thin clients, PC Anywhere, VNC, Windows Terminal Server, Citrix whatever it's called, Virtual Desktop Infrastructure, steam link, etc. Office productivity applications have a lot looser latency requirements, and tend to change the screen less frequently than games too. But current solutions are capable of playing videos and some gaming.
- gmueckl 7y agoLet's not forget that there are hacks like old mainframe apps that get accessed through web browsers where the web server is literally just a screen scraping wrapper around the legacy application. Inelegant? Fragile? Crappy to maintain? Yes. But it works.
- AnIdiotOnTheNet 7y agoYou don't need to involve streaming, though that is an option. You could do like we used to do with some personal computers and just have an add-on board that ran some other arch and OS. Between that, virtualization, emulation, and WINE-like compat layers you should be able to run just about anything.
- atemerev 7y agoWell, we already have a database like that. So why not a browser or an OS. Unfortunately, there's only one Arthur Whitney. Other people can emulate his style and genius, but I don't know anybody else who brings this kind of ruthless minimalism to everything they do -- and make it work so well.
- tellme_throwa 7y agoYou have plan9 for OS... And check suckless.org, especially dwm
- RodgerTheGreat 7y agoI think a bloat-free web browser that works with most existing websites is a contradiction in terms. You could have something fairly simple that did the _job_ (jobs?) of a web browser, but it would not be broadly compatible. You could write something broadly compatible, but it would be intrinsically, inescapably very complex. Maybe if we all thought like Arthur we'd just use gopher and be able to write a new client or server from scratch in an afternoon.
- mwcampbell 7y agoLet's add a couple more constraints. The OS and the applications that run on it should be accessible to people with various disabilities and should support a variety of human languages for both input and output. And there are probably more things I'm not thinking of that any widely used platform must have. To be sure, software does have some bloat. But some of the complexity is necessary for software that can be used by the whole world.
- bodi 7y agoMost of the bloat is covering bad or outdated architecture. Imagine starting from scratch with Genode or what Google is doing with their new (3rd) OS.
- Asooka 7y agoGoogle are (only) replacing the kernel. Which I think is the right approach - identify the bits that are holding you back (in this case holding you from taking full control of the os) and replace only those with ones that are as compatible as possible with the existing software.
- bodi 7y agoThey're pretty much designing a whole new OS stack actually. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Google_Fuchsia https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Google_Fuchsia
- bad_luck 7y ago> accessible to people with various disabilities I agree that's important, but I don't think that a great OS should become just a good OS in pursuit of that goal. After the OS is made, it seems like there would absolutely be ways to make the system accessible as-needed.
- AnIdiotOnTheNet 7y agoWe made DOS work with various non-latin languages and for people with disabilities. If DOS can do it, anything can.
- AnIdiotOnTheNet 7y agoAs others have mentioned, a bloat-free web browser is impossible currently because the web itself is far too bloated. However, I'm not convinced that our OSs can't be much, much simpler. You can, almost reasonably, use DOS as a daily driver still. I have very fond memories of DOS because it was simple. Even as late as the early 2000s, if you wanted something like a MAME cabinet you'd often use DOS. You just plop some application and data folders onto a disk with like 4 system files and you were pretty much done. Where is today's DOS? I suppose it's Linux, which is orders of magnitude more complicated (especially once you start talking about a GUI) and even Linus admits it has become quite bloated. I personally think we can do a lot better and I've been toying with the idea of putting something together because I'm just so sick of modern computing's bullshit. PS: If anyone is aware of an organized effort towards this goal that already exists, please let me know.
- meruru 7y agoI'm not sure exactly what you have in mind, but have you considered OpenBSD?
- AnIdiotOnTheNet 7y agoLet me put it this way: if it has a package manager, it's not what I'm looking for.
- meruru 7y agoThat's weird, why wouldn't you want a package manager? That said I think 9front and Redox lack them. Have you considered those?
- AnIdiotOnTheNet 7y agoBecause the purpose of a package manager is to hide complexity that shouldn't exist in the first place.
- 7y ago