3 ms·
I remember several years ago thinking that RedHat was the be-all end-all of user-friendly Linux distros. They were on a nice track back then and I could see the
by dheera 7y ago
I remember several years ago thinking that RedHat was the be-all end-all of user-friendly Linux distros. They were on a nice track back then and I could see them taking the Linux market by storm at one point. Then they started going off into this weird enterprise tangent, and that's about when Ubuntu came in and swept up vast amounts of the market, eventually including a lot of the enterprise folks.
Ubuntu, too, has made some rash decisions at times. They cling to their sluggish developer-unfriendly Unity UI, randomly kicked out ffmpeg from 14.04 for political reasons, among other things. These kinds of rash decisions cost them every single time.
- diegof79 7y agoI understand you. I was a RedHat user during 98-2002. At that time RedHat was the king of Linux desktop, and “the year of Linux desktop” was predicted multiple times. But in retrospective, I think that RedHat did a good move. Where is Mandriva/Mandrake Linux today? Even SuSe which is doing fine, didn’t have the growth of RedHat. It was sad for users hoping for the year of Linux desktop that never materialized; but a good business decision for RedHat.
- dheera 7y agoTo some extent Mac OS X was the "year of the *nix desktop". Not Linux, but it could just easily have been a Linux kernel instead of BSD if they wanted. Android is the Linux phone. 3 billion people are running a Linux kernel in their pocket right now. It did happen, just that it didn't unfold in the way that RedHat users originally imagined.
- pjmlp 7y agoLinux aficionados keep giving Android example. The Linux kernel isn't exposed to app developers, only OEMs writing drivers. Google could switch it for something else tomorrow and beyond Google itself and the driver writers, no else would notice. Same applies to ChromeOS. As for Apple platforms, with each release POSIX APIs become less relevant with Objective-C/Swift/C++ replacements for them. So it is pretty much a pyrrhic victory.
- dheera 7y agoSure, I don't think we should stop at Android. The reason Android and MacOS won market share is because those companies built an ecosystem around it, including hardware, and very importantly the end user never needing to touch the command line. They built a lot of exactly what pure Linux lacks. Ubuntu is pretty far from that. I still have to do quite a bit of command line fuss to setup and maintain my Ubuntu system. Fine for me as a dev, but not fine for mass adoption.
- cwyers 7y agoThat "weird enterprise tangent" is a billion-dollar business, and no matter what the market share is for Ubuntu in the enterprise, the revenue share is very, very much in Red Hat's favor.
- dheera 7y agoAre there numbers on this? I wouldn't be surprised if enterprise Ubuntu support is already the new thing, seeing as so much enterprise-friendly hardware is already very much Ubuntu first. NVIDIA's machine learning products, for example, are mostly designed for Ubuntu, and most server-side stuff these days tends to be released with .deb packages first.
- bryanlarsen 7y agoI wouldn't be so sure of that. Ubuntu gets a cut every time somebody spins up an Ubuntu VPS on AWS. Yes, Red Hat has more revenue, but Red Hat is a lot more than Linux these days.
- simtel20 7y agoHow does Canonical get paid when someone spins up a vm with Ubuntu?
- bryanlarsen 7y agoThe distribution has been slightly modified to work on EC2. The Ubuntu license allows you to do that and still distribute it, but not under the Ubuntu trademark. That's the main reason "Amazon Linux" exists.
- cwyers 7y agohttps://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20250149 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20250149 Red Hat is a lot more than Linux, but that revenue disparity is huge, and I bet they are licensing out RHEL to everybody who buys other stuff from them.