6 ms·
> ... nor should it be. This bit I don't really understand. If someone is interested in X, why would they be ok with carrying around what turns out to (likely
by justinclift 7y ago
> ... nor should it be.
This bit I don't really understand.
If someone is interested in X, why would they be ok with carrying around what turns out to (likely be) incorrect knowledge about it?
That approach is more equated with (say) Wired, who are famously inaccurate in many details "for a good story". eg Wired is entertainment.
That's not what Science (the journal) is supposed to be about though. Or is it?
- Misdicorl 7y agoYes, believing false knowledge is unsettling. But it's unlikely the results in question were that momentous that they stayed with people outside the field. If the results were that, impactful the refuting article would belong in Science.
- jtbayly 7y agoArticles from BBC, CNN blogs, “featured on an episode of NPR’s Hidden Brain podcast,” a video on YouTube from National Geographic (11m subscribers), all since 2012. Lots and lots of people outside the field continue read about this and remember it. Many millions of people. I remember when I first heard about it. I’m not in the field. A notice in Science is at least noteworthy to that same public, even if it still won’t get a fraction of the same coverage. At least people who tried to track down the original research would find the follow up study as well.
- Misdicorl 7y agoThe public and scientific discourses are different and Science/Nature/etc have a target audience firmly in the scientific discourse. Most of the arguments here (and in the slate article) have been talking about Science shirking their scientific duty. They are not. Perhaps you can argue that they owe it to the quality of public discourse to print this article, but they certainly don't owe it to the scientific discourse.