5 ms·
Visualizing temperature change isn't the problem I've ever had with people. It's always been about: "okay, so what does 1.5C mean?" I think what we need to be
by Waterluvian 7y ago
Visualizing temperature change isn't the problem I've ever had with people. It's always been about: "okay, so what does 1.5C mean?"
I think what we need to be using when we talk about climate change are things like projected coastline and population displacement maps.
One of the most powerful facts I've seen recently in Canada was an insurer talking about how some houses simply aren't insurable anymore because they will be flooded again every few years. I want to show people a map of "communities that will be uninsurable by 2050"
- hi5eyes 7y agothe toronto islands properties an example of the very flooding right now
- shitgoose 7y agohouseboat is the solution. i always wanted to get one.
- ianai 7y agoThe book “uninhabitable earth” is good for this. As is his talk on the Chris Hayes podcast. Some key points: 2C means genocide. Entire island nations under water and lost. Every minor increase means exponentially higher costs - many more dead, large swaths of the earth uninhabitable. 4C is something like Hong Kong/Shanghai, and many other parts of th world uninhabitable. Going outside would be fatal within minutes. Here’s a map someone put together for 4C: https://mymodernmet.com/parag-khanna-global-warming-map/ https://mymodernmet.com/parag-khanna-global-warming-map/ At 8C of warming, clouds may be unable to form.
- ianai 7y agoThe majority of emissions have been released in the last 30 years. All human emissions prior to that point are less than the human emissions from that point. People were talking about climate change back then. People decided to burn more oil. The map I included there seems pretty optimistic compared to some others I’ve seen. In a recent paper, “Boaty McBoatface” saw faster wind currents increase ocean churn and aided sea warming faster than expected. I’ve taken this to suggest the current ocean raises predicted are under estimates.
- NeedMoreTea 7y agoThe thing with that map is it's absurdly optimistic, as it implies a world entirely happy to have entire populations of other countries and continents to move into yours. The amount of migration, displacement, rebuilding and major wars that would actually get us to that point is unimaginable. Uninhabitable Earth is terrifying, and convincing. I thought I had a pessimistic outlook on climate until I read that.
- ianai 7y agoI took it as “this is what would have to happen for the least of us to die”. So yes, optimistic. I also think their projected coastlines are optimistic. I don’t remember seeing so much of the US labeled uninhabitable in other discussions.
- Anthony-G 7y agoScarily, much of the regions marked in that map as suitable for food-growing is mountainous or tundra. I wouldn’t be optimistic about its fertility and suitability for agriculture – even with optimal climatic conditions.
- SECProto 7y ago> I want to show people a map of "communities that will be uninsurable by 2050" Relatedly, there was a recent story in CBC [1] pointing out that flood maps are due to get updated next year, and the impact it will have on housing prices. [1] https://www.cbc.ca/news/opinion/flood-plains-1.5135336 https://www.cbc.ca/news/opinion/flood-plains-1.5135336
- southern_cross 7y agoRecent research suggests that flood maps (at least in the US) now and always have understated flood-prone areas by a factor of something like 3x. So those 100-year and 500-year and such flood pronouncements may be equally off, too.
- donjoe 7y agoSimilar to this map? https://ss2.climatecentral.org https://ss2.climatecentral.org
- gmuslera 7y agoPeople must understand that increasing 1.5ºC of yearly average of global temperature is not the same as the increase of 1.5ºC in any particular day in their local city. It is not only not evenly distributed around the world (this chart, and the monthly ones on https://data.giss.nasa.gov/gistemp/maps/index_v4.html https://data.giss.nasa.gov/gistemp/maps/index_v4.html gives a different picture), that is the average could well mean 10+ ºC in their particular area in several given days (this week there was like 40ºC in Poland, and there was over 50ºC in India and Vietnam the previous one) while decrease in others, that is not just how they feel temperature, but also what is affected by it in larger areas (more energy to fuel extreme weather events, including the ones that brings extreme cold), and that the regions with the bigger increase in temperature have also several of the possitive feedback loop factors for increasing the global temperature even more. You don't need 100ºC to get a lethal temperature, with half of that (it is becoming increasingly common), depending on hidration and humidity, a lot of people will die. And you die in a particular place/day, not in a global yearly average, after you are dead doesn't matter if the next week the temperature is bearable. And the food sources that feed billions of people must survive too. And the complex ecosystem that enables that you, and your food sources survive as it is now, even if you are not aware of how something that just got extinct was essential, should survive too.
- taneq 7y agoIt kind of reminds me of when stereo manufacturers stopped using RMS power to rate speakers and instead started using peak power. Suddenly your 50W speakers were 2000W and wow that number was really big. Climate scientists have been using RMS temperatures but it's peak temperatures that people notice.
- DenisM 7y agoI found this to really illustrative of what 1.5 might mean. https://xkcd.com/1732/ https://xkcd.com/1732/ And it's not speculative - it's historical. It shows that decline of 4.5 means basically complete icing of the north North America and puts 1.5 in perspective.
- DanielleMolloy 7y agoIs there a good similar chart for daily or monthly maximum temperatures that one could share instead? As you say, people don't understand the problem about 1.5 degrees increase in average indeed. If temperature regularly exceeds 40°C it will look more threatening to people.
- wdr1 7y ago> Visualizing temperature change isn't the problem I've ever had with people. It's always been about: "okay, so what does 1.5C mean?" That plus a few other things, including how much variance is to be expected?
- MrMember 7y agoThe variance is tricky because of the enormous time range and the huge number of variables. It's also impossible to account for any black swans, positive or negative, that might happen in the next 80 years. We have no idea if some miraculous carbon removing technology will be discovered that saves us all. Or if we're missing some key component to the puzzle and actually we'll be extinct by 2050.