4 ms·
Really? Downvotes? (Come at me bros! I have imaginary Internet points to burn! :) I am not arguing for/against socialism, nor am I arguing for/against particul
by throw0101a 7y ago
Really? Downvotes? (Come at me bros! I have imaginary Internet points to burn! :)
I am not arguing for/against socialism, nor am I arguing for/against particular policies. I am simply saying that Right-leaning politicians have been throwning around "socialism" to the point that in the US, for the general public, it's basically lost its meaning. This has been going on for decades:
* https://www.washingtonpost.com/politics/2019/06/20/republicans-have-been-tying-democrats-socialism-years-trump-is-going-all-tradition/ https://www.washingtonpost.com/politics/2019/06/20/republica...
> In particular, it analyses conservative Republican rhetoric and the strong emphasis associated with the socialist label, especially how the socialist label is employed as a critique against the New Deal and its ongoing political legacy – the modern American welfare state. I compare the difference in how conservative Republicans employ the socialist label in the context of being the majority party, as well as of being the minority party.
* http://discovery.ucl.ac.uk/1482196/ http://discovery.ucl.ac.uk/1482196/
- simonh 7y agoI'm not quite sure what you're saying. Are you arguing that, because some republicans bandy about the term socialism in loose and pejorative ways, that therefore we should feel bound to that definition of Socialism? That seems like a strange argument to make. Why exactly do you want people to 'come at you'?
- throw0101a 7y ago> Are you arguing that, because some republicans bandy about the term socialism in loose and pejorative ways, that therefore we should feel bound to that definition of Socialism? I'm saying that the GOP has thrown around the term "socialism" for so many things that the term has become confusing when it comes to American political discourse. The technical meaning has not changed ("public ownership of the means of productions"), but the day-to-day definition in regular conversion has become next to useless. It's not that one "should feel bound to that definition", but rather one is bound to that definition unless you, in the middle of a conversation, make sure you clarify what you mean by that word. Because otherwise Joe Plumber and you will be talking about two different things, even though both of you would be using the same word. It's kind of like talking about "feminism": it means so many things to so many people that, unless you define terms at the beginning of a conversation/debate, it's probable that folks will be talking about completely different ideas when invoking the word.