3 ms·
To everyone who is saying "that is not socialism" * Please talk to the US Republican Part and tell them to stop lying. When someone (especially a Democrat) br
by throw0101a 7y ago
To everyone who is saying "that is not socialism"
* Please talk to the US Republican Part and tell them to stop lying.
When someone (especially a Democrat) brings up universal healthcare, the GOP says "that's socialism!". When free tuition is brought up: "that's socialism!". Universal daycare: "that's socialism!". Carbon pricing: "socialism!". Higher taxes on upper income to pay for social programs: "socialism!".
The GOP has thrown the word "socialism" around as a boogeyman to the point that it is now meaningless in the US:
* https://www.washingtonexaminer.com/opinion/op-eds/defining-socialism-down https://www.washingtonexaminer.com/opinion/op-eds/defining-s...
This isn't the 1950s anymore.
The problem is not with the author's (Kevin Kelly [1]) use of the word, nor necessarily with the policies that are being proposed by some (left-leaning) politicians, but with the fact that the GOP (as a party) does not participate in US politics in good faith.
* [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kevin_Kelly_(editor) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kevin_Kelly_(editor)
Edit: Case in point, McConnell called granting statehood to D.C. and Puerto Rico “full bore socialism” in a Fox News interview just this week:
* https://www.foxnews.com/politics/mitch-mcconnell-dem-d-c-statehood-full-bore-socialism https://www.foxnews.com/politics/mitch-mcconnell-dem-d-c-sta...
- 0815test 7y agoThe weirdest part is not that Republicans think universal healthcare is socialism; it's that they think that it is, while also thinking that Medicare is not! Remember "keep the government out of my Medicare"?
- throw0101a 7y ago> [...] that Republicans think universal healthcare is socialism. Do the Rs really think that, or do they simply say "socialism!" because they've trained their base and some independents to think (socialism = bad)? Centrailly planned economies generally don't work, and I wouldn't want actual socialism for most things where I live. But if you don't like a particular policy, argue the pros/cons of that policy instead of trying to 'slander' it. A lot of people in the US want affordable health care, and there are various ways to implement that, but if you label them all as "socialism", then people will end up "wanting" socialism.
- toasterlovin 7y agoThis stems mostly, I think, from a confusion about the difference between social democracy and socialism. And, to be fair, plenty of people on the left make the same mistake. I see lots of red roses appended to Twitter usernames. I think most of those people want socialized medicine and safety nets, not socialized control of the means of production. Yet they call themselves socialists.
- throw0101a 7y ago> This stems mostly, I think, from a confusion about the difference between social democracy and socialism. Sure. And my argument/thesis is that this confusion is a deliberate tactic by Right-leaning politicians. McConnell called granting statehood to D.C. and Puerto Rico, “full bore socialism” in a Fox News interview just this week: * https://www.foxnews.com/politics/mitch-mcconnell-dem-d-c-statehood-full-bore-socialism https://www.foxnews.com/politics/mitch-mcconnell-dem-d-c-sta... WTF?
- beatgammit 7y agoWell, it would certainly increase representation for people who support policies that Republicans call "socialist", so the result will be more of those policies. I don't know what "full bore socialism" means to him, but socialism in general has a different definition for politicians than academics. For example, I'd consider the US to be more socialist (in the academic sense) than Scandinavian countries in many ways, yet people like Bernie Sanders use the term to describe policies they'd like to adopt from Scandinavia. Both sides get it wrong, with the right labeling everything they don't like with it, and the left trying to make the term more palatable, yet they both use it completely incorrectly. For some reason, when most people say "communism" they mean "socialism" and when they say "socialism" they mean "progressivism". Likewise for the opposite end of the current spectrum, where by saying "fascism" they mean "nationalism" and/or "protectionism", and by "nationalism" they mean "patriotism". Basically, they'll say whatever will get the biggest emotional impact, even if it's completely false (but has been used similarly in the past).
- 7y ago
- throw0101a 7y agoReally? Downvotes? (Come at me bros! I have imaginary Internet points to burn! :) I am not arguing for/against socialism, nor am I arguing for/against particular policies. I am simply saying that Right-leaning politicians have been throwning around "socialism" to the point that in the US, for the general public, it's basically lost its meaning. This has been going on for decades: * https://www.washingtonpost.com/politics/2019/06/20/republicans-have-been-tying-democrats-socialism-years-trump-is-going-all-tradition/ https://www.washingtonpost.com/politics/2019/06/20/republica... > In particular, it analyses conservative Republican rhetoric and the strong emphasis associated with the socialist label, especially how the socialist label is employed as a critique against the New Deal and its ongoing political legacy – the modern American welfare state. I compare the difference in how conservative Republicans employ the socialist label in the context of being the majority party, as well as of being the minority party. * http://discovery.ucl.ac.uk/1482196/ http://discovery.ucl.ac.uk/1482196/
- simonh 7y agoI'm not quite sure what you're saying. Are you arguing that, because some republicans bandy about the term socialism in loose and pejorative ways, that therefore we should feel bound to that definition of Socialism? That seems like a strange argument to make. Why exactly do you want people to 'come at you'?
- throw0101a 7y ago> Are you arguing that, because some republicans bandy about the term socialism in loose and pejorative ways, that therefore we should feel bound to that definition of Socialism? I'm saying that the GOP has thrown around the term "socialism" for so many things that the term has become confusing when it comes to American political discourse. The technical meaning has not changed ("public ownership of the means of productions"), but the day-to-day definition in regular conversion has become next to useless. It's not that one "should feel bound to that definition", but rather one is bound to that definition unless you, in the middle of a conversation, make sure you clarify what you mean by that word. Because otherwise Joe Plumber and you will be talking about two different things, even though both of you would be using the same word. It's kind of like talking about "feminism": it means so many things to so many people that, unless you define terms at the beginning of a conversation/debate, it's probable that folks will be talking about completely different ideas when invoking the word.
- beatgammit 7y agoIt's like they equate any redistribution of wealth as socialism. Socialism is social ownership of the means of production, not redistribution of wealth (though that's usually a part of it). You can have socialism with unequal redistribution, that's not a fundamental requirement (requirement is that the people are involved in the redistribution process). I'm guessing they use it because the public doesn't really understand the term. It's like "communism" was anything that happened in Asia that related to the USSR and "socialism" is anything the Democrats want that they don't, when it's more correct to say that the stuff that happened in Asia was socialist (under a communist ideology), and the stuff Democrats want is progressive (shifting taxes more toward the rich) as opposed to regressive (shifting taxes more toward the poor). However, "progressive" is too close to "progress" and obviously Republicans don't want to be seen even more as "going backwards", and that's certainly the message you get from the left. I just wish politics focused on the pros and cons of a policy, not on name calling and getting support because the other side is "worse". I like a lot of policies from both sides of the aisle (and likewise hate a lot from both), and I just want to know why a candidate supports a given policy and whether they've put in the time to know whether it would help or hurt their constituents (rather than party image/unity).