4 ms·
So a journal can get a free pass on an obvious violation of scientific ethics just by saying that they're a general issue journal? The field of study has nothi
by pdonis 7y ago
So a journal can get a free pass on an obvious violation of scientific ethics just by saying that they're a general issue journal?
The field of study has nothing to do with it. If a journal publishes a result, they are ethically obligated to publish further work that refutes that result.
- dash2 7y ago“If a journal publishes a result, they are ethically obligated to publish further work that refutes that result.” Too general. Few in science would accept this. The claim here is the weaker one that journals are ethically obliged to accept failed replication studies - and even that is non-obvious to me. (Should Science also be obliged to accept _successful_ replications? No? So it should accept papers on the basis solely of the results? Hello, publication bias.)
- vinay_ys 7y agoAren't they obligated to investigate? If the methodology applied is sound and conclusions are different, isn't that scientific progress in and of itself? The ask here is to send it for peer-review so that they get some different points of view which may guide their own further study. They are ok with rejection but not without peer-review.
- Hasknewbie 7y agoNice attempt at reframing there, but if this new paper is correct then it's not a 'failed replication', it's a refutation. Big difference.
- londons_explore 7y agoA middle ground could exist here... Rather than publish the entire paper, they could publish the single sentence: > Issue 55, Page 8, the paper we published has been replicated with more data, and results do not support the original research conclusions. See paper entitled "Foo" published in "other journal" for details.
- Misdicorl 7y agoRefutations and competing null results get published in different journals all the time. Seminal results get shown to be kind of not seminal 10 years later more often than you might think. > If a journal publishes a result, they are ethically obligated to publish further work that refutes that result. This isn't a violation of scientific ethics and I think its a silly argument to make. Journals aren't the parents of research results they publish and somehow responsible for all counter arguments or competing data points.