4 ms·
I hope the Coreboot people are extremely careful about this. Accepting code from a giant agency with the goal of making everyone less safe is very dangerous.
by mort96 7y ago
I hope the Coreboot people are extremely careful about this. Accepting code from a giant agency with the goal of making everyone less safe is very dangerous.
- kbenson 7y agoThe same was said of selinux. I think perhaps the NSA is slightly more complicated with more complex goals than you describe.
- lugg 7y agoAre people really so quick to forget? https://www.miracl.com/press/backdoors-in-nist-elliptic-curves https://www.miracl.com/press/backdoors-in-nist-elliptic-curv... Their goals are at the very least nationalist. As a non US citizen why should I trust them at all? Their main directive errodes my privacy on most levels in most sense of the words.
- kbenson 7y agoAll I said is that they may have complex goals, while pointing out selinux was also contributed primarily by them. I take it that means your position is that they only contribute code for the purpose of exploiting people for national security, and selinux is also suspect?
- mort96 7y agoI mean, being primarily contributed by the NSA is a great reason to not use SELinux, especially if you're outside of the US. AppArmor exists and does a lot of the same job, so why not use the safer option?
- closeparen 7y agoThey're a spy agency, they're presumably capable of not signing their work.
- ENOTTY 7y agoThe chief problem with AppArmor is that its primary mechanism of identifying objects in the system (to which relevant policy rules are applied) relies on paths. In Linux, paths are not usable as strong identifiers because Linux provides a variety of ways to alias those objects. Additionally, some objects that deserve scrutiny from a mandatory access control perspective don't map cleanly to paths.
- ganzuul 7y agoHas that changed? A decade ago when I looked at their charter they were supposed to strengthen security; not weaken it.
- mankeysee 7y agolmao at trusting their "charters" to gauge their real aims
- AmericanChopper 7y agoTheir two missions are Signals Intelligence and Information Assurance. The contributions they make to security technology and standards are going to be equally as effective no matter what country you’re a citizen of. If you think the work they release is motivated by an intention to compromise your security, then you must also believe they are trying to do the same thing to the US federal government. A goal which hardly seems very nationalist.
- lugg 7y agoBoth of those missions are at odds with improving security. Try harder.
- AmericanChopper 7y agoInformation Assurance is not at odds with improving security. It is literally the NSAs mandate to improve the security of the federal government (and other US entities). You’re making an assumption that in order to gather signals intelligence, that they need to trick people into using compromised cryptography. A fact that is not in dispute is that huge portions of the US federal government implement NSA recommendations and standards. For your assumption to be true, the NSA must be intentionally weakening federal systems. Nothing about that seems nationalistic to me.
- cf498 7y agoDid you already forget how long they knew of EternalBlue instead of immediately forcing patches?
- dehrmann 7y agoThe NSA's track record here is mixed, so I'm not sure how to feel. They actually improved the design of DES. > Bruce Schneier observed that "It took the academic community two decades to figure out that the NSA 'tweaks' actually improved the security of DES."
- lugg 7y agoAll they did was make sure breakable-by-them encryption was in use much longer than it should have been. I'd hardly call it a mixed track record. > However, the NSA also ensured that the key size was drastically reduced such that they could break it by brute force attack. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Data_Encryption_Standard https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Data_Encryption_Standard
- mort96 7y agoI got curious and found the post you were referring to (https://www.schneier.com/blog/archives/2004/10/the_legacy_of_d.html https://www.schneier.com/blog/archives/2004/10/the_legacy_of...). They tweaked the algorithm, and that tweak turned out to make it more secure; they also cut the key size by more than half, making sure they could brute force it. That doesn't exactly scream benevolence.
- anfilt 7y agoIt could also be the NSA does not trust proprietary firmware for similar reasons people are working on open source firmware to begin with. The problem is NSA really only knows their motives. The other problem with the NSA is that they have two goals. One is to protect the US and US entities security and the other is subvert foreign entities. If they start publicy recommending coreboot for what they deem senstive installations then their intentions are obviously not malicous. Problem is the NSA may never publicy specify that its for senstive installtions and may only ever be an internal guideline.
- rincebrain 7y agoIt's worth noting that it's even worse than that - some of the NSA employees contributing might not be aware of the motives involved if any are concealed.
- ganzuul 7y agoFrom what I have read of how compartmentalized that organization is; could be no ill intent exists for now. Later however, the knowledge they gain could be used for a different purpose.
- AsyncAwait 7y ago> no ill intent exists for now. Later however, the knowledge they gain The thing is, if there's no ill intent now, there shouldn't be any backdoor to allow them to have any sort of special knowledge later. Unless you mean familiarity with the codebase in general. If they however do insert a backdoor, even without using it for anything now, "just in case", than that in itself is ill intent.
- ganzuul 7y agoI do mean familiarity. Also, there is connections with other people in the project.
- mort96 7y ago
- neilv 7y agoIf there's a concern about that, then maybe some other governments should be paying people to be intimately involved with projects like Coreboot, Linux, GNU, open hardware, etc. -- such that those people are spending enough time that they can understand and keep an eye on things, as well as furthering the projects with their more conventional contributions. (I know Coreboot has had at least a few people who seem to be activists or enthusiasts who are not potentially beholden to anyone, but people getting paid can afford to spend much more time on projects than volunteers can.)
- garmaine 7y agoI won’t be an NSA apologist because in the last 20 years they have in fact made everyone less safe with their undermining of open standards. But for the purpose of accuracy it should be pointed out that one of the two missions of the NSA is to safeguard American commerce, which they did for many decades prior (see: DES, selinux, etc.).